Apparently it doesn’t matter that Sam Winchester grew up following his brother. That he’s looked up to Dean, his entire life. That he dresses like Dean, even when it’s not hand-me-downs, and they speak similar, and drive similar. Hell, they mostly even fight similar.
Sam’s always known that they’re different.
This isn’t bacon versus salad shake. It isn’t about Sam getting up for sunrises, and Dean going out for the sunsets. It isn’t orange or red plaid, or a beard versus none.
Point is, they’re fundamentally different.
(Even John knew it. After all, he never treated his boys the same.)
Dean and he have always dealt with loss differently.
When Sam dies, Dean sells his soul, and would do it again. But when he loses Sam, he hangs up the gloves and goes back to Lisa.
When Dean dies, Sam runs away to Ruby, Amelia, anyone. But when he loses Dean, he changes into every monster’s worst nightmare. Becomes the dread of a demon’s dreams.
Sam and Dean could not be more different, when it comes to losing the people they love.
When Cas dies, Dean gives up.
When Jess died, Sam started hunting again.
Two brothers, who keep choosing each other over the world - does that mean they’re the same? It’s never meant that.
Then how does Dean assume they want the same things, now?
How can he decide that they’re done - and think Sam should feel the same way? When they’ve never felt the same way about these things.
When Cas is gone again, Dean wants to quit. He wants to stay with Cas’s coffin, the Mal’ak box - and with Cas’s voice within, until either withers away or dies. He can’t let Cas be alone. Dean promised him he wouldn’t.
But when Eileen is gone, Sam wants to fight. He wants to chase the monsters, and go after the worst of the world. He doesn’t want to stop.
He wants to make it right.
And he’ll keep going, whether or not Dean comes with him.
When Dean says stop, he means peace.
When his world falls apart, Sam doesn’t even know what that is, anymore. He only knows anger, and he only knows pain. He only knows might.
Castiel sits staring at and slowly turning his cold, quarter-cup of quite terrible black coffee.
A quarter to the right; three quarters left; back to centre; repeat.
According to the nineteen-seventies-made Abelo clock on the wall, he has now been ensconced in this squeaky vinyl booth aside the large and grubby window for precisely one hour, eleven minutes and forty-three seconds.
Forty-four; forty-five; forty-six; forty-seven...
The dismal truck-stop diner, Susie’s, just outside of Soda Springs, Wyoming, is seemingly not a popular spot. The server—Susie? Castiel didn't look at her name badge—has refilled Castiel's cup twice by this point, but has left him to stare blankly out into the gloaming and juxtaposing amber glow of the newly blinking street lamps for a while now.
tick-tock, tick-tock, tick-tock
Castiel has counted sixty-one vehicles drive past in the time he's spent in this dreary place.
Sixty-two. This one is a motorcycle.
What now?
He pointedly ignores the question.
Yet again.
Having no answer to it is beginning to irritate Castiel.
tick-tock, tick-tock, tick-tock
Sixty-three. This latest car is a vintage model. It's big and black and not unlike—
Castiel clears his throat, peering down at the coffee. He now knocks it back, pouring the stale bitterness down in one gulp, wincing slightly before placing the cup back onto the Formica table-top.
tick-tock, tick-tock, tick-tock
A quarter to the right; three quarters left; back to centre; repeat.
Whilst aware and fully able to hear all that's occurring both inside and outside of the establishment he is currently wasting his time in, Castiel hasn't really listened to anything particular in a while, instead letting the sound waves or "ambiance" simply wash over him like a stream's current. Zoning out was the term that Dean—
Castiel shifts in his seat, lips pressed together into a neat line. He's just... he needs to be occupied, is all. He tries filling his head with only thoughts of the the nearby case he'll begin work on tomorrow morning.
tick-tock, tick-tock, tick-tock
Then at eight twenty seven, twelve seconds post meridiem and counting, a new sound slices through the monotony. A vaguely familiar sound.
Castiel is now very much listening.
"no one knows what it's like
to be the bad man
to be the sad man
behind blue eyes"
At once sardonically amused, Castiel almost laughs aloud at the uncanny parallelism to his circumstance which he hears in the lyrics of the song being played through Susie’s speakers.
This one could have been written for him, as Dea—he would've said.
However, the sharp blade of such cosmic mockery then cuts painfully deeper with the cruel words that follow:
"no one knows what it's like
to be hated
to be fated
to telling only lies"
Filtered into quiet, tinny musings via the diner's kitchen radio, all amusement previously attached to the song lyrics becomes at once sickly and beguiling to Castiel.
tick-tock, tick-tock, tick-tock
Billions of humans know what it is to be hated. The species hate on a level that can rival even Lucifer's hatred of his—and Castiel's—Father. The atrocities people will commit in the name of hatred is unparalleled. But for Castiel to be hated by him...
The only one who matters
tick-tock, tick-tock, tick-tock
Sixty-four. A Winnebago.
Castiel thinks about not taking his phone out from his coat. Ruminates over checking or not checking.
He turns his empty cup again.
A quarter to the right
Sixty-five. A modern, silver two-seater. He doesn't know the model.
Ignoring a glare from the previously friendly server—who has no doubt now become disgruntled at Castiel's lack of a food order—he slips a hand slowly into the pocket of his trenchcoat like he's performing some unsavory act. Runs an unsure fingertip over the slim edge of his cell.
tick-tock, tick-tock, tick-tock
Three quarters left
Castiel's hand grips the casing. It's cool to the touch.
I'm the one who gripped you tight and raised you from perdition
tick-tock, tick-tock, tick-tock
Flips it over in his palm.
Sixty-six. A truck pulling in.
Back to centre
tick-tock, tick-tock, tick-tock
Castiel closes his eyes and he can hear it again, like Chopin's Sonata No.2…
"The plan changed, Dean. Something went wrong. You know this. Something always goes wrong."
"Yeah, and why does that something always seem to be you?”
tick-tock, tick-tock, tick-tock
Repeat
His phone is half-way out of his pocket…
"but my dreams they aren't as empty
as my conscience seems to be
I have hours, only lonely
my love is vengeance
that's never free"
Castiel was wrong. The song isn't only about him. It is not only he who has done wrong. Just like it's not only up to Castiel to fix what's broken. It wasn't him who broke it, not this time.
"no one knows what it's like
to feel these feelings
like I do
and I blame you"
This part of the song is all Dean's.
tick-tock, tick-tock, tick-tock
Sixty… how many?
tick-tock, tick-tock, tick-tock
Quarter to the right? Or is it—
Castiel loses his grip on the cup and it slides along the Formica, careering from the table and falling to the floor, the ceramic handle breaking as it lands just off to the right of his feet.
"no one bites back as hard
on their anger
none of my pain and woe
can show through"
And, just like that, the song is Castiel's again.
He allows the phone to slide back into his pocket and now filters out all noise, not wanting to hear the rest of the words. Instead, he tunes into the white-noise of angel radio, fully aware he won't hear anything from his own near-extinct kind. There are too few left of those he had once thought of as his brothers and sisters. Heaven is fading by the day.
In all of creation, Castiel has never felt so alone.
After retrieving the cup and its handle and placing them down gently on the table-top, Susie or Not Susie glares at him once more. This time, Castiel glares back.
