Summary: They broke up a long time ago. Azzi told herself not to go back, not after everything. But she can’t resist Paige Bueckers.
A/N: hi hi i’m sorry for the late chapter i had a crazy week but we’re kinda making some progress!
A Couple Minutes Masterlist
Azzi changed outfits four times.
The first one looked too casual.
The second looked like she was trying too hard.
The third made her feel like she was dressing for someone else entirely.
By the time she stood in front of her bedroom mirror in black jeans, a fitted cream top, and a light jacket, her bed was covered in rejected clothes and her nerves had settled somewhere high in her throat.
She stared at her reflection.
A girl she liked talking to.
Nothing to feel guilty about.
Azzi looked toward the bedroom door as though Paige might somehow be standing on the other side of it.
Paige was two floors below.
Paige had ended things with Maya.
Paige had said her heart wasn’t in it.
Azzi had spent half the night pretending those things weren’t connected.
Her phone buzzed on the dresser.
Riley: Downstairs whenever you’re ready. No rush.
Of course Riley was early.
Azzi grabbed her purse, checked herself in the mirror one last time, then walked toward the door before she could change again.
The elevator arrived quickly.
Azzi stepped inside and pressed the lobby button. As the doors closed, her eyes drifted automatically to sixteen.
Tonight was not about Paige.
Riley stood near the front entrance in dark jeans and a green button-down with the sleeves rolled to her elbows. Her curls were down tonight, falling around her shoulders, and the nervous smile on her face made something warm unfold in Azzi’s chest.
Azzi slowed, her head tilted. “Okay what?”
“You look…” Riley paused, apparently searching for the right word. “Very distracting.”
Azzi laughed, the tension easing from her shoulders. “That sounds like a complaint.”
“It is absolutely not a complaint.” Riley held out a small bouquet.
Soft yellow and white blooms wrapped in brown paper.
Azzi stopped. “You brought me flowers?”
Riley’s confidence slipped for the first time. “Too much?”
“No. They’re beautiful.” She said quickly. “Thank you.
Riley released a breath. “Good. I almost left them in the car because I panicked.”
“You panic a lot for someone who acts very smooth.”
“It’s a carefully constructed image.”
Riley opened the building door for her. “Ready?”
Azzi glanced once toward the elevators behind her.
Two floors above the lobby, Paige stood in her kitchen holding the same glass of water she had poured ten minutes earlier.
Her apartment was too quiet.
Paige had turned on the television, but the volume was low and she had no idea what was playing. She had opened her laptop, stared at film from training camp for less than five minutes, and closed it again.
She had cleaned the kitchen counter.
Now she stood near the window, telling herself she was not waiting to see Azzi leave.
Azzi was going on a date.
Paige had no claim on her.
No reason to care what time she left, where she went, or when she came home.
Headlights moved along the street below.
Paige’s eyes tracked each car anyway.
Riley held the passenger door of a small dark car open while Azzi stood beside it with flowers in her hand.
Paige’s grip tightened around the glass. “Fuck.”
Azzi said something that made Riley laugh.
Then Riley leaned closer, brushing her fingers lightly against Azzi’s elbow as she guided her into the car.
Water spilled over the edge of the glass and onto her hand.
“Jesus Christ,” she muttered.
She set it down too hard on the counter.
For a few seconds, she stared at the puddle spreading across the stone.
Then she grabbed a towel and wiped it up, jaw clenched.
She had broken things off with Maya because leading her on had been wrong.
That didn’t mean Azzi would come back.
It didn’t mean Azzi should come back.
Paige had made that clear when she ended things.
Paige had no right to resent her for it.
That didn’t stop the jealousy from spreading hot and ugly through her chest.
Paige picked up her phone.
Opened her messages with Nika instead.
The response came almost immediately.
Nika: Depends. Is this basketball busy or emotional crisis busy?
Paige stared at the message.
Paige: Neither. Azzi crisis.
Nika: So emotional crisis.
Paige threw her phone onto the couch.
She let it ring twice before answering.
Nika laughed. “Hello to you too.”
“Which is Paige language for ‘please call before I make a bad decision.’”
Paige sat on the edge of the couch. “I’m not going to make a bad decision.”
“Good. What decision aren’t you making?”
Paige rubbed her palm against her thigh.
