While I recognize the irony in opening with the statement that that this is not a fully-thought-through idea, there's a concept that's been chewing at the edges of my brain and I'm going to try to write it out to help formalize it. And if anyone wants to "Yes, and..." or "no, that's not it" to help refine it, please jump in.
The concept that's been going in my head is that "Right and Left" isn't really an effective mechanism to map the current political landscape, not anymore.
Instead, what I'm observing is a large scale movement of various flavors of authoritarian autocrats and their supporters, engaged in alliances of convenience and mutual benefit, whose worldviews are not "reality-based"--they're fundamentally founded on vibes/propaganda/ideology. But they recognize each other as fellow authoritarians, and while they're certainly willing to fight each other, they're more concerned with squashing "centrist liberals"--principled democratic technocrats who are concerned with such things as "facts", "rule of law", and "consistent ideological principles".
The autocrats come in a variety of flavors--Kleptocrats like Trump and Putin, Islamist theocrats like the IRGC and associated, Strasserites and Stalinists like Western Leftists and the DSA, or just good old-fashioned absolute monarchists like Crown Prince Suliman in Saudi Arabia or the leaders of Qatar and the UAE. They all have more in common with each other when it comes to their authoritarianism and rejection of factual reality, and it's why you get things like DSA members in the US finding it easier to engage with people like Trump than centrists (yes, I'm singling out Mamdani for his interactions with the Orange One here).
And from my perspective, it's terrifying just how many of those groups specifically blame The Jews in one form or another for everything wrong in the world.
This really does hit on why I describe myself as an anti authoritarian first politically. Because autocrats are more willing to work with each other to crush any chance of freedom for humanity as a whole than actually sticking to their principles. I first noticed this in my union organizing days when the entire group tore itself apart over russia's invasion of Ukraine. All these die hard anti imperialists flocked to the russian side because NATO evil don't ya know.
They've only gotten worse and more extreme with time and I've found myself increasingly alone in trying to stick to principles like invading other nations is bad. Massacring random people just trying to go about their day is bad. Terrorism is bad (whether it's Left, Right, Islamist, other flavours)
Then there's the Jewhate that you've mentioned which everyone seems to be adding to their repitoire now, even though Jews are just fucking people who deserve to live in peace. It's utterly fucking exhausting explaining to people online and in real life that no, they don't control the world, and no Israel didn't do that thing you just don't read enough actual media or read widely enough to get all the facts.