The server doesn't look in his direction again.
Forcing himself to tune back into the diner—back into the world—Castiel heaves a breath he doesn't have to take but has never needed quite so much.
He leaves enough bills on the table for both the coffee and the broken cup, also leaving his last dregs of hope behind for what once was.
Move on, Castiel
He steps out into the evening and as the diner door is closing, he just catches the last verse of The Who song, the very same one that an old friend—the man Castiel had believed loved him—had once played to him through shared earplugs.
"no one knows what it's like
to be the bad man
to be the sad man
behind blue eyes"
_____________________________
written for @misha-moose-dean-burger-lover's @angsty-angstweek and
inspired by the who's "behind blue eyes".
p.s. chopin's sonata no.2 is more commonly known as "the death march" and was tradtionally played at funerals.
“Make my hand three inches,” Malcolm mumbles, looking around for the solution.
It’s not too late.
Images of Ainsley’s body, butchered fill his head.
It’s not too late.
“Hammer,” he says as he sees his solution.
It’s not too late.
His mother, her lips trying to form his name as she bleeds out, lays in front of him.
“You're not real,” he says, laying his hand flat.
It’s not too late.
“One… two…” he takes a deep breath before bringing the hammer down on his hand.
Upon impact, he involuntarily wails, unable to stop until he’s out of air.
It’s not too late.
There it is. He made his hand three inches. Malcolm a piece of fabric around his broken hand before picking up a crowbar with the other, because it’s not too late.
His ears fill with ringing and fuzz like static from a TV as he crawls up from under his house to save his family.
The words that leave his mouth don’t go through any sort of filter as he yells. It’s pure instinct “Watkins! I know you’re here. This is my house. My family.”
It’s not too late.
If there’s any response, he doesn’t hear it.
He hears his blood pumping. He hears static. He hears Dr. Whitly, almost taunting him.
It’s not too late.
Then he sees it. Ainsley’s blonde hair turned red. The life slowly draining from her eyes. Oh God. He can’t look away from his sister’s pleading eyes. Not until they go blank.
Not until he hears his mother begging. Not with Watkins for her life, but with Malcolm. To turn around and save her, because Watkins has her pinned.
“You don’t have to do this,” Malcolm says, stopping a few feet from Watkins, trying to keep his anger at bay.
It’s not too late.
Maybe he couldn’t save Ainsley, but he can save his mother. Malcolm glances at the crowbar gripped tightly in his hand, the thought crossing his mind.
“You can end this,” Dr. Whitly is back. “We can end this, my boy.”
“No,” Malcolm’s voice is quiet, but stern as he argues with the hallucination.
He’s not real. He’s not here. Malcolm doesn’t have to listen to Dr. Whitly.
“Watkins,” Malcolm says, trying to buy himself- his mother- more time.
To talk Watkins out of this.
Watkins looks over his shoulder at Malcolm, a crazed look in his eyes. Then he brings the axe down. Then again. And again.
Jessica’s cry rips through the air, drawing Malcolm from the thin veil of shock that settled over him. He sees red and not just from the blood that sprays from his mother’s body as Watkins withdraws the axe.
It’s too late.
“Finish it,” Dr. Whitly hisses.
Malcolm doesn’t tell himself that Dr. Whitly isn’t here. That he isn’t real. Because for once in his life, Malcolm welcomes the voice.
Dr. Whitly glances at the crowbar in Malcolm’s hand, reminding him it’s there. His knuckles are white, yet he somehow grips the crowbar tighter. Then he makes the decision, closing the space between him and Watkins as Watkins brings the axe down once more.
It’s too late.
Watkins doesn’t notice how Malcolm nears him. No, he’s too caught up in the thrill of the kill. Watkins doesn’t notice- at least until the crowbar comes in contact with his head, sending his body crumbling to the ground. Then again as Malcolm lets his rage take control.
It’s too late.
Malcolm’s own senses take over. Oh God. He drops to his knees, landing in Watkins’ blood, kneeling in front of the body.
“No,” Malcolm realizes the weight of what he just did.
Of how easy it came to him. How instincts took over. How he listened to that voice inside his head that he claims to hate. How he killed John Watkins.
After all, he is his father’s son, and it’s too late.
This my angst re-do. Or maybe just another submission for the angst-angsty week challenge. Approx. 1.5K. Warnings: Drug use. MCD. Sadness inducing.
He kicks his legs out harder, trying to chase that flying feeling Cas always talked about. Dean grips the metal links tighter letting the cool metal bite into his hands. He breathes the chilly night air deep into his lungs. Call him crazy for swinging on the swings in the middle of the night, but it’s the only place he can come to think. The only place he feels close enough to Cas.
Dean closes his eyes while leaning back letting the swing rock him back and forth, unaware he’s holding his breath until he needs to take another. Memories play on repeat behind his eyelids; memories of an utter troublemaker who just happened to be his best friend with his way too blue eyes that were too wide for his face, his gummy smile that made his nose wrinkle too, and his stupid perpetual messy dark hair. Dean opens his eyes to the twinkling stars letting the burn in his lungs settle. Peeling his eyes from the endless sparkles, they land on the empty swing next to him.
Fuck. Staring at the empty swing too long is too much. Instead, Dean sets his eyes forward again and kicks off the ground once more falling into the familiar motions of swinging. He remembers how Cas loved the weightlessness that came from swinging. How Cas always joked about how having his feet off the ground felt like freedom; felt like anything was possible when he was propelling himself through the air. Dean tries to feel it. The freedom, the weightlessness, the possibility of anything, but in the end, numbness wins out.
The swings squeak and rattle underneath his weight but he could care less. Damn things have probably never seen a can of WD-40. If the swing broke now and he ends up a pile of mangled limbs, it wouldn’t be the worst thing to happen to him he thinks. A memory tickles the back of his mind as he feels reaches the highest the swings will allow him to go without toppling over. He’ll jump on the next back and forth. He’ll sail through the air for a fleeting seconds before hitting the ground.
When his feet touch the ground, his knees protest the jump with an audible crack. He’s half-expecting for Cas to wind up beside him. Dude always crashed and burned when jumping off the swings, the last time ruining his favorite pair of jeans with some serious grass stains on the knees. Dean catches himself waiting. Waiting for Cas to grab his hand and pull him down to the ground so they both end up laughing their asses off while covered in dirt. A smile tugs at Dean’s lips thinking about the stupid grin that’d be on Cas’ face if he was here.
A shaky inhale is followed by a more affirmed exhale. While the swings were Cas’ favorite, they weren’t his special place. Dean turns towards the overpass which sits on the very edge of the park. The bridge hovering above a small creek which fed into the large river that ran on the outskirts of town. His feet move faster than he can brain can process. He ducks crawling up underneath the overpass like he’s done a hundred times in the past.
You’d think with his love for flannel, leather, muscle cars, and hair gel Dean would be the bad boy influence but nah, Cas most definitely was the bad influence. Dean turns in a circle soaking in the sight. Cas had brought him here when they were just beginning their friendship; they spent the night shivering their dicks off while sharing secrets. Something about being hidden away from the world made it feel safe to say anything, so they came here often to say all the things they couldn’t anywhere else—Dean’s dreams about being a musician, Cas’ about being an artist, school, girls, problems at home.
