there’s nothing wrong with either of you. even as georgia’s words echoed in anthony’s head, he couldn’t help but feel like that wasn’t true for him. maybe it was true for blythe because, well, it was blythe after all. but anthony? the whole reason he was back in wrensted was because there was something wrong with him. he didn’t need mandatory therapy to tell him that much. he had felt it since he twelve years old, waking up to find out that whispered i love you from his mom was really a goodbye. the feeling had only grown deeper, digging roots into every fiber of his being, since then. but he couldn’t explain that to georgia, not now. he’d be shifting the attention to his pain, like he always does, and this moment is about hers.
georgia’s use of the past tense, not just once but twice, is a cut deeper than anthony's ever felt before. there weren’t many people that he let into the most intimate parts of himself, but with georgia, it had always been so easy. he never felt judged or weak. she had been a pillar for anthony to lean on when he needed strength. he had hoped he’d done a good job at reciprocating that for his friend, but now he wasn’t so sure.
“we don’t like each other,” he says limply, knowing it’s futile. what kind of sane person sleeps with someone you don’t like? not just once, but twice. it didn’t make any fucking sense, despite the reality that it was.
anthony can feel himself sinking now, especially at the sound of georgia’s voice, how small and betrayed she sounded. he wanted to tear himself open, show her that he was still the same ant that she knew and loved but had just made a mistake. a pretty fucking big mistake. one that was apparently costing him one of the best friendships he’s ever had.
“i wanted to tell you.” his voice is quiet, weak. “but anytime i might’ve thought about it, i just felt… kinda like how i do now. ashamed and pathetic.” his grip on the chain around his neck tightens for a second, his breathing becoming more shaky. “it wasn’t even supposed to happen. but then it did, and it was so much easier to act like it didn’t. plus, with me and blythe… it felt like an unspoken agreement to just never talk about it again. i-i didn’t think… god, musa is gonna hate me, isn’t he?”
it wasn’t georgia’s job to placate him, not anymore. but for anthony, he couldn’t help himself. the little devil on his shoulder was always searching for assurance, despite knowing he wasn’t going to be getting it. a pity, knowing he needed it now more than ever.