No hate to any Cullen fans. There are incredibly valid reasons to hate this man and they’re all canon.
There was Cullen discourse on twitter the other week and it was SUPER dismissive of the perspective of people who hate him. Like his writer wrote him as a creep and potential sex offender and the Cullen fans were saying “Actually HE is the victim” as if he was the only person tortured and that his captivity absolves him of the wrongs he done in his templar service to that point.
Also they spun him being a templar as if he was taken from his family when that boy LEFT said family WILLINGLY to join the templars. He signed up for the magic police academy, and yes templars are cops. because they arrest mages, abduct mages, and police the mages.
His 180 against Meredith at the literal last second got brought up as a heroic moment like he wasn’t marching to annul mages regardless of Hawke’s decision. Discounting however many dozens of mages he helps torture, murder, or worse tranquilize over the decade that DA2 covers. He outright tells a Hawke that COULD be a mage that Mages aren’t people. complete depersonification only to “change” and tell the Inquisitor to abandon mages for templars, that the mage rebellion isn’t worth saving only the templars should be chosen for the breach, but that’s “deprogramming’ from his ‘indoctrination’ despite being in lock step with his views from his entire adult life.
and the fact that his ‘redemption’ is kicking the addiction that comes with his choice to join the templars is used to wash him of his murderous, torturous, and oppressive ways is sickening. Oh his lyrium addiction is so tough, choosing the templar specialization lays that out for the Inquisitor but that in no way equals even the life of Karl from Anders’ intro quest, a fully harrow mage turned tranquil, a complete violation of his person and his life. As knight Captain Cullen oversaw and stood by those things and only saving mages and going above and beyond to COUNTERACT his behavior is redemption.
Like enjoy the guy as much as you want, I used to before I played the first two games, romance him, smooch him, lust after him, ship him whatever, but don’t ignore and twist what he has done to suit a narrative of ‘he actually didn’t do anything wrong’ when the lives of hundreds of people ruined at his hands say otherwise.








