Torn
Pairings: JJ Maybank x Good girl!reader, Rafe Cameron x Good girl!reader.
Warnings: Mentions of smut. (Doesn’t happen though, other than a kiss)
A/N:
1.3k words.
Requests: Open. Masterlist
Summary: Y/N and JJ’s feelings for each other grow as they spend a day out on the HMS pogue with their friends.
Part 1, Part 2, Part 3, Part 4, Part 5
Part 6 -JJ
“I looked into your eyes and found my favorite color.”
You woke the next morning to your head on JJ’s chest with his arm wrapped around your back.
He was still sleeping peacefully.
You looked up at him with tired eyes and smiled.
You admired the way the sunlight illuminated his face.
It was like he was glowing.
A golden aurora surrounding him.
“Don’t you know it’s creepy to watch someone sleep.” You heard JJ say.
You snapped out of your daydream to see JJ’s eyes still closed, but a big smiled was plastered on his face.
“Sorry.” You mumbled, looking away as your face heated up.
He opened his eyes, chuckling at the way you got embarrassed for being caught staring at him.
“It’s ok, I like this stalker.” He teased, as he brought his other hand to your face, turning you to look at him.
“Stalker is a little exaggerated, don’t you think?” You teased back. Giggling at the way he tried not to laugh.
“C’mere” he said, as he grabbed you into a tight hold and started tickling you.
You laughed loudly.
“JJ!- JJ stop it!” You said in between fits of laugher.
“Not until you claim that you’re my stalker!” JJ teased, as he tickled you more.
“Ok! Ok! I’m your stalker!” You laughed.
He stopped tickling you but didn’t let you out of his grip.
You laughed. “Stop it!” You said, as you pushed at his chest as he laid there smiling at you.
“Did you just try to push me? Didn’t feel a thing.” He teased.
You huffed as you swatted at his arm.
“You’re gonna have a hard time trying to get out of my iron grip. I’m. Not. Letting. Go.” JJ said, pulling you in even closer.
You giggled at his actions.
“Are you two awake?” You heard a voice at the door. John B.
“No. Dead asleep.” JJ called back.
You tired not laughing at his sarcasm.
“Very funny. Get up, we’re going out on the boat for the day.” John B said, as you heard him walk away.
JJ was silently scowling John B. He didn’t want to get out of bed and let you go.
He could stay there for eternity and never get enough of you.
“Are we gonna get up Maybank?” You asked, rubbing his arm as JJ had his head buried into your neck.
He smiled.
“No. I’m gonna hold us here forever.” JJ mumbled.
“Come on.” You said, laughing, as you shoved him harder.
He budged, letting you go.
You got up and walked over to your bag, grabbing some clothes and a bathing suit.
JJ stayed in bed, watching you.
He was lost in a daydream when he felt something hit him in the head.
You threw his hat at him as you had called his name 3 times and he didn’t answer.
“Hey!” He said, as he grabbed his red hat, running a hand through his messy hair before putting it on.
You laughed as you walked over to the bathroom to get changed.
-
JJ got up, grabbing a shirt, and throwing it on as he headed out of the room.
John B and Pope were there.
Pope raised his eyebrow as he looked at JJ, John B was trying not to laugh.
JJ rolled his eyes as he walked past them.
“Soooo,” Pope said, making sure to drag out the ‘o’
“Soooo,” JJ mocked.
“How was last night?” Pope teased.
JJ looked over at him, he wanted to act annoyed, but a smile spread across his face.
“No way!” John B exclaimed.
“He’s falling in love with her!” Pope exclaimed.
“This can’t be! JJ Maybank finally settling down!” John B teased.
“Shut up! She might hear!” JJ said, quickly moving closer to his friends.
“He didn’t deny it!” Pope gasped.
“Ooooo!” John B said.
John B and Pope laughed while JJ rolled his eyes at his friends. That’s when he heard the door open
The three boys froze, looking to you.
“I’m ready” You walked out. All three pairs of eyes landing on you.
“What were you guys talking about?” You asked, as they were all looking at you with wide eyes.
“Math.” Pope said,
“Fishing.” John B said,
“The boat.” JJ said.
All three of them said three different things at the same time.
“Right.” You nodded your head confused as you looked at them.
“Yeah. We’re really switching between topics.” JJ laughed, a hand reaching to the back of his neck as he scratched it.
You nodded, not giving it much thought as you thought it was just some stupid guy talk.
You walked out the door and made your way down to the boat.
-
You sat on the boat with JJ, watching your friends laughing and splashing each other in the water.
You smiled looking at them having fun, it made you happy seeing them be happy.
JJ was staring at you.
He smiled while admiring you. He loved the way the sun made your skin look like it glowed.
Just like you were sun-kissed.
He admired the way you smiled and laughed lightly watching your friends have fun.
It was giving him butterflies with how beautiful you looked.
He couldn’t believe it, but JJ Maybank knew he was falling in love with you.
You turned to look at him.
“What?” You asked, playfully shoving his arm as you caught him looking at you.
He laughed at your gesture.
“Nothing.” He said, looking down and smiling at his hands.
“Oh, come on! Tell me!” You complained, moving closer to him.
He turned to look you dead in the eyes.
“You’re the most beautiful girl I’ve ever seen.” He said.
You blushed at his words.
JJ moved his hand to your face to brush a piece of loose hair behind your ear.
Your eyes locked on his lips, and he noticed.
He leaned in slowly, waiting to see if you’d do the same.
And you did.
Just inches apart, if you spoke your lips would have touched.
You could feel his breath on you and it so desperately made you want to close the gap between the two of you.
That’s when JJ filled the space between you two and pressed his lips into yours.
Your lips moved together as one, as desire filled through you.
If it weren’t for your friends in the water shouting “Oooo! They’re kissing! Guys! Look!” JJ wouldn’t have been able to control himself.
You pulled back from him, heat flooded your cheeks from both the kiss and your friends.
You peered over at them, and they were all clapping.
You blushed and turned back to JJ, who couldn’t take his eyes off of you.
You smiled at him, feeling warm inside. Butterflies exploding in your stomach.
JJ leaned in closer to you, whispering in your ear. “If they weren’t here right now, I wouldn’t have stopped.” He said in a low raspy voice.
It caught you completely off guard. Your cheeks heated up so much and you swear the butterflies in your stomach were doing cartwheels.
You looked at him with wide eyes, so shocked by his comment.
He laughed watching your expression.
You had to get away from him, your friends were still laughing, and JJ was making you all flustered.
You walked to the side of the boat and jumped into the water.
The water was slightly cold, making the heat in your cheeks go away.
JJ was quick to follow in after you, scoffed at him as he splashed you with water.
-
Your friends all laughed and talked, climbing back on the boat, and heading home.
You couldn’t stay focused on any of their conversations.
The only thing you could think of was JJ’s comment.
You couldn’t stop thinking about how much you wished your friends weren’t there in that moment.
You really wanted more to happen with JJ.
The only thing you heard was about a party they were going to throw tomorrow, maybe that’d be your chance to see where that moment from earlier with JJ would lead to.
