Some of the biggest fantasy worldbuilding fails that I see, in no particular order
Gods without religion. The Gods are real and a known historical fact, but virtually nobody is religious.
Cultural racism/discrimination without structural racism/discrimination. Discrimination that exists only in microagressions or mean comments, without existing in any sort of structural way.
Secret history with no clear reason for it to be secret and no clear method for maintaining that secrecy. Major parts of the world's history are kept entirely secret, even though there's not an obvious reason to do so and even when history has shown this is virtually impossible to enforce (especially in a world with any movement or communication across borders).
Large, homogeneous countries. Even without immigration, virtually no country larger than the Vatican will be fully homogeneous in terms of culture, dialect, beliefs, traditions, etc., much less a large one with limited communication technology as is often seen in fantasy. The Planet of Hats problem.
Racial/species accents instead of regional accents. Like listen I know âall dwarves are Scottishâ but a dwarf who is raised in the Underdark is not going to have the same accent as a dwarf who is raised on the surface a hundred thousand miles away in the literal exact same way that being white doesnât mean having a Texan accent
Polytheism as monotheism with a phone book. (I will never shut up about this.) A polytheistic religion actually specifically means that there is more than one deity, so you offer prayers and offerings to the one who best suits your needs AT THE TIME⌠not that you pick your favourite one from a list and thatâs Your God who You Worship and the only one you interact with. You do not pray to Odin to bring in a good harvest (but Thor, Freyr, Freya, or Frigg are all good options)
No one has ever heard of magic before. Now this is specifically if magic is explicitly included in the world, but as a general rule, if your MC has magical abilities that they have recognized and been able to hone with help from a mentor, or thereâs a formal system like a sorcery guild or wizard school, people just might suspect that your MC knows magic when something implausible happens. Especially basic beginner magic - creating a shower of sparks in a world without electricity probably only has one cause, so theyâll look for a mage before âooh what could possibly be causing that oh no!â
Everyone is human in a modern/urban fantasy. Fuck you put elves in your Starbucks.
Iâve seen Odin-worshippers on Tumblr who do the phone-book approach, but that might actually support your argument.
Yeah itâs one of the clearest flags of being raised in a monotheistic society and not actually thinking all that deeply when âchangingâ religions
(I mean really, trading SkyDaddy for Dishonourable War Berserker Daddy is painted as a direct one to one but Odin only became relevant after the vikings found England heâs just not the specialist we need)
Thereâs a whole concept in classical Greek culture specifically called sophrosune, which means âThe Gods Will Kick Your Ass If You Play Favouritesâ
It was considered dangerous and bad to praise one god to the point of denigrating another, and the god you praised would be the one to kick your ass for trying to start shit
I wish people would just. Just learn one little thing. Before trying to put it in their worlds and games. Just open a book. Just look at history.
People have been people since the beginning of time and we always will be, but that is not the same as saying âand thereâs no real differenceâ
Some motherfucker on here wrote a beautiful story about Odin welcoming people into Valhalla as warriors for fighting cancer and shit like that and listen
It was beautiful. It was touching. It was a wonderful story.
It was fucking bullshit there was SPECIFICALLY a place for every single person who didnât get shanked bloody on a battlefield to go and it was Niflheim or Niflhel
(This was why Odin would deliberately and intentionally turn on his best heroes at their moment of greatest need to make sure they died violently)
Hel will welcome you with open, slightly frosted arms, and the Lady of Comfort did nothing whatsoever to deserve to be slighted like that
Also, Freya again. Goddess of death and magic and making sure warriors were reunited with their lovers in her hall of FĂłlkvangr because not everyone was into Valhalla but they still needed to not be scared to die in battle
But no, see, if we want Direct Christian Parallels, Odin ended up ruling the Ăsir so he gets to play SkyDaddy because heâs got that old patriarchal Look, and well Hel, itâs in the name, and thatâs also why Hades was a villain in Disneyâs Hercules
(He also did nothing to deserve this he kidnapped one single person EVER, and was such a wifeguy that there were whole cults worshipping her to make sure they got a good afterlife
The Eleusinian mysteries, one of the few âmysteriesâ we do actually know something about because, well, they were fucking huge and widespread because people have always worried about what happens when you die)
If you want to worship a deity you should probably do a LOT more research than just to build a fantasy world and I will not be the one who dies on this hill but I will make it taller with as many bodies as necessary