His heart lurches as he turns toward the slanted wall of the bridge. A beautiful black spray-painted feather accompanied by some really bad black smiley faces stares back him. He doesn’t remember moving, only coming back to himself as he watches his fingers trace along the flecking paint lines. The feather is still just as beautiful as the night Cas painted it. Dean imagines the warmth from Cas’ laugh as his finger trails over the little C-A-S.
He remembers when Cas put the letters next to the stem of the feather after finishing his masterpiece, only turn to watch Dean painting the worst smiley faces ever. His eyes crinkled with tears he was laughing so hard. Dean presses his forehead against the cold wall biting back a laugh at the memory. He gave Cas his best damn pouty face, the kid was an artist while Dean was a musician, of course, he’d be better with a can of spray-paint. The next few moments are etched into his brain the way his birthday is: Cas wiping the tears from his eyes as he steps into Dean’s pace, Dean’s breath hitching as Cas stopped centimeter’s from Dean, Dean flicking his eyes down to Cas’ lips like he had down a million times but this time finally swallowing his fear, Cas responding to his kiss with nothing but sheer eagerness.
Tears Dean didn’t know he was holding back silently slither down his face. He pushes himself up from the wall. That night after sharing their first kiss they just held hands smiling at each other like a bunch of freaking dorks, but neither his hand nor his heart felt warmer than they did at that moment. Now his hand is empty, and his heart feels cold. He wipes at his cheeks before tracing the feather one more time.
“I miss you,” he whispers.
He steps back letting his hand drop back to his side.
Cas was an artist. The kid had the talent to rival any famous painter. Cas’ passion in everything he did was one of the reasons Dean fell head over heels in love with him. Dean learned pretty quickly though that passion has a price. For Cas, he thought his best work happened when he was high. So, Cas chased all different kinds of highs—weed, pills, booze, sex with Dean. He chased and chased with Dean none the wiser about his self-destructive habits.
You never expect to fall asleep one night to wake up to your phone ringing repeatedly until you answer. You honestly never, ever expect the voice on the side to mutter he’s gone, he’s gone, Dean. Accidents happen, you just never think they’ll happen to you let alone your best friend turned the love of your life. Dean remembers crawling into Sammy’s bed after the call, like they did when they were little and had bad dreams, trying to process the information. He remembers how Sam rubbed his back being Dean’s rock while Dean’s whole body shook from sobbing.
Dean walks back to the Impala, the moonlight lighting his way. Climbing into Baby, he feels lighter. Being here, swinging on those damn squeaky swings, and seeing that beautiful feather makes it easier to remember the boy he loved rather than talking to some stupid headstone. He starts the car and waits for the radio to start playing before pushing the next button until their favorite song plays through the speakers. He hums along with lyrics and when Dean looks over at the passenger seat, he swears can see Cas muttering the words while tapping his finger against his leg. Smiling, Dean pushes the gas pedal down a little bit letting the purr of Baby’s engine guide him home.
When Dean arrives home, he opens his laptop and pulls up a blank document. He stares at the blinking cursor; it taunts him until he begins typing. He writes and writes, spilling his emotions onto the page. He doesn’t care if the words are bad or that some of the sentences don’t make sense. He just simply writes—writes their story like he has done every night since the accident three years ago.
Five years later
Dean flips open his laptop setting his mug of coffee down at the same time. He adjusts himself in his chair trying to get comfortable so he can put some words on paper tonight. He looks over at the beautiful hardcover book adorning a black feather on its cover resting on the top corner of the desk. Dean reaches out and pets the cover. He’s a published writer, wild he thinks. Leather and Feathers, their story, is Dean’s first published work. Sure, the characters are slightly different, the events definitely overexaggerated, but it’s still their story, although he did change the ending; everyone loves happy endings after all, and they damn well deserved one. He swears Cas wrote some of the book given how snarky and passionate some parts of it are.
Dean never thought as stares at that damn blinking cursor he’d ever be a writer, but now he’d never want to be anything else. He gets to write their story across every kind of alternative universe, rewriting the ending over and over again.
He gets to fall in love with Cas in every possible way his imagination can dream of all over again. He hopes Cas doesn’t think his stories are too cheesy. But every time he finishes one, he swears he catches Cas’ smiling face out of the corner of his eye.
Here’s my submission for @misha-moose-dean-burger-lover‘s angst week. Hope you enjoy, and make sure to check out @angsty-angstweek if you want more angst!
Plot: Sam and Dean have stopped God with the help of Cas taking on the Mark of Cain. But for the WInchesters, happy endings can’t last long. The Mark is starting to corrupt Cas. The brothers know he must be stopped, and that the Ma’lak Box is the only thing strong enough to hold the angel. But can Dean go through losing him again? (Takes place before what is shown of the Butch and Sundance ending in 15x09 The Trap)
Word Count: 1195
Sam had been doing nothing but bracing himself for the dam to break. He could only sit back and wait for the Mark to corrupt Cas, and now for Dean’s switch to flip. But until it did, Sam could only endure the silence in the Impala so much longer. So, he decided to turn on the radio.
“A gathering of angels appeared above my head
They sang to me this song of hope-”
Those were the only lines that Dean let play. He turned the radio off quicker than if a Celine Dion song had come on.
“Not a Styx fan suddenly?” Sam tried to joke, to no response. He felt odd trying to be the humorous one during a situation like this, but he wanted to do anything to lift the veil of awkwardness over them. Plus, he was too worried about his brother to have comprehended the night’s events yet. To him, it felt like Cas was still waiting for them, safe in the Bunker. He wasn’t trapped in the Ma’lak box, six feet under the same spot that the door to the Cage had been opened many long years ago.
Meanwhile, Dean’s eyes were on the road but his mind was back in the cemetery, reliving the burial.
Rereading the “On my way” from Cas made him panic. He should be here any minute now, and Dean wasn’t sure if he could follow through. How could he do this to him? Is locking him away for eternity really the best solution? What if he escapes like Jack did? What if the Mark’s not affecting him as much as Sam kept trying to convince him it was?
Cas’ truck pulled up so he put on a fake smile and kept reminding himself of what happened at the vampire nest. Sam’s right. Sam’s right. Sam’s right.
“Hello, Dean.”
Dean couldn’t look into the eyes of the angel as he handed him the purposely forgotten lighter. “Hey. Thanks, I must really be getting old if I forgot this.”
His gaze stayed on the holy oil circle on the ground, waiting until the black shoes entered it. Once they did, he lit it and watched the flames surround the angel.
“What is this?” He exclaimed.
“Look, Cas. I didn’t want it to be this way. But you have two options. Go into the Ma’lak box down there by choice, or by a spell from Rowena... I’m sorry, but you and I both know the Mark is too dangerous.”
Cas looked down at the box, and then Dean, the fire reflecting the hate in his eyes.
“I can’t believe this, Dean. After everything I’ve done for you! Everything we’ve been through. Here I was thinking you changed and actually cared about me. About us.”
Holding back tears, Dean struggled to repeat what Sam had been telling him. “The Mark makes you think you’re fine. But you’re not, Cas. You haven’t been yourself. Just look at what happened with the vamps. Trust me, I hate to do this to you. But it’s the only way. I’m sorry.”
