The Silver Showdown

The ultimate battle between the various psychic hedgehogs from across time! | Run by @ramblingsofasandvich

[silvershowdown]

WE HAVE A WINNER!

Congratulations to IDW Silver! The victor of the Silver Showdown!

[Live Silver Reaction.]

Through 4 rounds, IDW Silver won by:

Round 1: 32.2% against the Lightron.

Round 2: 53.4% against Ace (Secret Freedom Fighter) Silver.

Round 3: 42.2% against Plushie Silver.

Round 4: 54.2% against 2006 Silver.

With a total of 2524 votes!

Once again, congratulations to IDW Silver!

And with that, this concludes the Silver Showdown!

A huge thank you to everyone who voted or made propaganda posts. Sorry if I missed any and never reposted it.

And an extra special thanks to @calamitycons for the fantastic short comic about the unexpected iconic fight of the tournament!

And speaking of which, although the main tournament is over, one final battle is waiting in the wings. A rematch, against an old foe.

(Mabey, I'm still unsure whether I want to do this or not...)

[silvershowdown]

IDW Silver maintains the Title!

It was a valiant reattempted by the Lightron, but unfortunately it was still not enough.

IDW Silver has won again.

[silvershowdown]

Surprise Rematch!

A Rematch between IDW Silver and the Lightron!

IDW Silver has come far, through 4 rounds to win the Silver Showdown.

But so has the Lightron, from a simple slot filler to a fan favorite!

These two are back for one final poll! Will IDW Silver maintain the title? Or will the Lightron make a comeback?

IDW Silver VS The Lightron

IDW

Lightron

Voting ended onMar 12, 2023

VOTE NOW!

[silvershowdown]

Where'd it go?

[catgirlkirigiri]

Happy Throwing Him Thursday

[silvershowdown]

Heh, yeah. Hope you don't mind

I don't mind at all.

And that goes for all of you. Don't be afraid to tag me about any and all Silver propaganda. Weather its about 2006 or IDW, I'll repost it.

[krafterwrites-alt]

Tbh 06 Silver and IDW Silver exist in such different contexts that I feel like it's hard to directly compare them to see which one is "better". 06 Silver had never been to the past before, had presumably only interacted with one other person in his entire life before Mephiles showed up, and is very determined in his goal to the point of it kind of clouding his vision. IDW Silver has been traveling back to the past and interacting with others for a while, and has also already saved the future in multiple instances, so obviously he's less stressed and tunnel visioned when it comes to doing what he needs to do to prevent his time period from being ruined since he now knows he can rely on others for help. Because he's less stressed and more familiar with everyone, he's also learned to relax, and just enjoy the smaller things in life. If you expect IDW Silver to be like 06 Silver, then you're going to be disappointed. I don't say that because I think IDW Silver is a bad portrayal, but because it's showing him off in a different context. He's not meant to be 06 Silver, he's meant to be a version of him who's been saving the future for a while now, and has allowed himself to become more open and laid back. If you think that Silver would develop differently after he becomes more familiar with everyone in the past and has saved the future multiple times, even though I would personally disagree, I would still think that's a more valid criticism of IDW Silver. They're both two sides of the same coin, not separate coins entirely, which is why I believe that it's not super fair to say that one is definitively the more true version of Silver

[krafterwrites-alt]

Obviously it's fine if you like how Silver is in 06 more than he is in IDW, I'm just saying that it's not fair to say that one is unobjectively a better representation of the character than the other

[silvershowdown]

(Silver thoughts I have nowhere else to put) 06 Silver is like. A complete meal. He's got a backstory, develops relationships, meets people, and has some of that sweet sweet angst and conflict to play around with. He's also one of the very few Silvers with a well-defined past and future.

The problem is that 06 is kinda hard to consume in general, and there's no nice easy way to get that complete meal. It's like it was left in the fridge, and you're not sure how to heat it up right, so at best it's still gonna be kinda wonky.

In comparison, IDW feels less complete, but much fresher, and oh so sweet. There's more, and it keeps coming, and he's put in many situations.

anyways I voted for IDW but best of luck to all the 06'ers out there!

Some Silver propaganda sent in by an Anonymous.

(Disclaimer: The posting of this is in no way indorsing IDW or 06. The blog is a mutual party, and is merely the host of this tournament.)

[silvershowdown]

A return of a past competitor?

While the 'main' final is going, I want to ask you all something.

Would you be interested in / find if funny if after the final rounds conclusion, the Lightron comes back for a rematch agents the winner?

The Return of the Lightron?

Yes

No

Voting ended onMar 10, 2023

[hyperfixation-land]

Ok how about when @bestsonicshowdown, @amyroseshowdown, @knucklesshowdown, @shadowsmackdown, @bestactualsonicshowdown, @silvershowdown and @tailsshowdown finish their competitions, somebody makes all their winners compete against each other for fun? What do you think?

Do we need an ultimate winner showdown?

Yeah!

Nah.

Voting ended onMar 9, 2023

[silvershowdown]

It all comes down to this!

2006 Silver VS IDW Silver

06

IDW

Voting ended onMar 10, 2023

Whos it going to be!? Vote! Vote! Vote!

And make sure to Repost after voting. We want to spread this as far and wide a possible. Its important everyone gets a say in this.

WHO IS THE SILVERIST OF SILVERS!!!

[silvershowdown]

The Finally is at Hand!

16 Silvers entered this Tournament and it all comes down to this!

Who will win? Silvers 'iconic' debut, or the most recent Comic iteration?

Its 2006 Silver VS IDW Silver! Poll opens in T-minutes 10 minutes!

GET READY!

[silvershowdown]

Round 3 has Concluded!

Round 3 has come to a close!

Bracket update in progress.

[blazeshowdown]

Welcome to the blaze showdown!

Inspired by @bestsonicshowdown @tailsshowdown @robotnikshowdown @silvershowdown @amyroseshowdown @tailsshowdown and @shadowsmackdown.

This is a poll based tournament to determine the best version of blaze the cat, consisting of 10 blazes! The roster will be:

Blaze the cat

Archie Blaze the cat (pre-SGW)

Archie Blaze the cat (post-SGW)

IDW Blaze the cat

Sir Percival

Blaze plush

Blaze Woman

Burning Blaze

Prototype Blaze

Sonic ‘06 Blaze the cat

Details will be in pinned post! Voting will start soon

[silvershowdown]

I can't believe I missed this and that the final showdown is going to be between Silver's first appearance (his lowest point as a character) and a fucking PLUSHIE

The round has just begun, anything can happen.

[silvershowdown]

Round 3 is Live!

Round 3 is now active!

Four are left, and only two can move on the the Finals! So go out a vote!

Please repost after voting, we need a large voter pool now more then ever!

[silvershowdown]

Round 3

IDW Silver VS Plushie Silver

IDW

Plushie

Voting ended onMar 9, 2023

This one will be fun to watch...