So, watching Rise of Skywalker again made me think of and dream of what could have happened. I absolutely loved The Force Awakens, though I acknowledge that people had criticisms. But Episodes VIII and IX just disappointed and frustrated me so much. I'm mainly going to be talking about things specifically in IX and in the trilogy overall, though.
I really wished that Poe hadn't had being a former spice runner added to his backstory. He is one of my favorite Star Wars characters and I feel like this just came out of nowhere and didn't fit. For me, Poe never was a spice runner. He grew up being around his mom Shara learning about her service to the Rebel Alliance and how to fly from her. Her and his dad Kes, who was also a rebel, inspired him and led him to joining the Resistance without any divergence.
Finn's story is just so disappointing. He started off having so much potential with him purposefully disobeying orders from Phasma, freeing Poe, and helping Rey and the Rebellion. I love his relationship and connection with Rey, whether that could have been romantic or stayed deeply platonic. There was so much potential of having a former stormtrooper as part of the trilogy's main trio. His knowledge of Starkiller base was vital to destroying it. I would have loved to see more of that. To me, it felt like he didn't get developed that much after Force Awakens. I wanted more than just his drive to save Rey, like when he told Jannah that he didn't execute his orders because it was the right thing to do. Maybe that was because of the timeline of when the each movie took place in addition to inconsistent storytellers. I just would have loved to see more about him in general, including his possible force connection. I did love seeing him and Poe being generals together though, so that was a plus of IX.
I know that someone who has more experience, education, and proper insight could do a much better job than me analyzing, talking, and explaining the racial connotations of Finn's character, storyline, or lack there of. That should be taken into consideration, thought about, and discussed. So, I will try to not overstep, and if I have, I apologize profusely.
I also really really really really really don't like the Kylo Ren and Rey romantic relationship at all. It doesn't make any sense to me that Rey would fall for someone who had kidnapped her, had forced his way into her mind, killed someone she was starting to connect with (Han), and then seriously injury her friend (Finn). Kylo Ren said she was nothing, except to him, even though that wasn't true at all. To me, that isn't a healthy basis for romantic relationships. Instead, I would have loved for Rey to be Ben's twin. It would have paralleled Luke and Leia being twins and would have made some sense since twins run in families. They could have been dyad in the force. They would be the grandchildren of Anakin/Vader and the children of Leia, both who are really powerful. Them being twins would also work for the connections that were shown in VIII and IX, if that would still fit. So, I could only imagine how powerful they would be. Plus, it would reference Legends where Han and Leia had Jacen and Jaina. It would also help explain the looks from Han and Luke, the hug from Leia, and Chewie liking her. It could also help explain why Luke's (Anakin's) lightsaber called to her. I just feel like this storyline might have made me feel better about the last two movies of the Sequels. This would lead her open to possibly being in a romantic relationship with a better person if that would have served the story in the right way.
My other preferences would have been for Rey to be Luke's daughter or have had parents not connected to anybody already in canon, leading her to choose the Skywalker name, like she did in IX. I'm a huge fan of chosen family!
Anyway, thanks to anybody who has read through this entire thing. Just wanted to get it off my chest. 😅😅😅