The Letter
Pairing: Avengers!Bucky x Fem!Reader
Summary: You have a HUGE crush on your fellow Avenger, but have never gotten the guts to tell him. Instead, you write letters that you keep to yourself. Until one letter goes missing...
Warnings: one-sided pining (turns out it was mutual), elevator confrontation, mostly fluffy but with a bit of angst that mainly comes from the unrequited feelings
WC: 3.5k
Masterlist
When you joined the Avengers, you expected a life full of danger, intrigue, secrecy, and maybe comradery if you were lucky.
You never expected Bucky Barnes.
It didn't take you too long to figure out the rest of the Avengers, at least on a base level. Tony was brash and flippant, Steve had morals of steel, Bruce was awkward but brilliant, Natasha and Clint were watchful (yet somehow playful at the same time). But Bucky?
He was so hard to read. Quiet, brooding. He just stood off to the side during meetings listening but not saying much. When you had team dinners, he would have quiet conversations with Steve and Nat, but was never the life of the party.
He was hard to approach. During training sessions, you would ask him to help you out, and he never said no, but he was never eager to assist. Sometimes, you couldn't tell if he liked you or hated you.
But there was something about him.
The way his lips would twitch into the faintest ghost of a smile when the team was goofing off. The sparkle of pride in his eye when he saw his best friend come home after a difficult mission. Even the ferocity with which he fought to protect his teammates on the battlefield.
When you saw those moments, it was like you could see another side of him peeking through. A layer of softness that was trying to crack his hard shell.
You saw it especially well when you were just living your lives out in the Tower.
In the morning, you would spot him making a pot of coffee and cooking breakfast on the stove, and he just looked so... domestic. So normal. Or in the evening when Steve would turn on the news and they would sit and discuss current events, he looked like any other man.
And when he would help you with simple tasks, like grabbing a book off a high shelf, or fixing a door hinge that came loose, it took everything in you not to stare at the curves of his muscles as his arms flexed. You tried not to notice the way his lips would tense as he worked. You begged yourself not to peek as his shirt rose up an inch or two to show off his muscular abs.
But over time, you couldn't help it.
You couldn't help but be hyper-aware every time you were in the same room with him. You couldn't help the way your heart would leap for joy when you got assigned on the same missions, or when both of you didn't. Your breath would catch on the days he sat next to you at meal times, and there was nothing you could do to stop it.
Not that you really wanted to.
A few months in, it started to feel stifling, these feelings you couldn't release. Your mind was filled with thoughts of him and nothing else, which was starting to show in your performance.
At first, it was simple mistakes, a missed cue, or an unnoticed shadow.
And then came the time when you got hit by a bullet because you were distracted by him.
Clint shoved you behind a wall and growled, "What is wrong with you?"
You cried out in pain and held your hand to your side, warm blood seeping through your fingers. "I-I'm sorry," you wheezed, "I thought I saw something."
"What could you have possibly seen that would override the guy right in front of you?!"
It took you three weeks to recover to a place where you could start participating in missions again. Three weeks where you barely saw Bucky while he was out in the field.
During those weeks, you bought a box and paper and just started writing. You started writing down all of your thoughts, all of your dreams, all of your fantasies. Every scenario that you fixated on when it came to Bucky was down on paper the same day. And each letter you finished found its home in a lovely little locked box that lived under your bed.
Your letters were your perfect safe haven. A place where you could be honest and free, and spill everything you wanted to without being judged or rejected.
They were your perfect secret.
---
Your breath came quickly as you tore your room apart. Your desk was a disaster, every piece of paper in the room was thrown onto it. The contents of your shelf were on the floor, your blanket was balled up on the corner of your bed.
Crouching down, you frantically searched under your bed. "Where is it," you muttered, shoving your hand out in hopes of feeling the crinkle of pink paper.
Nothing.
A knock sounded from the door. "Hey, you good in there?" Natasha's voice called.
"Huh? Oh, yeah, I-I'm fine," you replied distractedly, hopping back up on your feet.
"You sure? I heard something bump against the wall."
