My rating: 5 of 5 stars
Are You Sleeping starts out with an excerpt of a transcription of the fictional podcast, Reconsidered. It is a podcast that promises to delve into the 13-year-old case of the murder of beloved father, history professor, and member of the Elm Park community, Chuck Buhrman. The thing is, it's not a cold case, far from it; it's a case that went to trial, and the killer is now serving out a life sentence in prison. It is a solved case. Or is it?
Next, we're introduced to Josie Buhrman, daughter of Chuck Buhrman, who has spent the last 10 years of her life trying to get away from her past: her father's murder, her mother's abandonment Josie and her twin sister (Lanie) by joining a cult, and her sister's betrayal. In that time, she traveledlk;p the world, and she met her boyfriend Caleb. Not expecting to have a future with Caleb, she gave him the standard lie she told everyone she met in her travels: her parents had died in a car crash, and she didn't even mention her sister. But now, five years into the relationship, the podcast is released and it looks like the lies she has built her new life on are going to fall down around her. When she is called by her cousin to let her know her mother has died, that possibility becomes much more of a certainty.
In my opinion, this book was very well-written. I started reading it when I was listening to podcasts almost constantly, and went into it thinking it was going to be more about the podcast. I was initially a bit disappointed when it ended up being more about the story behind the podcast; that is, the effect that the murder had on Mr. Buhrman's family. Once I got over myself and settled into the story, I found I really enjoyed the book. As I mentioned, the focus is on Josie, who has a twin sister, Lanie. Josie has spent the better part of a decade trying to forget (or at least avoid) her past, and had done so pretty successfully. But when her mom died, she had to return to her hometown and confront her past head-on. The podcast just adds to the complexity of the story, because it casts doubt on the original case, which was heavily dependent on Lanie's testimony that she saw the guy next door pull the trigger. The author does an excellent job of mixing in excerpts from the podcast, Twitter feeds, and posts from reddit to tell the story in a rather unique way. Not only do we get to see the story from the perspective of the Buhrman family (through both current events and flashbacks), but we get to see it from a journalist's perspective, and also the point of view of fans of the podcast.
I felt like the characters were developed very well, the contrast between Josie and Lanie was very clear and interesting. I absolutely hated the podcaster/journalist Poppy Parnell, but considering that was kinda the point, I thought the author handled her character excellently. The only part of the book that frustrated me was that I knew from the beginning that Josie had a major issue with Lanie, that her sister had betrayed her in some unforgivable way, but it wasn't until about a third of the way through that the actual betrayal was made clear. Even then, it was a little while longer before the effect it had on Josie was thoroughly explained.
Overall, this was a good book, maybe even a great book. Once things really started to pick up about halfway through, I had a very hard time putting the book down, I just had to know what would happen next. I would definitely recommend this book for anyone who likes psychological thrillers and who is tired of always reading books with the same basic storyline and the same predictable ending.
Many thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with a complimentary copy of this book for review.
Get Are You Sleeping on Amazon!
View all my reviews or Visit my website