“I don’t think you are,” was the last thing he said before Dean threw the spell onto the fire, making Cas fall into the box that closed above him.
“You can’t do this Dean!”, “Come on, it’s not too late”, and similar pleas got more and more muffled as Dean filled in the grave.
After wiping his eyes, Dean climbed into the Impala where Sam was waiting. “It’s done.”
The brothers reached the Bunker after the rest of the eerie ride home. They went straight to their rooms, not bothering to say their normal “good night.” Both were exhausted, but neither could fall asleep.
Laying in bed, the horror of what they had done to their friend started to settle in Sam’s mind, and so did doubt. Was I right to talk Dean into this? Was this seriously the only solution? Would Cas have really have caused any more harm? It was just vampires… No, it was right. We stopped him before he killed any innocents like Dean did. It was right-
The sound of footsteps interrupted his worries. He got up to follow them and made his way to the kitchen since he saw the light was already on. He found Dean grabbing the Impala’s keys.
“Dean?”
“We need to go back, Sammy. I...”
“Look, I know this isn’t easy, but we can’t just go unbury the box. You know what will happen if we do.”
“It’s all only possibilities! We’ll deal with whatever happens, if anything even does. We’ve dealt with freaking God!”
“Chuck only wanted to mess with us. Cas could have harmed anyone. You know what the Mark made you do. You know what Leviathan Cas did.”
“And we dealt with both! Cas has gave up everything time and time again for us, so dealing with the Mark is the least we could do for him.”
“I know, but all of that wouldn’t excuse the harm he’d cause. He was a ticking time bomb. This was the correct move, you’re not thinking straight since it’s him.”
“How the hell can you be so certain?”
“Because the box was the only thing strong enough to stop him!”
“I never should have made that damn thing. Look at what it caused with the kid…”
“Neither of us were thinking straight after losing mom. Acting on emotions has never done us good.”
“I don’t care. I’m going, but you don’t have to.” Dean said, his voice holding none of its previous emotion. He walked to the kitchen door but Sam jumped in front of it to block him.
“You’re not.”
“Oh come on, man,” Dean said, looking up at his taller brother. “We can’t leave Cas locked in a box for eternity!”
“We have to. I know it’s hard losing him. But please, just sit down. I’ll get us drinks and we can grieve the Winchester way. We just can’t rush into such a horrible decision.”
“You don’t know how hard it is! We have to get him out. I have to tell him…”
“Maybe I don’t, but I do know that who’s buried isn’t the Cas. You’d be talking to the Mark, not him.”
“Goddamnit,” Dean screamed, backing away. He went to the kitchen table, slamming down the keys before sitting down and putting his head in his hands.
“You’re right.” Looking up at Sam with tears filling his eyes, he continued, “It’s not him. It’s not the Cas that I… I loved. I loved him Sammy, but I couldn’t ever man up enough to say it... I’ll never get to tell him.”
“I’m sure he knew,” Sam replied while grabbing two beers from the fridge. He was surprised, but glad, that his brother was finally being so honest with him.
“How could he have?”
“You two made it pretty obvious.”
“It’s still not the same as actually saying it.”
“Well, it’ll have to be.”
Sam handed him one of the drinks and joined him at the table.
They toasted “To Cas,” and Sam could swear he heard his brother mumble “I love you” before taking his first sip.
It's Sheya, here ~ This is the first Angsty-AngstWeek ever, so I'm going to start by describing the purpose of this blog! Here, I'll reblog all your pieces for the Week, so that we have a safe, easily-accessible compilation!
Later, if we do more Angsty-AngstWeeks, it will just keep getting added onto here. Until eventually, this becomes a hub of all the angstiest ficlets! A compilation of our nightmares!
I know I keep tagging you folks a lot these days, please don't get annoyed? I promise to stop. Soon.
And I also wanted to inform y'all that since Tumblr is such a wonderfully inept platform, known far and wide for it's dislike of tag-searches, please tag me in your ANGSTY-ANGSTWEEK posts.
I don't want to miss a single one, owing to the inefficiencies of our beloved hellsite. So, yeah. Thanks for hearing me out!
NOTES: 5.8k words. Not a happy ending. This is for ANGSTY-ANGSTWEEK. So, proceed only if you’re prepared. Warnings: Major Character Death, Suicidal Thoughts, Loss.
On September 15th, Dean Winchester buys a stack of Open-When cards from Archies.
They’re blank, but lined.
He knows Cas isn’t the biggest fan of his birthday, because it brings back sullen memories of a past he’s left behind - but he can’t just do nothing for his best friend’s birthday.
Ergo, he’ll just gift Cas those letters, and keep it mellow.
*
Come September 18, Cas wakes up to Dean holding a cake in his hands, giant grin lighting up his face.
Before Cas can even put on a shirt, Dean’s fixed a wobbly conical birthday hat on his head, struggling with the string until he just gives up and perches the hat indignantly on Cas’s unruly bedhair, and it stays.
“Happy birthday!” He beams, handing him the gift.
Cas smiles, not wholly because he feels the need to match Dean’s enthusiasm, but also a little bit for he can’t help it - as Dean waits expectantly for him to unwrap the now-thoughtfully-filled-in Open When cards.
“Oh!” Cas exclaims, when he understands what it is. “Thank you.” He adds, distractedly, starting to look through, without reading the contents.
There are three categories, and each has five cards. On top of the first, the ‘Open When You’re Sad’ bunch, is a handwritten birthday wish in pink. Cas flips to the second without opening the cards in the first, carefully, and that’s ‘Open When You’re Tired’. The last one says, ‘Open When You’re Lonely’. And there’s a red heart in the corner, which Cas stares at, with his cheeks warm, as Dean starts to speak.
“Y’know,” He mumbles, insecure. “I wanted to get you a gift which you don’t crumble in pressure, opening. No scope for awful, old memories with this one.”
Cas purses his lips.
Dean goes on. “So, there. You don’t even have to open these right now.”
“Thank you.” Cas repeats, feeling an overpowering rush of happy settle heavy in his chest. His eyes fall on the title, once again. “I really don’t.”
And then he scoots over on the bed so that Dean can sit down, and the first thing Dean does once they’re back in a huggable height range, is slide his arm around Cas, and squeeze.
“Of course you don’t. Happy birthday.” He repeats, as well.
They do eventually get on to cutting the cake, and later, while Cas tries to paint Dean with the blue icing, the latter briefs Cas about their minimalistic, yet also everything-Cas-like itinerary.
It’s a good day.
*
On November 6th, a truckdriver drives through the outskirts of Lawrence, Kansas. As his shabby radio plays Green Day, hooked to the local station, he curses at himself for spending all of the previous night in a bar. He knows he can’t afford to take a break either; delivery is due on the 8th.
When he hits the black Chevrolet Impala, emerging from an intersecting road into his lane, sidelights blaring exactly as they ought to - he swears out loud and immediately slams his foot on the brakes.
But it’s too late.
Within the very second of contact, the smaller vehicle had suffered damage beyond repair. Stuck in that moment of dread, it takes him a second to realize what just happened.
For a moment, he considers getting down to examine the wreck. Maybe someone was still -
No, that was ridiculous. The car was completely battered. If the crash had smashed the sturdy metal skeleton of the Chevy so horrifyingly, the driver must be in Heaven already.
