Strap the fuck in, y’all. We’re about to go on a wild ride.
On Friday I had a date planned for 8 at the San Pedro Market Square in San Jose. For some background, I messaged Andria on Okcupid because her profile said she is gay and interested in writing. She told me she’s Latina, which made me confident that a “date” would be fun. I didn’t expect anything romantic, and was just looking for conversation and some company.
I showed up 15 minutes early because mami taught me that if I wasn’t 10 minutes early I was late. 5 minutes before we were meeting up I got a text from Andria, Okay so I’m actually running super late :( does 9 work for you?
I responded, I was in Salinas and drove up already, but don’t stress it. I’ll be here whenever you get here :)
I felt unbothered; I was in a particularly good mood and glad for the time to take selfies. I put up a video of me appreciating me on IG, and responded to messages from friends hyping me up. Then I sat in my car to charge my phone a bit and watch some DOTA videos.
At 8:30 she texted again to say she was there, so I went down to meet her. She got a beer (and offered me a drink), but I told her that I was good and didn’t need the alcohol. We sat down on the brick steps in the middle of the open courtyard and started talking. We bonded over both of us having ADD.
After an hour of talking about anything and everything that popped up, we decided to try to find a tall building to appreciate the Downtown View. We walked towards 3rd Street, until she stopped me and yelled, “We should go into Olla!”
Now she mispronouned ‘Olla’, and I had to ask what she was talking about. She pointed out the restaurant and I asked, “Olla Cocina?”
She looked a little embarrassed, but said, “I don’t know the first word, but the second means kitchen right?”
“It’s literally ‘Pot Kitchen’,” I laughed and we walked in.
She ordered elote, and I ordered ceviche. Once we got our food I joked, “This is the type of place that preys on white hipsters.”
“Well, I could go in the hood and get 3 times the food for half the price. White folk are too scared to get the good shit though.”
She seemed defensive about my explanation and pushed me to say more. My answer insulted her sensibilities, and she asked, “What’s the difference between appreciation and appropriation anyway?”
I should have let the subject go, but I assumed that she agreed with me. She’d been very clear that she disliked Trump because she was a feminist, and that she disagreed with her parents about their hatred of Mexicans and her dating women.
Instead, I tried to answer. I told her that if the owner was Latinx, or if they employed Latinxs, that I supported them getting their cash no matter who they got it from. I continued, “It’s admirable that you want to educate people about your culture, but I’m not the person that can have ‘Devil’s Advocate’ conversations. That’s the kind of thing that white men pulled on me at Vassar way too often, and I’m tired of repeating it.”
To me, I’d made it very clear that I didn't want to continue the conversation, but she took it as a slight bump on her journey to ‘get me riled up’.
“What if someone wants to understand your culture, and they’d support you if you spent time to educate them? Like I hate Trump, and I can’t believe I’m saying this, but don’t you want to spend time to understand him?”
Her riling me up worked, and I’m not sure what I said next. I know my eyes rolled so far back that mami would have slapped me, and that I was completely fucking done. I offered to pay for dinner and told her I was meeting friends to go out dancing. She invited herself to walk with me, and continued asking about educating ignorant people.
I responded, “If they want to understand there’s art like Get Out. It showed everyone else a black man’s perspective of racism.”
“Oh I didn’t watch that movie, I thought it was stupid to make fun of racism like that.” I hadn’t been surrounded by that much whiteness since dealing with blizzards in Poughkeepsie. I didn’t respond, and she continued, “Like do you remember learning about the holocaust? I was so heartbroken and wanted to write something serious about it. I should be able to if I want to support those people.”
We got to the bar and I told her, “I’m done with this conversation. I’m gonna meet my friends.”
She started crying, grabbed my hand, and said, “You can’t go! You hurt my feelings and made me feel like I’m a bad person. You have to fix this.” That level of entitlement seemed almost childlike, and I felt bad enough to agree.
“You have one minute to get some closure then I’m meeting my friends.”
“What about this did you hate?”
I hadn’t had this kind of conversation since Vassar, and never to this extent. I’d never talked to someone who pretended to care so strongly while prioritizing their own feelings above all else. I tried to explain again every single thing that I’d disliked: that she couldn’t disregard how other people presented their experiences, that I’d made it clear I didn’t want to have that conversation and she’d pushed anyway, and that her perspective came from her being perceived as a white woman (as I was often perceived as white).
She yelled, “I told you I’m 75% Mexican! You can’t ignore my identity and call me white!”
“I said other people perceive you as white, and you’re playing the victim now.”
“I am the victim here! I have such a big heart and you’re calling me out on all these things and won’t even take the time to help me grow.”
I’d told friends earlier that night that nothing could ruin my mood, but at that moment I started crying. Not because I felt bad for her, but because I was so frustrated in trying for a whole night to explain to someone that they should care about other’s feelings and ownership of their identities and failing. I felt scared because she is the type of dangerous ally that enters spaces to center themselves, and she was so good at hiding it.
I brushed the tears away, smiled, and said (honestly), “I hope you have a good night.”
She yelled back, “NO YOU DON’T!”
I joke that I don’t fuck with white people, and when I say that I’m thinking of people like Andria. They can be (75%) Mexican and gay, but if their experiences as white folk make them incapable of understanding or caring or even listening, I don’t fuck with them. Online dating makes this shit hard because most people on there are white, but I’m completely fucking done even trying.
I’d much rather be lonely than date a person that cannot understand me and my friends.