STRONGLY AGREE with this. Movie Bill was fine, but I have so much appreciation for Novel Bill. Heās such a compelling character. I didnāt understand how he was supposed to be the āleaderā character, until reading the book.
One of my favorite parts about Novel Bill is how compassionate and accepting he is towards his peers.
In chapter 5, when Ben is explaining how they should make the dam and is referring to the project as something that he himself is not a part of, Bill immediately corrects him and makes sure Ben knows that he is a part of their little group now.
In chapter 14, when Mike hangs out with the Losers for the first time, Bill asks if he can ask him a question and Mike immediately assumes that the question is going to be about his race. Instead, Bill just asks him a question about baseball. He doesnāt single him out (which is honestly the bare minimum, but this does take place the 50s), he just treats him as he would anyone else.
Novel Bill even treats Bev the same way as the rest of the Losers, for the most part. The only key differences that I can think of off the top of my head are the very rare semi-romantic thoughts he has towards her + him wanting her to sit out of the Smoke-Hole Ritual in chapter 15, on the basis of her being a girl.
Throughout the book, all of the Losers think very highly of Bill. Heās a great friend, and they all have so much respect for him. Hell, Eddie practically idolizes him. And all the while heās being a great friend to the Losers, heās simultaneously envious of them. I constantly think back to his internal monologue at the end of chapter 14:
āHe saw the gratitude in their eyes and felt a measure of gladness for them⦠but their gratitude did little to heal his own horror. In fact, there was something in their gratitude which made him want to hate them. Would he never be able to express his own terror, lest the fragile welds that made them into one thing should let go? And even to think such a thing wasn't really fair, was it? Because in some measure at least he was using them-using his friends, risking their lives to settle the score for his dead brother.ā
As much as Bill loves his friends, heās also envious of the fact that they have him to rely on. He feels like the glue of the group, that he must be strong and brave for them. Heās a kid forced to grow up too fastā neglected by his parents. Bill treats the Losers how he wishes his parents treated him. And even while heās jealous of them, he still brings himself to feel guilty about them helping him go up against It. He feels like heās using them, when in actuality theyāre here because 1) It has also tormented them and 2) he is their friend and they care about him enough to stand by his side.
On the subject of book and movie differences, I will also forever be upset that they removed the importance of āHe thrusts his fists against the posts, and still insists he sees the ghosts.ā That line is supposed to haunt Bill. The repetition of it shows how desperate Bill is for his parentsā attention. If he can just say the whole tongue twister once without stuttering, maybe they will be proud of him and actually acknowledge him for once. The fact that itās only mentioned passively in two movie scenes (that I can remember off the top of my head) is criminal.
But basically the main point I was trying to make is that Billās friendships are so so so important to his character and shape who he is, hence why itās very unfortunate that they remove a lot of that from his character in the movie.