He puts his head on the wheel. Muttering a prayer under his breath, he silently decides to keep driving.
After all, it’s an adequately busy road. Someone would get to the site sooner or later. There was no need for immediately medical services, either - or he tells himself, that he would’ve made an anonymous call. He has a family. He can’t risk the chance of being put away for this. And court always costs too much, as it is.
He drives on.
*
On November 6th, a few hours later, Cas receives a call from the General Hospital of Lawrence.
A serious voice informs him, punctuated by formal apologies and grave pauses, that Dean Winchester had been killed in an accident.
And in the next breath, he’s asked to confirm if he knew the man, since Castiel Novak’s listed as one of his emergency contacts, and the other, a Sam Winchester, is only in highschool, and cannot possibly be summoned for the purpose of identifying the body.
Cas cannot utter a sound for a few beats, but when his voice returns, it does so all at once; all that comes out is a strangled sob, which is supposed to be, “No!”
*
On November 8th, Castiel agrees to spend the night in Charlie’s apartment, after Dean’s funeral.
Ellen absolutely insists upon it.
All the way to her place, Charlie tries to talk to him. She’s gentle about it, but she needs Castiel to say something back; for she lost a friend, as much as he did.
Except, in a sway of feelings threatening to drown him, Castiel knows that she didn’t.
Nobody lost Dean as much as he did.
Because nobody had had him, as much as he did. Even before, they’d spend their days entwined with the other’s. And ever since Dean asked him out - September 20th - it had been even better. Dean had been everywhere, and Cas had loved it.
Castiel was the one who woke up next to him, and he was the person Dean first smiled at in the morning. Castiel was who kissed Dean at night, and hugged him in his sleep. Castiel was who shared an apartment with Dean, and had been doing it since the last three years. Castiel was his best friend, and his boyfriend, and -
Castiel was who’d lost him the most.
Tears start to prick his eyes, without a word said out loud - goddammit, he’s always so close to tears now.
Charlie notices. She’d been avoiding mentioning Dean - though ironically, he was the reason they knew each other. But now, it’s like she wants to address it. She looks the kind of crushed Cas feels.
“Cas? Are you okay?”
Cas doesn’t even bother to nod, as the tears start to fall.
During the funeral, he’d sat in the first row, next to Sam, who’d cried entirely through Bobby’s, and then Ellen’s eulogy. He’d even cried after, red-faced like Dean used to get, while shaking Castiel’s hand before he had to leave. Before Ellen packed him off to Charlie’s, worried about him spending the night all alone at his and Dean’s place. For the first time since it happened.
Castiel didn’t cry at the funeral. He was afraid he wouldn’t know how to stop. But now he does, and he still doesn’t know how to stop, but he can’t care anymore.
“Cas,” Charlie pleads. “I know it hurts, and I know you miss him, but we’ve got to -”
“Charlie, stop.” Castiel lets out, cutting her off. He knows it hurts, too. He knows he misses him, too. But he cannot hear her say the same things again.
He knows she cares, and he knows she’s doing it because she thinks it might help, but he doesn’t want to hear how they’ve got to be strong. About how they’ve got to hold up, because he can’t, he really fucking can’t.
“The car?” She asks, her voice trembling as well.
Castiel changes his mind. “Yes. Please, stop the car.” She does it, pulling over to the side, and turning her face to look at Castiel with red, teary eyes. Castiel knows she knows what he’s going to do.
“Cas, don’t go there.”
“I have to.” Castiel draws in a breath, and it somehow makes his chest feel more constricted. Like the air’s demanding space it doesn’t have anymore, for the heart has taken up all of it. “I - there’s some things I need to get, and I need to do this right now, Charlie, I have to go.”
He unclicks the lock open, and gets out of the car. But then he leans in, and looks back at her. “I’ll be at your flat by night.”
“Promise me you will.” Charlie bites her lip, and a tear rolls down her cheek. It’s awful to see his friends in pain. Everything’s awful, now. All of it.
“I promise.” Castiel swears. “Please drive safe.” He says, and those words make him lose the last bit of restrain he had over his emotions, and as he straightens from the waist to stop looking through the car window, his tears fall freely.
Drive safe.
“It was an accident.” The police officer had admitted. “Clearly a truck. We’re looking at camera footage from a mile ahead. I’m sorry, sir. It wasn’t his fault.”
Dean had been driving safe, too.
Castiel inhales, painfully.
Cheeks hot and neck hotter, his sleeves constantly dabbing at his eyes, and trying not to think, he takes off in the direction of their apartment.
He knows how it must look, a fully grown man running on the footpath, unable to stop crying, but he does not even think about it. He thinks about getting home. Castiel seeks refuge in all the shortcuts Dean’s ever taught him. He was so good at navigating, in even the newest parts of town. And at remembering directions. And roads. Driving safe -
Castiel forces himself to stop thinking, at once. He just allows his legs to take him, mostly functioning on muscle memory.
It’s not very far away.
Within minutes, he’s standing in front of their apartment building, and he’s buzzing himself in, but the elevator’s on the third floor - it’s useless to wait, so he sprints up the stairs to their fourth floor apartment.
When he’s panting in front of their door, somehow he remembers he has the keys in his pocket, and somehow his hands do the twisting in the lock, and some-fucking-how, Castiel is back inside this apartment and -
He has no idea what he’s been expecting, but Dean’s not here.
If anything, his absence strikes Castiel even harder here. There’s a lack of Dean in every nook. When Castiel locks the door behind him, there’s a lack of Dean by his side, maybe crowding him against the door with a teasing wink, and when Castiel turns, there’s no Dean on the couch, sprawled out, yet in the middle, so that whichever side Cas picks, they’re at least brushing knees.
When Castiel looks around, getting desperate, there’s no Dean in the kitchen, and no Dean in the hallway. There’s none of his bright smiles, or his awful jokes, or his ridiculous lines, or his full-body laughs.
There’s absolutely nothing of him at all. But yet, it’s all him.
Everything here’s his.
The couch, he’d bought, before Castiel moved in. The other furniture, they’d shopped for, together. The walls which they’d painted over summer, had Dean’s taste in color all over them. The curtains, if he listened hard enough, would probably complain about the millions of times Dean walked into them distractedly, and made the dreamcatchers jingle. Castiel can even bet there’s still leftovers in the fridge which Dean had saved.
And Castiel? Well, he’s Dean’s too, isn’t he?
Dean used to call Cas, his everything, sometimes.
Castiel lets out a sound of anguish, stranded in the middle of their apartment like he’s being held hostage by the memories, and gripping onto a chair to keep himself on his feet.
How is it fair that there can be so much of Dean around, but he can just be gone forever?
“Forever.” Cas repeats, the word pinning him down to that frame of time, but also making him want to fall to his knees and sob for the rest of his life. “Forever.” He says again, weaker, and it hurts even more. It pierces every inch of him with an icicle of despair, and it wrings his insides, and he doesn’t know what to do, and he can’t move.
He’s unbearably sad, and it nags at every fibre of his being like nothing ever has, and he’s tired, he’s tired of it all - he’s tired of missing Dean, and he’s tired of crying, and he’s tired of hurting, because it’s overpowering and it’s never going to subside - and of course he’s lonely; he knows he has friends and he knows he maybe even has a family, if he were willing to go back home - but truth is, he’s got nobody left in the world, for Dean is gone and -
Castiel suddenly remembers why he was here.
