Salt in the Wound
(You Call, I Answer, Part 3)
Conrad Fisher x fem!reader
Summary: reader breaks up with Jeremiah (not explicitly scripted), and takes some time for herself. Conrad reaches out, but she canât handle the whiplash right now.
WARNINGS: discussion of being drugged at a party, arguing, Jeremiah hate continued, ANGST, very sad Connie baby
A/N: I had to vaguepost the Jeremiah scene because I could NOT take him seriously, sorry! Also Iâm sorry, this one is going to hurt! Iâve been cleaning up the next part though so you will be ok soon :)
~2k words
It went about how you expected. Jeremiah had answered the door with an expression you thought he may have practiced in the mirror. The perfect picture of concern, soft and caring. Waiting to reflect back whatever it is that youâre looking for in him.Â
He almost cracked, when he saw you in Conrad's clothes - you saw the flicker of jealousy - but he managed to keep it together.
You donât remember exactly what he said, but it doesnât matter. An apology, long and wordy but insubstantial. Really, a cross between an apology and a lecture. It included the words âif Iâd knownâ, and âbig miscommunicationâ, and ânext timeâ. Youâd already checked out before getting there, but you respected him too much to do this over the phone, so there you were, nodding while he went on.Â
When the words âtake a breakâ left your mouth, the tone changed, as youâd expected. The Jeremiah youâd come to know was back then. The stone mask back on, angry, feigned hurt, dismissive. Heâd said it was âunfairâ, and you thought back to what Conrad had said. No, it wasnât fair.Â
You said some things that made you wonder whether this break could actually be temporary after all.
You hadnât even gone into his apartment. Just argued right there on the front step. Then youâd walked down the street in a fugue state, ears ringing, and ended up slumped in a seat at the bus station for half an hour before even checking the routes on your phone.Â
Youâre jolted back into the present by the notification waiting for you. An email from the clinic - how modern.Â
The results donât make any sense to you at all, but you see the words âpositiveâ and the sender encourages you to book a follow-up appointment to discuss. Great.Â
You think it over for a moment, and decide to rip off the bandaid. You take a deep breath before dialing the familiar number.Â
Taylor answers, and you can almost hear her smile through the phone.
âHeyyy, party girl. Just waking up now? I thought you were dead.âÂ
âHey, Taylor, can I come over?âÂ
Several hours later, you and Taylor are lying on a pile of blankets and pillows on the floor. Sheâd listened to everything, letting you ramble and cry, and she shared your indignation at all the right moments. Then youâd watched a bunch of videos about celebrity gossip, and eaten a pint of ice cream each.Â
Now youâre both on your phones, pop music playing quietly from her Bluetooth speaker.Â
âTaylor?â you ask.Â
âYeah?âÂ
âDo you think I made a mistake?â youâre embarrassed by the question the second it leaves your mouth.Â
She puts down her phone and sits up, looking at you.Â
âDo I think you made a mistake breaking up with the guy you cried about for almost 45 minutes? Like actually sobbing right here, in this spot, only an hour ago? Or do I think you made a mistake spending the day with Conrad and looking into his puppy-dog eyes?âÂ
âBoth, I guess.âÂ
âYouâre too funny. You know, you havenât even made a decision yet. Youâve got both brothers waiting for a call from you right now.âÂ
âThat is not true.âÂ
Then, like he has a sixth sense, your phone vibrates with a text from Conrad.Â
Just a simple: How did it go?Â
âUGHâÂ
âAaaaand, which brother is it?âÂ
You throw your phone down into the pile of pillows, and roll over, groaning into the one under you.Â
The next week passes quickly. You have your appointment at the clinic, where they try to convince you to file a police report. You politely decline, resolved to grill Redbird relentlessly, whenever you can muster up the courage to call him.Â
You try to stay off your phone, but itâs a challenge. Several ignored texts from Conrad, and not one text at all from Jeremiah.Â
Youâve changed your mind a thousand times. Of course, youâre probably making the right decision to end things with Jere. It hasnât felt right in a while, and that isnât going to change now. But what about Conrad? You try not to let yourself think about it too much. Itâs too early, you tell yourself. It needs to wait.Â
Wait for what? You arenât sure.
Friday night, you have a sleepover with Taylor. Face masks, home manicures, and every Twilight movie, back to back to back. Youâre watching Bella fumble over her words, trying to get vampires and werewolves to get along, when you hear Taylorâs dramatic gasp. You look over, and see her looking at her phone, like sheâs seen a ghost.Â
âWhat?âÂ
âNothing.âÂ
âOkay, I know itâs not nothing. Show me.âÂ
âItâs bad.â she looks concerned.Â
You reach for her phone, âOk now you have to show me.âÂ
She slowly turns her phone to show you Lacie Baroneâs Instagram story. A selfie of her and Jere at some party tonight. A big lipstick print on his cheek matching her wine-coloured lips.Â
âYeah, thatâs pretty bad.â you agree, after a beat.Â
âHow are we feeling, 1 to 10?â Taylor asks cautiously.Â
Youâre already typing a text to him.Â
Have fun with Lacie. Donât fucking contact me again, asshole.Â
Send.Â
Was that too much? Maybe. Probably. You donât even know if anything happened with Lacie. Are you just looking for a reason?Â
Before you can stop the thought from occurring, you realize that youâre thinking about how much you want to tell Conrad.Â
Oh my god, you tell yourself, get a grip.Â
Late in the morning, Steven comes by with coffee and muffins. When he walks in the door, he gives you a knowing look. You glare at Taylor.
