My Magnus Archive fic rec list!
(I have a surprisingly hard time finding fics that actually portray Jon's asexuality. But I love when it is actually mentioned so)
and they were roommates! by abeebumbling
In which the Archives do not have a spare room, but Jon's flat does (much to Martin's dismay).
I give this fic a solid 10/10! It was adorable and awkward and felt very much in character for these two idiots. They are very precious to me and OH MY GOD JON BEING SUPER SHORT IS MY FAVORITE I LOVE HIM BEING MY HEIGHT!
Waking Up at the Start of the Beginning of the World by thelocaldogooder
Jon and Martin wake up after Everything. Takes place after the events of mag 200 with Jon and Martin waking up in the cabin. Oliver likes to pay back favors and Jon not killing him was a big one.
I fuckin can't with this one. 100/10 Tugs the heartstrings. I finished tma almost a year ago and I still cry when I listen to mag 200. I am claiming this as canon because it should be and nothing else will make me feel better.
Break Me Like A Pattern by TheLibraryBat
The year is 2011. Michael Shelley is living his life in circles, blissfully unaware of the betrayal that awaits him in the summer. Gertrude Robinson has plans to enact and plans to destroy. Emma Harvey is hiding a book in the dark place at the back of a cupboard. When Gerard Keay walks into the Magnus Institute - two years sooner than he was meant to - everything changes. This is an (eventual) Archivist Michael AU, exploring how certain events might have played out, had one key player been in the wrong place at the wrong time. WARNING THAT THIS DOES CONTAIN THE MILD, UNDISCRIPTIVE SMUT.
1000/10 I know it isn't Jonmartin, but this one is my favorite. Gerry and Michael are my two favorite lesser characters and I love anything with original Michael Shelley. Don't worry about the ages or plotlines from the podcast. Og Jonathan Sims was wrong about those anyways. What does he know?
Death Is The Easy Way Out by traveller19
After having killed Jonah Magnus and ended the Change, Jon and Martin should finally be able to rest. Rest, however, proves impossible when Jon falls ill. What's more, he begins having vivid dreams of their dead friends - Tim, trapped in the destroyed Archives, and Sasha, trapped outside of them. As Jon's condition quickly worsens and the line between dream and reality begins to blur, love is all he and Martin have to hold on to, because hope is a dangerous thing.
*inhales deeply and exhales loudly* 10/10 This one got me good, guys. I'm a sucker for Jon being in pain and actually accepting help. Also Jon and Martin not being dead makes me happy :)
What Once Was Mine by Dieanywhereelse
12/? chapter (unfinished)
Martin was tired of Strangers wearing his friends' faces. Wearing his face. Still, it was nothing a gun couldn't solve. Or, the Scottish Safe house gets a few visitors from the past. Jon and Martin get a chance to set things right. You've heard of Time Travel AU. You've heard of Scottish Safehouse period. May I interest you in a combination of both?
GUNMARTIN SUPREMACY!! 9/10 Due to it being unfinished :( I know! I know! Unfinished fics suck and all but this one is so good that I don't even care that it's unfinished! (well I do because I wanna read more of it) Martin getting a gun is something that makes me so giddy. Also Jon being seen as the village cryptid/fairy is so funny to me but it also just fits him so well. Has some mild themes about suicidal thoughts(?) technically. Does it count if you want to kill your past self as your future self? Idk. ALSO POLYARCHIVES AND ALL OF THEM BEING ACESPEC AND SASHA HAVING VERY RELATABLE NEGATIVE THOUGHTS ABOUT HER OWN AROSPEC-NESS MY BELOVEDS<3
but i can't do this alone anymore by abeebumbling
âNow,â Martin says, his voice softer but still firm. âDo you have any more ridiculous requests or can you leave?â And for some ungodly reason, as if Jon hadnât given him enough trouble, he lifts his head, looks at Martin, and says: âCan I kiss you?â Based off Jonny calling MAG 154 the "lets gouge our eyes out and make out" episode.
