Once Bitten, Twice Shy
Pairing || Spencer Reid x Ex-f!reader (third person)
Summary || She and Spencer had been broken up for years. She never expected a phone call from Emily to tell her he in prison and wanting to see her. Angst and mentions of cheating.
"Spencer's where?" She dropped heavily into the chair behind her, head snapping up to look directly at Unit Chief SSA Emily Prentiss.
Emily grimaced. "He's in prison, awaiting trial. He's innocent," she hastened to add. "We just need the time to prove it."
That was the last thing she'd expected to hear when the FBI called her to come in to discuss something vaguely relating to one Dr. Spencer Reid. Injury or death, perhaps. Something related to drugs, maybe. Prison?! Not a snowball's chance in hell.
"Why are you telling me this? I haven't seen Spencer in a long time," she asked after a moment. She gratefully took the cup of water Emily offered her, ignoring the shake in her hands as she took a sip. She kept her focus on the drink, mind whirring. There was nothing that she could offer him in bail or legal aid, so why, why after all these years would he get in touch? Especially like this.
If anything, Emily's grimace deepened uncomfortably. "He added you to list of visitors."
"Did he... did he say why?" She asked, glancing up at Emily.
"The request came from his lawyer. I can ask him, if you like? Next time I visit," Emily offered.
She nodded slowly, unsure if she would ever step foot in the prison even if Emily found out his reasoning. There was so much hurt there better left buried.
"If he's asking for me, he's not doing well is he?" She asked, gripping tightly onto the cup and hoping this wouldn't pile onto her conscience.
"No," Emily answered honestly. "Prison is hard enough without a brain like Spencer's, and he's not in protective custody. There's a real chance he could get hurt."
"And he decided now is the time to dig up the past?" She laughed humourlessly. He always was a glutton for punishment.
"Can I ask what happened between you two? I only know what Spencer's shared and it's not a lot." Emily had never been the one Spencer confided in about relationships, and some of the things happened when she was in London. She was admittedly quite curious.
She let out a sigh, leaning back in her seat and staring out the window as old memories surfaced.
10th December, 2005
"I'm fine, just leave it," Spencer snapped. He wasn't fine. His nightmares woke her up as well as himself, but he'd never talk about it.
He'd never shut her out like this before. She wasn't sure how to process it. Was this a glimpse into her future? She didn't want to start a fight so she did as asked and gave him space.
It took a week, but eventually he opened up about the night terrors, that Agent Gideon had pulled him to one side with some advice. The nightmares didn't magically stop straight away, but with time Spencer started getting enough sleep and the tension became a distance memory.
25th February, 2007
She finished putting the last of her belongings in the car. A clean break. She'd donated and sold what she could, minimising the amount she'd had to pack up. Leaving Spencer was a hard choice, but the right one.
A recent case had him hooked on drugs. Oh he denied it at first, but the syringes in the bin partially hidden by tissues gave it away. That was aside from the behavioural changes and gaslighting. She couldn't stay while he tore down and burned everything that they'd built in the last four years.
"You don't know anything about behaviour. I'm the profiler, you're just a check-out girl." That had been the last thing he'd said to you before leaving on another case, when she'd begged him to speak to someone like Hotch or a therapist or an AA leader. Anyone at all. He said no, so she was saying goodbye.
12th April, 2008
"I'm sorry, for everything I said. You were right about me needing help, and I have it now. I've been going to AA meetings. I'm five months sober." He took her hands in his. "I want to give us another chance. I really messed up, I know that, but I want to earn your trust again. I missed you."
It was everything she'd wanted him to say. She'd missed him with every fibre of her being. Almost an entire year of still turning to tell him something first, when his shadow wasn't even there. A phantom limb. She hadn't dated anyone in the time they'd been broken up, no one compared. And he was being so sincere...
"There can't be any more secrets like that, okay?" She said. "Even if you fall off the wagon. I need the truth for this to work."
"Of course. I'll never keep something like that from you again." He crossed his heart with his finger.
16th September, 2012
She didn't know when he went back on his word. There were so many moments that she was suspicious of in hindsight. Little white lies when he said he was okay when he wasn't, the appointments he kept from her, the secret phone calls. The break up was uglier this time, full of bitterness and suspected infidelity. He called her insecure. She called him a coward.
She'd stuck by his side through all the missed dates and anniversary. She defended his lack of proposal despite having been together for nearly a decade to her family all the whilst knowing that he knew she wanted to get married. She'd been his cheerleader when he reached sobriety milestones, his emergency contact at all hours of the day. Despite all of that, he prioritised another woman. She promised herself she'd never go back to him ever again. No more chances. Never.
Emily let out a low whistle. "Well he certainly kept a lot to himself!" She said, surprised at how callously Spencer had treated you. It wasn't her place to comment on Maeve - even she wasn't entirely sure what had happened between her and Spencer, and there was no point pouring salt in the wound.
Resting her elbows on the desk, Emily leaned forward. "Look, I can't make you see Spencer, and it isn't fair he's put you in this position. But have a think about anything you might want to ask him, and I can forward it on. No pressure."
With no small amount of reluctance, she agreed. The meeting ended not long after, with a shake of hands and both with lots to think about. She still hadn't decided what to do, but Emily had given her her phone number so she could mull things over at home.
Later that night, she tossed and turned in bed and was still no closer to answer whilst images of an incarcerated, struggling Spencer tormented her soul.