Nika went quiet for half a second.
Paige frowned. “Don’t say it like that, bruh.”
“Like you feel bad for me.”
“Well, that’s convenient, because I’m doing it for free.”
Paige leaned back and stared at the ceiling. “She had flowers.”
Nika’s voice softened. “She brought her flowers?”
Paige closed her eyes. “Apparently.”
Paige sat up. “Whose side are you on?”
Nika laughed. “There are no sides. You broke up with Azzi.”
“You ended things with Maya because you’re still in love with Azzi.”
Paige’s face tightened. “I didn’t say that.”
Nika sighed. “Paige, I’m your best friend. You didn’t need to.”
Paige looked toward the window.
The car was long gone now.
“What if she really likes Riley?”
“Then she really likes her.”
Paige’s throat closed around the answer.
Nika sighed gently. “Paige, you don’t get to want Azzi frozen in place while you figure yourself out.”
“Then why do you sound like someone just told you she’s getting married?”
“Because it feels like every time she takes one step away from me, I realize how far I pushed her.”
The words came out before Paige could stop them.
Paige pressed her lips together, eyes burning.
Nika’s voice was quieter when she spoke again. “Then maybe stop hiding.”
Paige laughed bitterly. “And say what? That I ended things because I loved her too much, but seeing her with someone else makes me want to throw up? That’ll sound really healthy.”
“You could start with the truth.”
“The truth doesn’t fix what I did.”
“No,” Nika said. “But lying about not caring guarantees nothing changes.”
Paige looked down at her hands.
“I want her to have a good time,” she whispered.
“I just don’t want her to have a better time with Riley than she ever had with me.”
Nika groaned. “That is deeply embarrassing.”
Paige covered her face with one hand. “I know.”
Riley took Azzi to a small Italian restaurant tucked between a bookstore and a flower shop. It wasn’t fancy. It was warm.
Candles flickered in little glass holders on the tables. Strings of lights crossed the ceiling. The walls were covered in framed photos and handwritten notes from customers.
Riley had reserved a booth near the back.
“You planned this,” she said as they sat down.
Riley picked up her menu. “I told you. Carefully constructed smooth image.”
Azzi smiled. “You also brought flowers.”
Riley looked embarrassed. “Maybe.”
That was what surprised her most.
Riley asked about training camp but didn’t turn it into an interview. She wanted to know which drill Azzi hated most and which teammate had the worst music taste. She told Azzi stories about customers who ordered impossible drinks and one man who had tried to pay with arcade tokens.
Azzi laughed until her cheeks hurt.
For almost an hour, she barely thought about Paige.
Then Riley asked, “So how are you liking the building?”
Azzi’s smile faded slightly.
“That sounded convincing.”
Azzi looked down at her plate. “It is nice. It’s just complicated.”
Riley took a sip of water. “Because of Paige?”
Riley lifted one shoulder. “I have internet access.”
“I’m sorry,” Riley said. “I wasn’t trying to bring her up.”
“You don’t have to explain anything.”
Azzi traced the edge of her napkin with one finger.“We were together,” she said.
Riley nodded. “I figured.”
Azzi looked at her. “You’re good at figuring things out.”
“I make coffee for strangers. Most of the job is noticing what people don’t say.”
Riley’s expression stayed kind. “Is it over?”
That made it harder to answer.
“Yes,” Azzi said. “It has been for a while.”
“Or it’s supposed to be.”
There was no judgment in her face.
No disappointment either.
“Do you still love her?” Riley asked.
The answer arrived immediately.
Riley looked down for a second.
Azzi’s chest sank. “I’m sorry. That definitely wasn’t the right thing to say on a date.”
“Don’t be.” Riley looked back up. “Feelings don’t disappear because they’re inconvenient.”
“You should probably leave now.”
Riley smiled faintly. “And miss dessert?”
Azzi blinked. “That’s it?”
“What do you want me to do? Throw wine in your face?”
“I could use water, but it would lack drama.”
Azzi laughed despite herself.
Riley leaned back in the booth.
“I like you,” she said. “I wouldn’t be here if I didn’t. But I’m not asking you to pretend your past doesn’t exist.”
Azzi’s smile faded into something softer. “I don’t want to hurt you.”
“Then be honest with me.”
Azzi nodded. “I can do that.”
