What are your thoughts now given that the Gaza War is largely over?
that it was never about gaza. not really.
if it was about gaza. if gaza was so terrible. if i truly believed my actions had consequences, that people in power might listen to me.
fuck. i'd do anything to have even the slightest chance of stopping it. i'd demand the hostages go back, because sure, it's probably all a lie. sure, it's probably just an excuse. but what if it isn't?
what if I could have stopped a genocide, and I didn't, because I was so convinced it was a bluff? that they wouldn't stop when the hostages were returned? how would I be able to live with myself, knowing that?
(and is the return of the hostages really so horrible on its own?)
if it was about gaza (if it was about human suffering it wouldn't have focused on gaza. two million people is a lot but it's not so much, there are eight billion people in the world, in the first six months of 2025 more children starved to death in one state of nigeria, than people starved to death in two years of the gaza war). if it was about the well-being of gazans. then I'd beg and plead for a ceasefire. for a pause. then I'd demand that there be some sort of asylum program, and wouldn't reject out of hand Israel's (alleged) proposal to transfer the population, because sure, it's not good. it's awful.
But when your choice is leaving behind your life, or facing genocide--well, Jews are experts in that choice. you leave. you say goodbye and you hope to one day come back and you get the hell out. if you care about the risk of genocide, you don't beg america to close ellis island. if you care about the risk of genocide, you don't plead for the st. louis to be sent back simply because you refuse to bow. because in a genocide, there aren't easy choices. yeah, these people are being forced out of their homes. yeah, it's unfair. yeah, it's awful.
do you want to negotiate with the genociders? no. no, you really, really, don't. you hate it. you grit your teeth and you do your best to save as many people as you can and you go home and you wash your hands and you feel so very very guilty and you worry about the people you couldn't save and the agreements you're getting into and god you hate this life. but. at the end of the day. you'll have saved lives.
what does it say about them, that they value martyrs more than mothers? value propaganda more than peace? that to avoid the taint of working with who they may genuinely believe to be genociders, they will take the risk of condemning two million people to death?
the haavara agreement sucked. it was terrible. but. at the end of the day, it saved jewish lives. at the end of the day, jews that would have been killed, weren't. and what's your reputation, in comparison to that? what could possibly be worth giving it up? some imagined moral purity?
now that the gaza war has ended, we can see clearer than ever that they don't care about gazans. they never did. they just wanted to be able to kill us with impunity. to cheer on our deaths. to have an excuse for saying that they were good to want the (((zios))) to die.