The letters.
He abandons his knuckle-white grip on the dining table chair, and rushes to their bedroom. Castiel doesn’t look at the bed - because he will never be able to get Dean out of his mind if he looks, and he doesn’t look at the photograph of them on his bedside table - though it takes a huge piece of his restrain to not do so.
He just pulls open the bottom drawer, and shuffles through things like flashlights and emergency coffee, until he’s found the Open When letters.
He picks up all three categories - because of course he needs all of them right now, and he gets up shakily, clutching all three bundles to his shirt and spends a moment to think of where he should do this.
(He can’t just settle on the bed, or the couch, or anywhere else they used to spend time together, because that’d be more harm than not.)
So, he decides to do it in their balcony.
Dean wasn’t a fan of that place.
“The air, dude.” Dean crossed his arms. “It’s so fucking chilly. And the floor’s freezing, all times of the year.”
He didn’t like being cold.
Castiel does not need to think about Dean wearing his coat right now. Or holding him under the blanket, and kissing the top of his head.
He convinces himself he cannot be thinking about any of it.
Castiel rushes out to the balcony, and the wind blows wintry, but it doesn’t matter, and he just sinks to the floor.
The three bundles are still clasped to his chest - he’s really counting on these, they’re his last option, and they have to help somehow, don’t they - so he leans back against the door, crosses his legs, and picks up the first bundle.
Open When You’re Sad
He flips to the first card. The handwriting is small, and fills every line of the 5x3 card.
Mostly, when Dean wrote notes to put up on the fridge as reminders, it was all uppercase. But this was a tidy sentence-case - distinctly Dean’s, as it were. It’s black ink, and the background is a faded peach, and Cas hangs onto every word.
“I guess you’re sad right now, Cas, and that’s no good. So here’s how I say you should deal with it. Often when we’re sad, we forget how many reasons we have not to be. How bout you think about something that makes you smile, something that gets you fuzzy, something that feels like pie?”
That’s all the space there is on the card, and Cas takes a moment to curse at the thick embossed floral boundaries, which take up so much of the space where Cas could have had words from Dean instead.
He rereads the card, for it feels surreal to have Dean with him for a moment again, but then he lets out a staggering breath. This isn’t working.
There’s no reason for him not to be sad, right now. None at all.
Dean was who made him smile, Dean was who got him fuzzy, and Dean was who felt like pie. This doesn’t help, it just makes Cas miss him even more. And it’s not like he needs that. He cannot get Dean out of his head for a single second, and -
He desperately flips to the next card.
“I hope you’re not just flipping through all of these at once. Okay, I’m going to assume that you’re not. And that implies that you’re sad again, so here’s what I suggest you think about: the happiest days of your life. I know you’re ridiculously indecisive, hence, the plural. Go back to those days in your head, Cas. Leave the sad behind. (Hey, am I in it?)”
The last question - now, although a rhetoric - makes Cas want to scream.
Had there been any doubt of it, in Dean’s mind? Of course, Dean was in it. Who else could it even be?
Cas may have been indecisive before, but he was sure now. His happiest days were all the ones with Dean at his side. All of them. From the birthdays to Christmas, and from being sick to panicky about a deadline.
Dean wasn’t just a part of his happiest days. It was all him.
And the irony is that he cannot do what Dean says, and think about those days, because that’ll break him down again, and he’ll end up crying all over these letters and ruining them.
Which he’s not going to let himself do. He’s saving these, forever.
He breathes in through his mouth, and swallows - maybe that way, he’ll not feel like he’s being choked, an inch closer to his life with each passing moment. And he tries not to pay attention to how this card doesn’t help either. Not at all.
Still hopeful, he flips to the next.
“Cas, remember the thing we did last time about your happiest days? Well, I want you to realize, this time, that the next one is never far away. There’s even hope for tomorrow, to make it onto that list. All of this shall pass. There’s always going to be hope. Ps. it’s probably because you’re not right in front of me, that I’m spouting Dr Phil lines. Well, I can’t throw away this card, but if you flip to the next, I’ll forgive you.”
This won’t ever pass.
There’s no hope now, and there’ll be none tomorrow, and with each day, Cas will have a little less of Dean with him, and that will make it worse, not better. With each day, the sound of Dean’s voice will grow fainter in his ears, and that hurts to even think about.
Cas doesn’t think he could ever bear losing Dean’s voice. He loves it.
He’s going to lose it.
He’s going to lose everything.
No, he’s already lost everything. It’s just going to be taken away from him, soon.
Cas bites his lower lip hard enough that it stings. Stings so hard, that he’s pulled out of his reverie.
Dean, this time, gave him permission to move onto the next card. So he does.
“Hey, again. This time, I want you to remember how much all of us love you, okay? And people who’re loved by this many people aren’t sad, buddy. You’re brilliant, and you care, and I know your heart. It’s so kind, Cas. You’re a great listener, and have a really nice smile, and you’re tall and hilarious and all kinds of awesome. You’ve got good taste for a nerd. And you’re loved by us all for exactly who you are. (Wow, I did a lot better in this card.)”
Cas sighs, pulling his knees to his chest and dropping his head on his knees.
How is he ever supposed to even begin to stop thinking about Dean? Dean, who says these things; Dean, who always knows just how to make everything okay -
Except for now.
Except for fucking now, when Cas needs it more than anything else.
Of course, this doesn’t make him feel better. He’s trying to let the words help, he swears he’s trying, but these are all the things Dean has written, and will never say again. In fact, he doesn’t care what Dean says, as long as he does. But he won’t.
Cas shakes his head to stop himself from drifting away into the cruelest thoughts. He wants to read ahead, he’s still holding out for something that’ll help, he just has to keep reading -
Nobody will ever understand him like Dean did. Nobody can be anything like what Dean was to him.
And he can never be, to anybody, what he was to Dean.
He can’t stop himself. He can’t stop a thing. That’s just his life, now. Trying to stop thinking about Dean, and failing each time. Forever.
Cas flips to the last card of this bunch, and starts reading, clenching his jaw.
“You once told me I make you happy, so here goes nothing. You want to know when I knew we were going to be friends forever? I want to tell you, but I’m really not sure. I remember it being a few weeks of ‘snarky, neat, supersmart roommate’ but suddenly, I’d plunged into this thing, where we were best friends, and I could not imagine my life without you. I know this isn’t the kinda stuff one writes on these cards, but please don’t be sad, Cas? You’re the kinda guy who should get to be happy forever.”
“Then come back.” Cas whispers to the page, and the tears are back. His vision clouds, and he tilts his head back against the wall. “Come back to me, Dean, and I promise I won’t be sad anymore.”
The pages rustle in the wind, as if they want Cas to keep flipping through them.
“Any other time,” Cas says to himself, talking aloud to keep himself from crying. His voice shakes. “Any other reason I got to be sad, and these cards would’ve worked.”
But not this time, he doesn’t say. He still has hope. He has to have hope.
He’s finished the Open When You’re Sad bunch. The next was Tired.