"Yeah, that was my desk."
"...Why are you banging your desk against the wall?"
You rolled your eyes. "I lost something, I was looking behind it."
Natasha hummed. "What did you lose?"
You fiddled with your hands, floundering for something to say. No one knew about your letters. Not even Natasha, who was the closest thing you had to a friend among the Avengers. "Just, a personal item."
"Well, yeah, I assumed. Do you need help finding it?"
"No!" you said too quickly. "I mean, no, I got it. It's no biggie."
It was absolutely a biggie. This was the most recent addition to your letter collection, and was one of the most detailed you'd written to date. If anyone other than you found it, it was over for you. Months of hiding your feelings would go straight down the drain, and all your hopes of ever becoming more with Bucky would die with them.
After all, who would be interested in someone who's obsessed with them?
No. He could never know.
You huffed and threw your pillow across the room in frustration. Where could you have possibly left it? How could a piece of pink paper hide from you this well?
Natasha's voice came again. "One other thing, we'll be leaving for the gala in two hours, so make sure you're ready to go by then."
You winced. The gala. Right. "Got it. I'll be ready."
"See you then." You could hear her footsteps as she walked down the hall and let out a sigh.
Surely, you'd find it after the gala. Maybe it was hiding in plain sight and you'd only see it later.
Quickly, you showered and dressed in the shimmering gown Tony had picked out for you. You hated to admit anything that would inflate his ego, but damn it, he knew luxury fashion.
And damn it, he knew galas.
The moment you walked into the room, you were hit with the very image of wealth. Dozens of people in expensive dresses and suits that all screamed 'look at me!', waiters walking around with trays full of sparkling champagne that bubbled delicately. Golden light streaming from the beautiful chandeliers that were hung up above a dance floor.
Steve whistled from beside you. "He really outdid himself this time."
"Don't let him hear you say that," Bucky murmured softly from beside him.
You chuckled. "He'd never let you hear the end of it."
Bucky shot you a warm smirk and your stomach twisted. He was always handsome, but he looked positively stunning that night. His suit was perfectly tailored to accentuate his broad shoulders, the deep blue of the fabric making his eyes shine like an endless sky. His dark hair was swept back with gel, brushed and combed with care.
You wished you could run your hands through it.
"You look great, by the way," Bucky said casually. "The colour is nice."
Your cheeks flushed with heat as you glanced down at your outfit. "Oh, thank you. You look great too!"
He laughed. "Thanks, doll." He turned to Steve as you entered the hall, but you couldn't let go of that one word, that term of endearment that meant far more to you than it meant to him.
Doll.
You never heard him call anyone else doll. Giddily, you held that joy close to your chest as you joined in the party.
All through the night, your eyes struggled to stay on your conversation partners, drifting around the room until they landed on the only person you could actually pay attention to.
At one point, Natasha came over and gently bumped your shoulder, apologizing to the woman who was telling you all about her most recent mission to Dubai and whisking you away to a corner of the room.
"You know," she said quietly, keeping her eyes forward, "this wouldn't be a bad place to tell him."
You blinked. "What? Tell whom?"
She chuckled softly, her eyes crinkling with a lightness you rarely saw. "Bucky."
A cold hand gripped your heart and you took a step back. You'd never told her--anyone--about your feelings. "W-what are you talking about? What do I have to tell Bucky?"
Natasha waved her hand casually. "Nothing important, just that you're completely and utterly in love with him."
Your nervousness escaped your throat in a bark disguised as a laugh. "Nat, now is not the time for jokes."
"I'm not joking."
Your face cooled into a cold neutral expression. "Drop it."
"And let you keep pining over him from the shadows?" Natasha grabbed a champagne flute from a tray that was floating by and lifted it to her lips. "Did you forget that you live with a bunch of retired superspies? Did you really think we wouldn't notice?"
Your eyes widened. "You--Who--"
"Me. Clint." She sipped her drink. "Steve probably suspects but doesn't know for sure." When she lowered the glass, she tilted her head thoughtfully. "I think it's just us two."
