Nobody ever went broke underestimating the nincompoopery of New York’s city council. Now along comes Upper West Side member Helen Rosenthal to crank up the stupid, declaring her appreciation of the vandalism last week of a statue depicting the globally famous photo of a U.S. sailor kissing a dental technician in Times Square to mark the end of the Second World War. “I appreciate someone recognizing that a random man grabbing a random woman is completely inappropriate,” said Rosenthal—having a #MeToo moment as she prepares to run for city comptroller. Presentism—judging past events solely by current standards—is usually mindless, opportunistic, and petty, but Rosenthal’s politicized ahistoricism is breathtaking even by these standards. The image, captured on August 14, 1945, by Life magazine photographer Alfred Eisenstaedt, brilliantly captured the joy that swept over Times Square, and the nation, as news arrived of Japan’s surrender, bringing to an end the most sanguinary conflict in human history. ... Whether Rosenthal is aware of the ignorance she radiates or is merely taking advantage of a random news event is a matter for herself and her conscience. She should be aware, however, that serious people think that she looks ridiculous. And by the way, vandalism of any sort always is to be condemned, never appreciated. Those who aspire to high office in New York shouldn’t have to be reminded of that.
Bob McManus, Vandalizing History
https://www.city-journal.org/helen-rosenthal-times-square-statue