Cas was tired. He was tired of this moment, this day, this entire week. And he was tired of desperately hoping these cards would make him feel better, while it just seemed like they broke his heart into more pieces. Each fragment perhaps seeps into the letters. Nothing’s working.
But he doesn’t care.
It’s better to be sad with Dean’s letters, than to be so, all alone. So he flips to the next section.
Open When You’re Tired
He cannot give up hope.
“Cas, you’ve been an overworked, overachieving idiot for so long now, you know I don’t mind it, but if you’re opening this card right now, it HAS to mean you need a break. I need you to get up. Get yourself a bowl of cereal or something. Go outside to the balcony, maybe. Look up at the sky, and the birds flying around aimlessly, and tell yourself that if they can do that all of their life, then you have earned yourself a fucking break.”
That’s very different from what Cas just read in the previous card, so he rereads it, hearing Dean’s voice clearer in this one, because that’s usually how Dean speaks.
He doesn’t know if it’s better or worse.
Birds don’t fly around aimlessly, but Cas knows Dean knew that - it’s just poetic licence.
He also realizes that Dean had thought that Cas would come to this bunch when he was drained from studying. From writing papers, and learning for exams, and not when he was trying to get himself to stop crying over the death of his best friend.
He doesn’t blame Dean.
Three days ago, Cas would have thought the same thing.
Tired just means something else, now.
Cas flips to the next card. And then the next. They’re all similar to this one. Reminds Cas of the existence of parks. Suggests channels for animal videos on Youtube. Describes how to best take a nap.
Cas tries to smile, even if it’s sad.
He feels oddly deprived of more meaningful words. He’d just assumed that there’d be more things about their friendship - their relationship, about Dean, and not just about midterms and finals.
He only wishes that that were the reason he was nestled on the floor with all these letters.
Cas stretches his legs out again. The floor’s so cold, he can feel it through his slacks.
Funeral slacks.
Cas hardly notices it.
He flips on. The fifth card’s a different take on ‘tired’. Still not what he’d been looking for, but again, he treasures every word he gets.
“This World’s an awful place to be, and I wonder if you’re tired of it being horrible. There’s racists and bigots, and evil billionaires and anti-feminists, and I know it can be too much sometimes. But the thing is, change will happen. Starting with good people like you, Cas, and activists, and dreamers, things will turn out fine. So let’s try to hang in there, and hang in there with hope.”
Dean was so good with words.
His sentences make Cas want to nod, and agree, and applaud - but also shout at the top of his lungs, the harsher questions. Where’s Dean now? How does he expect Cas to hang in there, without him? How is Cas supposed to live in this world, already terrible, now made infinitely more so, by the loss of his best friend?
But Cas doesn’t utter a word.
Everything hurts.
He’s finished flipping through this second bunch too, and decides he’s no closer to feeling less sad and tired. In fact, this bunch wasn’t even particularly satisfying, because now he was getting closer to the end, but Dean’s words were just as casual, and inconsequential as -
As anyone would expect them to be.
Cas braves his heart, and resolves to not give into greed right now. He resolves to not seek out the intense emotionality which fiction had made him believe he would receive.
He gets to have Dean around for a little longer. That’s what should count.
He picks up the last bunch, and lets out a huff of a laugh, mocking his own predicament. He’s never been more lonely. Not even when he rode a bus across America, landing up here, freshly after cutting ties off with his own family. For, you see, there had been hope then.
Now? He was not just lonely, he was hopeless.
The wind blows with an almost eerie whisper, and Castiel decides to not give himself time to think.
The more he thinks, the more unbearable the pain became - so he will just read through all the cards; the last five cards Dean had written for him to read when he got lonely, and he resolves to not waste time thinking about how each of those was awfully ironic in some way now, because if he does, he’ll not be able to stop - and then he’ll not be able to move, and he’ll probably end up unconscious on the floor.
It’s getting really cold.
The tears haven’t stopped the entire time, though he isn’t sniffling. They just keep on rolling down his face, like there’s a button which was pushed so hard that it can’t come back to normal. Ever.
He wonders for a fleeting second if he’ll ever stop feeling this lonely, in every way he’s ever felt anything, as he starts reading.
“Cas, you know you’re one of the bravest people I know, right? You left your family because you wanted to follow your passions, and I respect you so much for standing up for yourself. But I know that makes you feel all alone sometimes, so I just want to remind you that you have a family here too. Ellen and Jo? They love you like one of their own. Bobby let you ride his frigging motorcycle, dude. Charlie, Kevin, all of them, they can’t stop gushing about you. May feel like it, but you’re never really alone. You’re my family.”
That was a long block of text, and Dean seemed to have squeezed in the last bits in tiny scrawl, and it makes Cas’s heart smash against his ribs. He knows how much that line meant to Dean. So it means a lot to him too.
He flips to the next.
“Just like a few moments of silence doesn’t mean you’re all alone, sometimes it feels like there’s nobody around you, but all they’re doing is waiting outside the door. Don’t be nervous to reach out. We’re all here for you, but you have a fucking stellar poker face, so it’s hard to tell you’re lonely unless you come out and tell me, so please don’t keep it bottled up. What am I here for?”
The ‘we’ had eventually become an ‘I’.
Cas wets his lips. That isn’t entirely true, because while Cas likes to think he’s good at hiding his actual feelings, it’s never really worked with Dean. Dean could always see right through him.
Probably why he’s never had to open these cards before when Dean was always right there.
He wishes Dean was right here.
There’s no falling stars in the sky. So his tears oblige.
“I’m lonely, Dean.” Cas whispers, and for the very first time, a teardrop actually falls on the paper.
He recoils, tries to rub it off, and breathes a sigh of relief when he sees that the rest of the cards are fine. This one just got a little smudged. He’s going to have to pay more attention.
He reads on.
“There’s this song, Cas. Simple man, by Lynyrd Skynyrd. I like to listen to it, when I’m lonely. Maybe because it’s one of the only songs I can play. I hope it’ll make you feel better. And, uh, I told Sammy I was doing this thing where I write you these cards for your birthday? And he suggested I suggest Coffins. By Bohnes. (Huh, just noticed the name thing. That’s cool)”
Cas has heard the song before. But it’s never quite struck him so hard.
‘When the man in black, comes to cash his check;
And you’re holding on to your final breath.
When you walk out the door, know that I will too.
I hope they build coffins for two.’
Fuck, he misses Dean so much.
He misses holding him, and he misses cupping his face and he misses kissing his lips, and he misses every bit of Dean he’s ever gotten to have, and is never going to, again. Cas needs him. He cannot imagine not having him here, forever.
Cas doesn’t know why he does it, but he reads on. He has to finish this.
“You really deserve to be so, so happy, Cas. I have said that before, but obviously you wouldn’t just have read it, so I get to say it again. You’re one of the best people I know, and you’re my best friend, and thank you for being a part of my life. I know it feels like you’re alone right now, Cas, but you’re always going to have me. I promise I’ll be there.”
“You won’t.” Cas shakes, starting to cry all over again.
He really won’t.
“I’ll text you, and I’ll call you, and I’ll wait for you right here, but you’re not coming back, Dean.“ Cas grits out. "Why aren’t you coming back?” His voice breaks with the last words.
All he can do is turn the page and start to read the last words he’s ever going to have, from Dean.