“Good.” Riley picked up the dessert menu. “Now help me choose between tiramisu and cannoli like the emotionally available adult you aspire to become.”
After dinner, Riley drove them to the park she had mentioned.
The famous hiding spot turned out to be exactly what she promised: a quiet bench beneath a huge oak tree, tucked far enough from the path that passing runners barely noticed it.
The city lights glowed beyond the branches.
They sat close but not touching.
For a while, neither of them spoke.
Azzi looked up through the leaves.
Riley was already looking at her.
Not dramatically, but enough.
Riley’s gaze dropped briefly to Azzi’s mouth, then returned to her eyes. Azzi’s heart sped up. She knew what was about to happen. She had imagined it earlier while getting dressed. She had told herself she was ready.
Now that the moment was here, Paige’s face flashed through her mind.
Paige pretending not to care.
Paige saying her heart wasn’t in it.
Riley noticed Azzi hesitate.
She leaned back slightly. “We don’t have to, I don’t want to rush you.”
Azzi released a breath. “I’m sorry.”
Riley smiled gently. “Wanting to want something isn’t the same as being ready.”
Azzi looked down at her hands. “You’re making it really hard for me to find something wrong with you.”
“Give it time. I leave mugs in the sink.”
Riley bumped her shoulder lightly against Azzi’s. “No pressure,” she said. “I mean it.”
Azzi leaned into the contact for a moment. “Thank you.”
“You still owe me a second date.”
Riley’s eyebrows lifted. “Unless tonight was terrible.”
Azzi smiled. “I owe you a second date.”
Riley nodded, satisfied. “Good.”
It was nearly eleven when Riley pulled up outside Azzi’s building.
Paige knew because she had checked the time nine times in the last twenty minutes. She had tried watching a movie. Then a game. Then film. Then nothing. Now she sat in the dark near her window, the city glowing beyond the glass.
Looking down at the entrance.
Paige’s entire body went tense. Riley got out first and walked around to open Azzi’s door. Paige rolled her eyes before she could stop herself. “Of course she opens doors,” she muttered.
Azzi stepped out holding the flowers Riley had brought earlier.
They stood beside the car talking.
Paige leaned slightly closer to the window.
She immediately straightened again.
This was none of her business.
Below, Riley said something that made Azzi smile.
But Riley’s arms went around Azzi’s waist, and Azzi rested one hand between Riley’s shoulder blades.
Her chest felt tight enough to bruise.
She waited for the car to pull away before moving from the window.
Then she walked into the kitchen, opened the refrigerator, and stared inside without seeing anything.
The apartment was silent.
Then came the faint mechanical hum of the elevator somewhere beyond the walls.
Paige pictured it stopping at sixteen.
Azzi would go straight to eighteen.
Paige closed the refrigerator.
The elevator hummed again.
A soft knock came at her door.
Her heart slammed against her ribs.
She crossed the apartment too quickly, then forced herself to slow down before opening it.
Azzi stood in the hallway.
Still holding the flowers.
Paige’s eyes went to them before she could stop herself.
Paige gripped the edge of the door. “Hey. You okay?”
Azzi shifted her weight and ignored the question. “I saw your light was on.”
Paige glanced toward the window behind her. “Couldn’t sleep.”
Paige wanted to ask everything.
Did Riley make you laugh?
Did you think about me at all?
Instead, she asked, “Did you have fun?”
Azzi looked at her carefully.
Paige forced a smile. “Good.”
Azzi glanced down the hallway. “You don’t have to do that.”
Paige’s hand tightened around the door. “I’m not pretending, Azzi.”
“I said I hoped you had fun.”
Azzi’s expression softened with frustration. “Those aren’t the same thing.”
Azzi took one small step closer.
“You were exhausted after camp yesterday.”
Paige gave a humorless laugh. “Do you want me to admit I was waiting for you?”
Paige wished she could pull them back.
Azzi’s voice dropped. “Were you?”
Paige stared at the floor between them.
She had been lying for weeks.
“I wanted to know you got home safe, that’s all.” she said.
Azzi looked at her for a long moment. “That’s not an answer.”
Paige finally raised her eyes. “Yes.”
Paige’s chest rose and fell too quickly now. “I waited,” she admitted. “I watched you leave. I saw the flowers. I saw you come back.”
