The Joestars (parts 1 - 6)
With a shy fem!Reader (who might have a crush on them)
Jonathan notices you staring at him from behind a tree a few times far too late, no matter how obvious you thought you were being. But once he does notice, it’s over for you — somehow he becomes aware of your presence every single time afterward, like a sixth sense.
At first, he’s genuinely flattered. In his mind, such a sweet-looking person must simply be trying to become friends with him, and in true gentleman fashion, he politely attempts to approach you… only for you to vanish before he can even say hello.
Eventually, Jonathan starts treating you the way one would treat a frightened rabbit or deer: gentle movements, soft smiles, never cornering you, always letting you decide the pace. (After a few attempts to call out to you from across the fields that is).
And after enough failed escape attempts and nervous eye contact, you finally manage to approach him yourself. Jonathan acts completely normal about it despite internally feeling like he just won a war.
Joseph notices you “accidentally” bumping into him one too many times and immediately clocks that it’s way too frequent to be coincidence.
Naturally, his first response is to flirt with you so aggressively that you short-circuit on the spot and flee before he can even finish his first sentence.
The problem? Joseph is absolutely oblivious to why you keep avoiding him afterward. He genuinely thinks he’s being charming. It takes Caesar spelling it out for him:
“She likes you, idiot. You’re scaring her.”
After that, Joseph tries to tone himself down around you. He really does. Unfortunately, he can’t maintain restraint for longer than thirty seconds before slipping back into his loud, animated, overly expressive self.
Still, your shyness only motivates him more. He keeps trying to coax reactions out of you — teasing comments, stupid impressions, dramatic storytelling — until one day you finally laugh at one of his jokes.
And Joseph genuinely freezes. Weak at the knees. Suddenly he’s the flustered one.
Jotaro knows you’re staring at him before your eyes even meet.
At first, he treats you like any other admirer. You linger nearby, avoid direct interaction, stare too long — typical fangirl behavior. He’s irritated by your presence, though he does silently appreciate that you never invade his personal space the way others do.
Still, something about you catches his attention.
Unlike everyone else, you never force conversations, never chase after him, never try to sit too close. You just… observe from afar before disappearing whenever he notices you.
Over time, Jotaro starts unconsciously memorizing little things about you.
The way you feed stray kittens on your walk to school every morning.
How you bite your nails before exams without even realizing it.
He notices all of it despite pretending not to care.
Jotaro receives countless gifts and confession letters from classmates, most of which go straight into the trash unopened. So when he finds a carefully decorated homemade cookie box sitting on his desk after first period, accompanied by a tiny note reading “From Y/N”, even he pauses.
And instead of throwing it away, he quietly stores it in his bag.
Josuke is so oblivious that it takes half the school gossiping before he even considers the possibility that you might like him. And even then, he refuses to believe it.
But once even Okuyasu catches on, Josuke can’t deny it anymore.
He acts casual about it, but internally? Massive ego boost.
Josuke starts trying to talk to you more often, though unlike Joseph, he’s slightly gentler about it. Unfortunately, you still panic and run away half the time, which sends him spiraling into self-doubt.
Did he say something weird?
Did he make you uncomfortable?
The more he thinks about you, the more attached he becomes without even realizing it. Eventually, Josuke starts learning how to approach you carefully — giving you room, letting silences happen naturally, waiting for you to come closer instead of chasing after you.
And honestly? That patience is exactly what makes him fall for you completely.
Giorno realizes almost immediately that you have feelings for him.
It’s in your heartbeat, your breathing, the way your voice changes whenever he asks for your opinion during missions. He notices every tiny reaction with frightening accuracy.
Still, Giorno doesn’t actively pursue conversation at first. He’s too focused on his dream to let himself get distracted by romance.
But whenever you gather the courage to speak to him, he gives you his full attention without interruption. And somehow, that calm focus makes it easy for even someone as shy as you to relax around him.
Little by little, your nervous stammering turns into rambling conversations. You start talking more freely, smiling more openly, forgetting to be afraid around him.
And Giorno grows unexpectedly fond of it.
He begins looking forward to your small rants, your animated expressions, the way your eyes light up when you get excited. To the point that Gold Experience unconsciously starts producing tiny carnations nearby whenever you’re around — a silent reflection of Giorno’s feelings.
The first time Jolyne catches you staring at her from across the prison cafeteria, she points directly at you and shouts,
“Quit staring at me like a creep!”
The immediate panic on your face makes her regret it almost instantly.
When you abruptly leave to calm yourself down, Jolyne sits there feeling weirdly guilty before eventually tracking you down to apologize — though she’s painfully awkward about it.
“Uh… I didn’t mean it like that. You just startled me, okay?”
It takes hours before you finally stop trembling around her like a frightened animal, but once you do, Jolyne starts finding your shy nature strangely adorable.
She becomes softer with you without even noticing it herself. Less teasing, quieter tone, gentler body language. She starts casually sitting near you during meals, offering you snacks, nudging your shoulder whenever she wants your attention.
And every single time she manages to make you smile without scaring you off, she feels ridiculously proud of herself.
areudirty
izzy806
stormborns
romaincrisis
titsay
ellievsbear
vaporwave
gummygunk
