Honestly I want to see Garp be wracked with guilt. I want to see him really think about and reflect on his actions and his in-actions. I want him to remember that he promised Roger that he would protect Ace from the Marines and I want him to sit with the knowledge and guilt that he broke that promise, no matter the reason.
Yes I know Garp was a Marine and had no obligation to help a pirate but he was also a grandfather who absolutely had an obligation to help his grandson. I want him to think about that. I want him to be haunted by that. I want him to face that.
I want him to think about how the last words that Roger ever spoke to Garp were, "My unborn child is innocent... I trust you... Save my child... I know you. You'll do it." I want Garp to think about that constantly. I want that to keep him up at night. I want Garp to think about how he took this new born baby out of his dead mother's arms and agreed to protect him and then proceeded to not actually do anything to protect him.
I need Garp to be haunted by the ghosts of Roger, Rouge, and Ace. The whole damn family just haunting this man from beyond the grave.