10/10 I do not have a soft spot for adorable yet mildly sad Jonmartin fics. What are you talking about?
I personally love ones like these where they take an actual episode and tweek it just a little bit; one decision made differently, one thing said or done that wasn't originally said or done. Also this author's writing is just *chefs kiss* Highly recommended (by me)
in a different world with different eyes by abeebumbling
A little later, Jon and Martin wake up somewhere else.
"Another post-MAG 200 fic?" you might ask. "Another fic by abeebumbling? " you may ponder. Yes. Because I love both dearly at this point. 9/10 because I wasn't 100% sure how they survived, but they did and it was adorable.
No disclosure, I am a monster by FNaFlifestyle
âYou want to what?â Martin asked incredulously. âI want to become a teacher,â Jon sighed. After the end of the world, Jon takes up a teaching position at a secondary school, and encounters a group of very cryptid curious teens. As their investigation on their new English teacher advances, Sam, Nat, Oliver and Ash experience some unintended consequences- realising something deeper may be at work.
10/10 I will say I usually HATE fics with oc's, but this one just does it so well and I have no clue why this one is so so good when most of them aren't but it has pulled me in by the ankles and I have become attached to these children (especially Oliver) in the same way I got attached to regular characters of the podcast! Also, Jon as just a tired, grumpy, creepy, weird teacher who just happens to know everyones names on the first day and who seems to know everything going on in the classroom is something that I didn't know I needed until now. (Now that I think about it, he kinda brought these students suspicions upon himself by being so damn weird. There isn't much Martin which is sad, but with as much as is going on, he would probably be drowned out anyways sadly enough :( I literally just got off of the ao3 page for the last episode as I am typing this out. I needed to share it.
leaves too high to touch (roots too strong to fall) by OllieoftheBeholder
âSo...youâre from the future. In the past. Why?â âYou want the short answer or the long one?â âShort,â Martin says after a momentâs deliberation. âUntil I decide if I trust you.â The other nods, as if he expected that answerâwhich, well, if he really is Martin from the future, he probably did. âTo stop the world from ending.â
They have one last chance to fix this - one last chance to prevent the Eyepocalypse, to save the world - to save their world. It all hinges on which is the greater force: greed...or love.
Fuuuuuuuuuuck This one has me by the ankles still and it won't let me goooooooo! 1000000/10 I loved it all. Time travel fics are the cherry on top of the cake. The Jonmartin in this from the Primes (lol) and the Jon-Tim-Martin from the past selves is so gooood. The characters are all so in-character it feels like it's actually them! I highly, highly recommend this one.
the heart goes nine by elfentruthed
âBecause youâre stressed. And so am I,â he replied. He twisted to reach into his satchel, then pulled out a corkscrew. âAnd I donât know about you, but relaxing is all but impossible for me, so once in a while itâs nice to cheat and get some help with it. Usually I just sit and unwind with it at home, but I figuredâŠâ He reached out and offered the corkscrew to Martin. The universeâs strangest olive branch. âUnless youâre opposed?â Jonâs question was not a challenge, nor was it laced with any suggestion of expectation. It was just clarification; an offer to back out if Martin truly was uncomfortable with the prospect of getting wine-drunk with Jon. It's been about a week since Martin temporarily moved into the archives, and between the fear caused by Prentiss and the confusion caused by Jon suddenly being a bit nicer, he's been a bit flustered. This has not gone unnoticed by Jon, who is nothing if not someone who tries to take initiative.
10/10 Just read it. Just do it. It's so utterly adorable the way they act in this and drunk-Jon is something I NEVER thought I needed until now. He is precious. Also, this is probably the first fic I have read where Martin is discovering his feelings instead of already knowing how he feels. It's so pure. T^T
I read so many fics that I gave nobody to share with, so there will likely be another one of these lol. Have fun reading these! <3