“Cas, if you really made it all the way to the last card of this bunch, you’re probably going to need more than words. Go (come?) into my room, okay? You need a Dean Winchester hug, buddy. I’m pretty much I’m the only thing that can make this right ;) Love ya.”
In the words of the love of his life, Sonuvabitch.
That hurt the most. He agrees, of course he agrees, Dean’s the only one who can make it better. And that’s the thing.
He can’t.
That was the last letter.
“No, no, no -” Cas begins to repeat in a frenzy, his eyes widening in horror as he got up to his feet. He tries flipping to the next page, but it’s over. That’s the last thing Dean ever said to him. It was his last suggestion. “No, no -”
His last words had been love you. They’d actually, unironically, been the words Cas most needed.
And also, the worst possible way to say goodbye.
Cas had started to walk, as he panicked. His breaths come out in ragged sobs, as he stares up at the sky.
Come find me, Dean could just have said.
“I love you.” Cas cries, and he actually cries too. “You can’t be gone, Dean. Please don’t be gone, I -” He keeps on shouting at the skies, until his throat closes up, and he stops, the cold metal railing of the balcony now against his hip. He freezes. The only thing between him and falling, is this railing.
Oh, it’s so fucking cold.
“I need you, please!” Cas begs, but he knows it’s of no use at all. Dean Winchester is gone. He’s dead. “I need you, Dean. I need you to come back and make this better like you just said you would.” His entire body shakes with his violent sobs.
He grips onto the railing tighter. And leans ahead, raising his eyes to the clouds, tipping his head back. “How can I live without you, Dean? How will I even get up in the mornings - you’re it for me, Dean, please -”
His voice breaks again, and he starts to cough.
“I,” He chokes out, as if for the last time ever saying it as though Dean is before him. “I love you.” And how his ears ache to hear it back, and how his skin tingles with the fading memory of Dean being near. “I love you so much.” He breathes out, screwing his eyes shut, and simply falling silent.
He’s run out of words. And he waits until he runs out of tears.
It’s dark, when Cas finally leaves the railing. When he stumbles back, his feet are unsure of where to go, but his breathing is finally even. Though even his eyes are tired. But he can’t think anymore. He’s numb.
He’d stopped feeling, almost an hour ago, but the tears hadn’t stopped.
So he’d just stood there, unmoving, thinking endlessly about how close he’d been to jumping. How tempted he was to do it. He wasn’t even scared - in that moment, he had nothing to live for. The only reason he didn’t, was because he was struck with the intensity of the guilt he’d leave her with.
*
On November 8th, Castiel would’ve killed himself, if he’d not promised Charlie that he’d be back.
He gets to her flat in another hour, and when he knocks, it’s like she knows. She just says, "I’m so sorry, Cas,” and wraps her arms around him tight, pulling him close to her warmth. It’s almost like she’s sorry Cas isn’t with Dean right now.
Cas hugs her back, trying to comfort her. After all, he won’t be away from Dean too long.
Thank you for always being my there to cheerlead and beta for me @nickelkeep
Also on Ao3
GRAPHIC VIOLENCE AND MAJOR CHARACTER DEATH WARNING
“I can fix this!” Dean yells.
“It’s not broken!” Cas pleads. He’s on his knees in an angel trap. “I’m not broken!” Holy oil spills over his face, slipping between his lips as he begs. He tries to wipe it away, terrified. He looks up at Dean and opens his mouth to try again, but Dean just pours more oil over his face. It forces its way into his mouth and down his throat. He sputters and chokes. His nose feels funny and he can feel the oil in his lungs. His hair is plastered to his face, and still, he tries. “Dean!”
“I can fix this!” Dean promises, flicking open the silver lighter. It was never meant for Cas. It was never meant for him. The lighter drops and Cas screams.
Dean staggers backward, holding his head as he groans. Pain rips through him as he doubles over. He squeezes his eyes shut and blinks through the pain before he looks up and feels his heart stop in his chest.
“Cas!” He rips off his jacket and throws it over Cas, trying to suffocate the flames. “No. No, no, no, no, no. Cas. No!”
The flames lick at Dean’s palms but he can’t feel them. He doesn’t care. He pulls Cas’ body out of the angel trap and pats out the flames as he tries to breathe. He can’t feel his heart. He can’t feel. He sees his burned hands shaking. He hears an anguished howl and wonders if it’s from him.
“Good job,” a voice says. “It was hard work, but we knew you could do it. I knew you could do it. Just took some persuasion.” Zachariah. “What’s wrong, Dean?”
“Bring him back, you son of a bitch. I don’t know what you did, but you will bring him back.” Dean feels the stinging in his nose as tears blur his vision. He refuses to let them fall as he cradles Cas against him.
“What I did? Oh, no. What you did. This was all you, Dean,” he says with that smile that turns Dean’s stomach.
It hits him with a wave of nausea. He remembers Cas begging only moments ago. He remembers Cas’ screams. He remembers pouring holy oil over his perfect face and wetting his parted lips. His eyes flicker to his lighter on the floor by the burning angel trap.
“I know, I know,” Zachariah sighs. “You loved him. You’ll never be the same without him by your side. Blah blah blah. This is good, Dean. We got two birds with one stone! You’re controllable and Castiel? Our broken angel who fell in love with a human? He’s out of the picture. He can’t stand in the way anymore.”
“Fell in love?” Dean breathes harshly, his eyes raking over Cas’ scarred face. His mind is reeling, but he manages to snarl, “I told you once and I will tell you again. I’m not a pawn in your game. I will never say yes.”
“Come now, Dean. You already killed the only being who will ever love you. What left is there?”
Dean can’t look away from Cas’ face. He had done this to him. He had killed the love of his life. He wasn’t even in charge of his own body, but he feels the guilt tearing into him like a knife.
“You will say yes. Now, or when we decide to take control again. You killed your poor, dear Castiel. You’ll kill your brother too.” Zachariah takes a step toward him. “It’s only a matter of time, Dean.”
“Take another step and I’ll kill you and then me,” Dean says without moving. Zachariah stops and Dean runs his hand over the burned cheek of his angel. He never got to tell him that he loved him. His final moments were spend in fear and desperation.
“You don’t have any weapons. You aren’t going to kill anyone,” Zachariah says. “Anyone else,” he corrects himself with a chuckle.
Dean grabs Cas’ angel blade from his sleeve and plunges it into his heart. He gasps and watches two tears finally fall onto Cas’ face.
“I’m not broken!” Cas had yelled in his final moments.
“But I am,” Dean answers silently as he chokes on his own blood and watches the world tilt and darken.
Tag List: To be Added like/comment/reblog the post on this link
@jemariel @blueeyesandpie @anarchiana @samatedeansbroccoli @localgaycatastrophie @fandom-is-my-middle-name @soloarcana @destielhoneybee @destiel-honeypie @misha-moose-dean-burger-lover @spn-bitchh @awkward-penguin-in-a-trenchcoat @skittles-rainbow-cat @kingofmyimagination @k-lewis @castibella-shipper-of-the-lord @aestheticallydyke @righteouscomeuppancejogstheliver@deanwinchesterswitch @adventurous-blob @iamcharliebradburylevelperfect @ain-t-bovvered @royalrowena @telefunkies @em-thechaoticplant @canadduh-fics @alex-alison