"I can't believe--"
Your words were cut off by the loud squeak of a microphone. You swiveled to see Tony at the podium in all his couture glory, his wife Pepper right beside him.
Off to the side of the small stage, you could see Bucky and Steve standing at the ready. It was only then that you remembered Bucky was going to be giving the welcoming speech tonight. You even sat down with him last night and helped him write it for hours. He'd been so adorably nervous about making one of his first public addresses as an Avenger.
Bucky's eyes caught yours and he gave you a smile, holding up his speech in his hand to show you.
You started to smile back when you saw the pink paper on the bottom of his stack and your face froze.
Oh. Oh god, no.
"Ladies and gentlemen," Tony started. "As much as I'd like to be the one to thank you all for coming to this event, let's be honest, you should be thanking me for the invite."
A light chuckle echoed around the room.
Pepper took the podium, shooting Tony a warning look. "This team, these Avengers, are proud beyond measure to serve you as Earth's Mightiest Heroes. Here to say more is our very own Bucky Barnes."
You watched as Bucky took to the podium and tapped the papers on the wood. Your heart started to beat wildly. That pink paper on the bottom of the stack. That was yours. That was your letter.
It must have gotten stuck to something when you went to help him write the speech last night, it had to have. How else could he have it right there in his hands?
He started to speak, but you couldn't hear a thing through the blood rushing through your ears. The world started to spin, and you needed to throw up. But you couldn't run. There were too many people, too many eyes. He would notice you sprinting away from the speech he worked so hard on. You couldn't do that to him.
But every second that dragged on brought you closer and closer to your doom. Every page he flipped brought him closer and closer to your biggest secret.
When he finished the last page of his actual speech, he paused, sliding the pink paper out from behind it.
Nope.
You couldn't do this.
You refused to. Refused to watch his eyes turn hard and cold, refused to see the confusion turn into horror. Refused to watch as he turned his eyes to meet yours in question and in pity.
And so you turned away and started to leave. You sat through the speech, now you could go, right?
Quietly, you pulled yourself away from Natasha's side and started to weave your way through the crowd of patrons who were starting to mingle again after the speech was done. You made it all the way to the elevator and managed to push the down button before you heard him.
His footsteps echoed down the hallway as he ran after you, his breaths coming quickly and shallow. "Wait," he called after you, slowing down to a quick walk.
You pressed the button again, refusing to look back. Come on, you thought. Come faster!
Bucky called your name and stopped a few feet away from you. "We gotta talk."
"Nope," you said as the elevator doors opened. "I'm not talking about anything. I am packing my things and moving to Belize."
You stepped in and tried to press the Lobby button and close the door, but Bucky stuck his hand in between the doors and they opened again. Fear flooded your system as he stepped inside with you. You were so completely unprepared to have this conversation ever, much less right this second. Your hands grew clammy and you forced them into a neat fold in front of you.
The doors closed and the elevator started to move.
You could feel his gaze on you, even as you refused to look his way.
"You really want to do it like this?" he asked, something sharp in his voice.
"I don't know what you're talking about," you said, crossing your arms.
He huffed out a breath and reached over to press the stop button. Your eyes widened. "Hey, what are you doing?"
"If I let you off this elevator down there, you're going to run away from me. You're going to run away from this." He held up a piece of pink paper and your cheeks heated to a crimson hue.
Your eyes were glued to the paper. "Give that back," you said halfheartedly.
Bucky shook his head. "Not until we discuss this."
You threw up your hands exasperatedly. "What is there to discuss?"
He opened his mouth and then hesitated, like he was editing his thoughts on the spot. "Why was your--why was this in my script?"
Tears prickled at the corners of your eyes. "I don't know. It wasn't supposed to be, it was supposed to be in my room with the rest of them. Hidden. Never to be seen by anyone except me and an eventual fireplace."
"...There are others?"
Realization at what you'd revealed shook you out of your pity party and you turned around to face the wall, dropping your head into your hands. "Forget I said that."
"I don't think I can. How many have you written?"