âYou told him??â
âHe's your brother.â
âDon't worry, I'm gonna kill him.â Steven says plainly, mid-bite into a muffin.Â
You chuckle before you can pretend to be unamused, âOk, you can stay.âÂ
You spend the afternoon with them, quiet and contemplative while they fill the air with conversation. For the first time in days, you start to feel like you might be where you should be, or close to it.Â
You decide you want to catch golden hour at the beach. You thank Taylor for everything, elbow Steven in the ribs, and make your way. It's not far of a walk from Taylor's place, and you arrive right as the sun glows orange, leaving everything on the beach basking in golden light. You snap a quick selfie, and post it on Instagram, and caption it:Â
glowing without you! #GoldenHour #BestSummerEver #StrongWomenÂ
Let Jeremiah see that.Â
You settle in on the sand, and watch the sun disappear into the ocean. Oranges, red, and pinks light up the night, and then, nothing. Something about it feels so poetic to you. Such beauty, lasting only a few minutes.Â
Now the sky is dark, and the cool, salty air feels sharp against your skin.Â
You hear him before you see him. His breathing, maybe. Or you just sensed him, who knows. But before you whip around, you already know what you'll see.Â
Big, green eyes stare at you, taking you in, swallowing you whole.Â
You stand quickly, trying not to let him see the electricity coursing through you.Â
âWhat are you doing here? Did you see my story and come here? What the fuck?â
âWhat? Your story?â He looks genuinely puzzled. âNo, I saw you from down the beach. Listen - â
âNo!â it rips out of your throat before you can stop it. âI am so tired of being told what to do. I can't do this right now, Conradâ
âYou've been ignoring me for days.â It's not an accusation, just a statement. Nothing but hurt in his eyes. He swallows slowly, like heâs forcing down something sharp.Â
âI'm scared!â you blurt out, regretting it instantly.
âScared of what?â His voice is soft. Too soft. Youâve ignored him for days and heâs still thinking of how you feel. He should be angry. He should bite back.Â
âWhat did you think was going to happen? That I was just going to leave my boyfriend of FOUR YEARS, Conrad, and hop into your bed?â
âI never said anything about my bed.â There it is, the flash of defensiveness.
âYou didn't have to! I know thatâs what you want. Thatâs always what they want.âÂ
âSeriously? Since when have I ever given you that impression? And since when have I been part of they?âÂ
âSince you fucking abandoned me, Conrad. I never see you anymore, and when I do, you keep me at armâs length. You barely even looked at me the other night while at Taylorâs. And now you want to text me every goddamn day?âÂ
âThings have changed, and you know it.â Thereâs fire in his eyes now, and it makes your veins feel icy.Â
You cross your arms over your chest, like youâre trying to contain something too big to hold.
âI canât do this,â you whisper.
âThen why are you here?â he asks. Still no anger, but maybe something close to desperation now. âWhy are you here, if not to talk to me?â
You want to snap at him, to push him away, but you canât seem to reach your anger anymore.Â
âI donât know,â you admit, your voice cracking. âI donât know what I want.âÂ
âYes, you do,â he urges, taking a step forward. âYou always know. Youâre just scared to say it.â
You canât believe how much you let this go off the rails. You shake your head. You want to argue, but heâs right, and thatâs worse than anything.
âI was with him for four years, Conrad. Four years.â
âAnd still, the second you needed someone - really needed someone - you called me.â
Youâre frozen in place. His eyes are soft, pleading.
He takes the opportunity to continue, âYou keep trying to act like this thing between us doesnât matter,â he says. âBut you know it does.â
âI donât know how else to protect myself,â you say, your voice so quiet it nearly disappears under the waves.Â
You remember that youâre supposed to be angry right now, and try to find it again.
âFrom me?â he asks. âIâve never wanted to hurt you.â
âBut you did, Conrad. You pulled away. You disappeared, and I didnât know why. And now you want to act like ⊠like Iâm the one who's broken this?â
He looks away, jaw tightening. You wonder if youâve finally pushed him too far.
âI was scared too,â he says finally. âScared to let myself feel it.â
The wind picks up, the silence growing heavy.
âYou think Iâm asking you to forget about him,â he continues, âbut Iâm not. Iâm just asking you to see me. Right now. Standing in front of you.â
You feel something fracture in your chest. The walls youâve kept up are coming down, fast.Â
âWhat if I canât?â you ask.
His voice drops to a whisper. âThen tell me to walk away.â
You donât. You wonât. You could never tell him that. But you have to say something to stop this.
âYou donât just get to love me when itâs convenient.â
He flinches, not from anger, but like you just cracked something open inside him.
âItâs never been convenient,â he says, searching your eyes, âbut itâs been realâ
He pauses.
â...for me.âÂ
You donât want to cry. You want to run. But your voice comes out anyway, trembling.
âIf I love you, Iâll lose everything.
The moment stretches - sharp and silent. Something hangs in the air between you.
âYou already have.â
It hits like a wave to the chest.
You canât look at him. You turn, and walk away - your footsteps loud on the sand, his silence louder.
You donât look back, but you know heâs still standing there, watching you disappear.
Dividers by @enchanthings-a
Part 3 posted on my new account! Sorry for the confusion if you follow me here! I'm using @somethin-sparklyy now.









