Small discussion of Gender and Queerness and Community in relation to Plurality and Fictionkin experiences, under a cut so I don't clog anyone's dashboard with my ramblings. extremely brief extremely passive mentions of abuse/grooming but zero detail.
We came out as trans when we were young, young enough that trans issues weren't in the spotlight, or even discussed on tumblr. I don't say that as some strange exclusionist convoluted bragging right, but because I want to snowball it into discussing the fact that we've had, not issues or struggles, but questions about our own gender for quite literally as long as we can remember.
We didn't really have words for it, what are you supposed to say in elementary school when someone asks why you want to play the Prince in the school play and not the Princess, 'I just don't feel like a Princess' would have been accurate I suppose, but we didn't have the language even for that really, 'I just want to' was probably the answer we gave.
I'm sort of lucky, one of my cultures (an indigenous north american nation) doesn't have gendered pronouns at all, that's probably part of why we enjoyed spending time with our father's side of the family so much, other reasons notwithstanding. So I didn't need to think about it passively there much.
But here's the thing, 'I just don't feel like a Princess' would have been accurate, but only accurate-ish, because here's the thing, sometimes we do, absolutely, feel like the Princess.
All of that to say we've been thinking about our gender since like, easily first grade or earlier, so we've had plenty of time to think about it.
Offline we call ourselves trans, or just 'I'm a trans man', it's simple, requires little extra explanation, and all of us are okay enough with he/him when people don't know of our plurality that it doesn't feel like anyone's being gut punched, if someone gets to know us really well, we'll say, 'I'm gender-fluid', and that's where it ends.
These days, we try not to entertain being in spaces online, servers anyway, that aren't respectful of plurality, we do so much masking in our day to day that we don't really care to in our leisure time, and we fought so, so hard to become ourselves, to find out who we are, after a period of time when who we are as a whole was being warped by abuse and grooming, it would be a waste to not be our most authentic self/selves now.
The fact of the matter is, even in queer spaces, our gender just isn't one we can really get indepth into, because it is impossible to explain without going 'well there's enough people in our skull to comfortably fill a small village, so I would describe our genders as; it depends who you're asking'.
And then it gets even more detailed, okay who are you asking, Chilchuck?
Well, his gender isn't human in most ways, his society's concept of gender wasn't reliant on sex at all, his entire species is gynandrous, and gender is an extremely multifaceted fluid state of being that can change on a dime depending on a variety of factors; social standing, dominance hierarchy (and that itself isn't even how humans would fully understand it, there's no misinterpreted wolf theory here), how many assets you have, if you have children with someone else do you prefer to carry the litter or not, or do you prefer to split that task a certain percentage, or do you just want to help your family and friends raise theirs, or do you want nothing to do with them at all?
He literally doesn't even have framework to discuss it within, because 'Male, Female, Man, Woman, Nonbinary' aren't even relevant talking points for most of his species, there are exceptions of course, he absolutely knew other halflings who saw elven or tall-man genders and went 'oh yeah that's it for me', but for the most part, there's just no way for him to convey the concept to someone outside his own species, he doesn't really mind that, it's rarely relevant and he's comfortable with any pronouns.
But how do you explain that? How do you go, 'well, to understand my gender, you must first understand all these concepts that we probably can't even really explain perfectly' and Chilchuck isn't the only one, many of us, probably most of us, aren't human, and of them many of them don't really fit neatly into human understandings of gender, even like deeplore queer theory understandings of gender.
In plural spaces, it's usually pretty easy for people to understand, 'your gender is effected by who you're asking, because you are a myriad of different people', in queer spaces, it's nearly impossible to do so without just outing ourselves as plural, which we don't care to do in most spaces.
As a queer person, it can already feel very isolating just to be yourself, finding spaces that are for you can feel like a nightmare if your identity is one of the lesser known or less understood ones, I won't even get into detail about the rise of transphobia in otherwise queer friendly spaces and how all of that fits into the loneliness of the queer experience.
As someone who is Queer and Plural, those spaces shrink even further, to even begin to explain the framework of your identities, you must first explain your plurality, if you're queer and plural and fictionkin, what's left? Very few public spaces, you can use tumblr, clearly I do, but that can feel very vast and ironically almost make the loneliness issue worse.
Overall, I wish that these states of being (being Plural, past lives being passively respected even if not believed in, etc) were just the tiniest bit more accepted in mainstream spaces, because until and unless they are, we, and people like us, simply have to accept that even in extremely accepting spaces, we're probably going to have to just wholesale lie about our identities.
And furthermore, I wish there were more spaces to discuss things like this with people who are in the same situation. That whole 'My gender is complex because of my plurality, because of my kin status'
For a long time I actively ran a huge 21+ server for fictionkin and plural folks, and lately I've been feeling the itch to get it going again in earnest, because even though it was insanely hard work to run, I think people deserve the community, and because selfishly, I want to be able to go, 'here are the nuances of my experiences being alive', and to not have to first explain the entirety of my religion from square one in order for our gender to even begin to be perceived correctly.