Azzi’s eyebrows pulled together. “You watched us?”
“That sounds worse than it was.”
Azzi looked down at the flowers in her hand.
Paige’s jealousy twisted again.
“Did she kiss you?” The question escaped before Paige could stop it.
Paige closed her eyes briefly.
Azzi’s voice was quiet. “She didn’t.”
Relief hit Paige so hard it made her feel ashamed.
“Why do you care?” Azzi asked.
Paige looked past her toward the elevator. “You know why.”
“I want to hear you say it.” Azzi said.
Paige’s eyes snapped back to hers.
Azzi stood just outside the doorway, flowers in one hand, waiting.
Paige could feel every excuse she had ever used crowding her throat. Bad timing. Too much pressure. Trying to protect you. Not fair to you.
“Because I’m jealous,” Paige said.
Paige continued before fear could stop her. “I’m jealous that she gets to take you to dinner. I’m jealous she brought you flowers. I’m jealous that she gets to make you smile without all this history sitting between you.” Her voice cracked. “I’m jealous because I still love you, and I know I don’t have the right to ask you not to move on.”
The hallway seemed to disappear.
Paige’s eyes burned, but she refused to look away now.
“I ended things with Maya because it was wrong to keep pretending I could give her something when every part of me still—” Paige swallowed hard. “Still comes back to you.”
Azzi’s expression crumpled slightly.
“You broke up with me,” she whispered.
“You didn’t let me choose.”
“You made me feel like I was too much.”
Paige shook her head immediately. “You were never too much.”
“I was the one who wasn’t enough.”
Paige stepped forward, then stopped herself at the doorway. “I was scared,” she said. “You were right at the draft. I made it sound like I was protecting you because admitting I was scared felt worse.”
Azzi wiped beneath one eye. “What are you asking me for?”
Paige’s face tightened. “Nothing.”
Azzi laughed softly, painfully. “Of course.”
“No.” Paige shook her head. “I’m not asking you to end anything with Riley. I’m not asking you to forgive me because I finally told the truth. I just couldn’t keep standing in front of you acting like I didn’t care.”
The flowers rustled softly in her hand.
Paige swallowed. “I know.”
“She didn’t pressure me tonight.”
Paige’s jaw tightened, but she nodded.
“She deserves someone who’s actually available,” Azzi continued.
Paige’s voice was barely audible. “Yeah.”
Azzi looked at her again. “So do I.”
Paige’s eyes filled completely. “I agree.”
For a moment, neither moved.
Then Azzi stepped forward.
She simply reached out and placed the flowers in Paige’s hands.
Paige blinked down at them. “What are you doing?”
“I don’t know where my vase is.”
Azzi’s mouth trembled slightly. “And I don’t want to look at them tonight.”
She accepted the flowers carefully. “Okay.”
Azzi turned toward the elevator.
Paige gripped the flowers too tightly, forcing herself to loosen her hands.
Azzi kept her back to her. “I know you did.”
“I’m sorry it took seeing you with someone else for me to stop hiding.”
Azzi looked over her shoulder. “So am I.”
The elevator doors opened.
Paige stood in her doorway holding flowers another girl had bought for the woman she loved.
Before the doors closed, Azzi met her eyes. “I’m still going on a second date with her.”
Paige’s throat tightened.
She nodded. “You should.”
Paige forced herself to continue. “You should figure out what you want without me making the decision for you again.”
The elevator doors began to slide shut.
Azzi’s face softened. “That might be the first right thing you’ve done in a while.”
Paige remained in the hallway for several seconds.
Then she went inside and placed Riley’s flowers in a glass pitcher because she didn’t own a vase.
Upstairs, Azzi leaned back against the elevator wall.
The words should have fixed something.
Instead, they had opened everything again.
When Azzi reached her apartment, she stepped inside and locked the door behind her.
Azzi stared at the message.
Azzi: Yeah. Thank you for tonight. I had a really good time.
Riley: Me too. Second date still on?
Azzi looked toward the window.
Two floors below, Paige was awake.
She looked back at Riley’s message.
Her chest hurt, but she didn’t regret it.
Paige had finally stopped deciding for her.
Now Azzi had to decide for herself.
And for the first time, she understood that loving Paige and choosing Paige were not necessarily the same thing.