"Oh, what does it matter, Bucky?" You whipped around to face him, your eyes wet with unshed tears. "They were supposed to be for me. Just for me. So I could... unload onto something that wouldn't care."
Suddenly the tears were no longer unshed, hot and wet as they dripped down your cheeks. "I-I... I'm sorry, you weren't supposed to-to see any of them." Your breaths were uneven as they filled with your tears.
He froze, his hand trembling slightly as it held onto your letter. Slowly, he looked from the letter to you. "So, everything in here is real?"
You closed your eyes and nodded. "I know it isn't fair to you, and I'm sorry. I wanted to just keep this to myself, but I can't even do that right."
"Why didn't you tell me?" his voice was soft as he took a few steps in your direction.
You pressed yourself back against the wall, creating space between you again. An incredulous laugh bubbled up inside of you. "What was I supposed to say? 'Hey, Bucky, I know we don't talk a whole lot but I've had a crush on you for the last eight months and don't have the balls to ask you out!' I couldn't do that! I can barely ask Tony to get me take out most days."
You heard him make a sound, a sound that you quickly realized was him trying to cover up a laugh. "You're laughing at me," you said in disbelief. "My biggest secret comes to light and you're laughing at me!"
"Ten months."
You stared at him like he'd just grown a second head. "Excuse me?"
"I've liked you for ten months." He took another step closer to you, your letter still clutched gently in his hand like he was afraid to wrinkle it. "I didn't say anything because... I was sure someone like you would have been happier with someone else."
All you could do was blink. What was he saying?
He took another step closer. He was so close you could smell his cologne, deep and mesmerizing. Bucky took his hand and lifted your chin up gently, forcing you to look him in the eyes.
"Every time I see you, I want to scream my feelings out in to the world, to tell you the truth and run into your arms, but I'm so scared about what you might say," he quoted, reading from your letter. "You wrote that about me? "
A stray tear fell from the corner of your eye and you tried to turn away from him, but he didn't let you, just held your face firmly in place before sliding his hand up your jaw to brush the tear away with his thumb. The heat from his hands sent shivers down your spine. You gave him a small nod.
Part of you thought that he was trying to gently let you down, or tell you that you would always be friends but he was interested in someone else. There was no part of you that was ready for him to lean down and kiss you.
Your eyes widened in surprise, but when you felt him lean into you, you couldn't help but melt into him. His lips were soft and warm, full of a desperate longing that was so familiar you couldn't tell if it came from you or from him. Your head felt like it was full of air, floating away into pure bliss.
How long had you dreamed of this moment? How many nights had you stayed awake wondering what it would be like for him to be sleeping next to you? How many movie nights did you spend thinking about what it would be like if he sat next to you, close enough for you to feel his warmth?
And now, his warmth was all over you. His right hand held your face gently like he was afraid he was going to lose you, his left arm curled around your waist to pull you in tighter. His lips moved against yours, slowly at first, then quicker, fiercer with every second you didn't pull away. Your heart felt like it was beating so fast it would stop any moment now.
When you started to feel lightheaded, you pulled away, breath heaving as you tried to force oxygen into your lungs. Your lips felt swollen and heavy, and when you risked a glance up at him, he looked the same, his beautiful lips curved into a small smile.
If your cheeks could burst into flames, they would have at that exact moment.
"That was..." you breathed. "Why did you--"
"I have spent months dreaming of doing that," he whispered, placing his forehead against yours. "I never once thought I'd actually get to. Not until I saw the letter. I couldn't let you run away from me, not when I finally had a chance."
You let out a nervous giggle. "You really... like me?"
"Doll, I've liked you since the day you walked into the compound." He brushed a lock of hair behind your ear, but kept his hand near your face. "I... I know I'm not good at talking about feelings, not as good as Steve at least, but... I really like you. And I-I would love to take you out for dinner. If that sounds okay to you."
You grabbed him by the collar of his suit jacket and pulled him down into another kiss.
He smiled against your lips. "I'll take that as a yes."
A/N ngl not my best work but I couldn't get it out of my headddddd
Masterlist













