“Good. You shouldn’t, because she’s not the one to blame. I am.“ The Williams male replied, somewhat sheepishly as he met her gaze briefly before returning to his previous position of scanning the crowd beyond. “It’s not about what I would tell her, it’s about what I didn’t tell her.“ Fletcher started, exhaling a sigh as he moved them slowly but surely across the dance floor. Carefully he slid his hand down to her lower back, before gently pulling her closer. Tilting his head some, his lips remained inches from her ear as he spoke. “You leaving fucking sucked, Sammy. After loosing the family, you were the last nail in my coffin. And while I though that it would be easy, that staying in touch when we were miles apart was the right thing, it fucking hurt and I couldn’t handle that on top of everything else.“ He mused, tone one of sincerity as he paused, gathering his thoughts momentarily. “So I stopped replying, figured cutting off contact was the only way to ignore the void you left in our lives. Grace of course asked questions, so I told her you stopped replying. Because if she knew the truth she would have talked me out of it.“ He added, a sigh escaping him as his shoulders rose some in a simply shrug. “I told her the truth a few weeks back.“ A decision he still wasn’t sure of, perhaps it was his his need to mend the bridges he had broken not only for himself, but for his sister too.
Pulling back some he caught her gaze, aquamarine irises studying hers as if watching the clogs turning in her head. His lips curved upward before pulling into a fully fledged grin, filled with amusement and intrigue. “Did you really though, I mean you’re still here talking to me. Either I’m not that much of an asshole or you, Samantha Reed still have it bad.” He teased, a lowly chuckle escaping him before her next question was posed. “Of course, ask away.” He breathed, though his mind remained intrigued by the idea of the very woman he had spent his entire adolescence pathetically pinning after, could ever possibly have felt the same way. There was simply no way. Because Sam had always been the bright one of their trio, and he would always be the annoying twin brother that was but a friend by association. At least that was how it was before they lost Brooke.
The amusement that danced over his features moments prior was quickly replaced by confusion and concern. It was one thing to dream about his deceased twin, but a complete other thing to see a physical apparition of her or perhaps someone that looked like her, when he was awake and alert. “They were just dreams, but seeing her now – that felt so fucking real.” Raising a hand he dragged his fingers through his hair, shock plaguing his somber expression. Maybe he was loosing his mind, maybe he was projecting her to squash the feelings he had surprised over the years that came with Sam’s return. Either way it was the feeling in his gut, that same feeling he used to get when she was close by that left her confused beyond measure. “Blue, a baby blue dress.”
You were the last nail in my coffin.
How true it rang for both of them, though Sam considered herself not dead, but rather unmoored without Fletcher as a defining anchor. Drifting through life, floating along the waves without a directional header or purpose beyond... what? Her career? The necessity to unravel knotted truths had become a compulsion more than anything else, a way to fixate elsewhere when the alternative was to miss all that she lost over the years. And him, always him. An old wound they rehashed now in close proximity without the vitriol and heightened tensions from the pier, which somehow made it feel intimate in a way that Sam had forgotten. This was their temporary confessional and she lacked enough courage to match it, simply nodding with understanding and a quiet, “It’s okay, Fletch. I meant it when I apologized on the pier and I meant it again when forgave you. We’re good.” The blonde cleared her throat after a moment, choking back some convoluted emotion. “She told me that, but...” Now came Sam’s turn to shrug, emphasizing that it hadn’t changed Grace’s feelings on the matter. Past scars could become easily irritated under the right circumstances and she didn’t blame the eldest Williams for rejecting their relationship.
Could dry throats still swallow beneath the weight of nerves? Apparently so, despite how the movement lacked any relief or time to consider a quippy response. Even less helpful was the manner in which he scrutinized Sam’s features in an attempt to read whatever thoughts lay behind her expression, effectively blanking them out altogether. It required every ounce of willpower to not allow her eyes the opportunity to flicker downward and give the whole truth away. “You’re not that much of an asshole,” she finally managed. “And I owe you a dance, remember?” Phew. A close one. Though she didn’t have enough time or awareness to pat herself on the back, not with their gazes still aligned and a million dollar question on her lips. “Did you ever––?”
It never came out, effectively drowned by their current predicament and Fletcher’s seemingly bewildered expression as he attempted to make heads or tails of whatever plagued him. He mentioned something about it feeling so real, but the entire moment felt akin to another one of his infuriating jokes. The sort meant to push Sam away to the very best of his ability and drive her out of Oceanside altogether, only this one’s punchline was far crueler and she couldn’t parse that from where they had been only minutes prior. Baby blue. Of course it was the same color as Sam’s own dress. How convenient. “Wow,” she exhaled in disbelief while firmly removing herself from his grasp, already hating the way that hurt too. “You couldn’t even come up with something more creative than my dress? I know you’re probably just going off the top of your head, but really?”
It became near impossible to shield the disappointment and pure anguish as they danced behind crystalline hues. “Of all the stupid shit you’ve said to purposely piss me off, that... that takes the cake.” Anger blossomed within the pain, not enough to cause a scene, but she felt it in the way her voice trembled. “I can’t believe I almost––” It didn’t matter. Fletcher was playing the long con by attempting to twist the knife precisely when it would hurt the most, in the way that only he could as the person who knew her better than anyone. “You really had me going. Fuck.”