the bane of ‘beauty with brains’
Growing up, a phrase which was often thrown around me by my aunties was- ‘She’s growing up to be a beauty with brains!’ My chest would swell up with pride on hearing that as I had taken on the dual role of being beautiful as well as smart. I found myself nodding along to friends and teachers who segregated smart children from the beautiful ones on the basis of our marks and the outfits we adorned on Children’s Day. Coming from a typical middle-class Indian family, I was always taught how education is the only way for me to succeed in life, as we had no generational wealth to fall back on. It was evident which student I aspired to be. Keeping my head in books, my body grew in adolescence and subject to comments from everyone around me. However, a miracle had happened. I understood that a third category of children who had managed to intersect between the categories of being smart as well as beautiful. This was the next category I knew I had to be a part of. Effortlessly beautiful and a straight A student. A beauty with brains.
All my school years were spent trying to be the exception to the rule of either being beautiful or smart, facing the double brunt of the stereotypes of beauty as well as the desperate need for academic validation to determine my worth. As I blew 18 candles this September, things were different. I had an epiphany. An epiphany so profound it shook the ideals I had built my entire life around. Why ARE women made to believe that beauty and smartness are mutually exclusive concepts?
Throughout our lives, women are conditioned to believe that they can fit in either of these boxes and if we do manage to break through these boxes, being a ‘beauty with brains’ is treated as a rare exception rather than the rule. It is important to note that these comments are gendered comments catering to the image of a woman who can either be conventionally beautiful or intelligent. Never are cisgendered men subjected to a compliment which threatens the ideal of them being either attractive or intelligent. It is taken to be a de facto part of their being. The double standards come into play only for women.
American sociologist C.H Cooley’s ‘the looking glass self’ talks about the stages of perception wherein individuals base their sense of self on how they believe others view them. In a society which puts forth the false narrative that women are naturally less intelligent than men, alters how women determine their self-worth and of the other women around them. The phrase feeds into the degrading way that patriarchy perceives women. It makes women skeptical of their perceived ability to be intelligent if they are taking care of their appearance. For years, I had done my best not to attract too much attention as I wished to be seen as a student who was only interested in her education. Moreover, it also fosters in women a sense of internalised misogyny which caters to keep benevolent sexism and its microaggressions in place. Thus, when one is faced with the dilemma of ascertaining whether ‘beauty with brains’ is a compliment or not, be rest assured it is not. If anything, it is a backhanded ‘compliment’ the cost which is the acceptance of a reality which systematically conditions women into constantly having to prove themselves and avoid being labelled as ‘dumb’ or ‘uptight’. Now the decision is ours: to smile politely at this comment or to question it.












