Rambling about Fairies - Manga Chapter 159
I think it’s either the translation in the anime or manga that trips me up here, but this line actually surprises me for how cold it is.
Honestly, I just realized that in Fairy Tail, there isn’t actually a genuine criminal in it. Everyone was a victim of circumstance, and genuine ‘villain-turned friend’ characters are in other guilds.
Fairy Tail itself doesn’t have a true villain-turned character in it.
They were all children caught up in tragedies and made awful mistakes. Everyone in Fairy Tail starts in the good alignment and stays there, except Laxus, but I find it hard to call him anything in the evil alignment when Fairy Law explicitly told us he was a good boy all along.
If there are any characters that are actually ‘evil’ with malicious, truthfully irredeemable intentions, like Lyon in Galuna or Sabertooth in GMG, they’re probably not in the guild anymore. Case in point: Hades, and the TOH trio: Sho, Millianna, Wally, all who were either members or were almost members.
So, it’s kind of ironic that Natsu says “we’re used to committing crime” when members of FT are rambunctious delinquents with godzilla-scale powers at worst. They never destroy things or cause trouble maliciously, they only do it as accidental collateral damage, or the injured were assholes to begin with.
And as we've seen from Makarov's first speech when Lucy first joined, they are all unapologetic about it, and Makarov literally says 'fuck the council, we are free and proud mages'. So... I find it a bit iffy that Natsu says this here, because they don't feel any guilt for those "crimes" at all. It would be one thing if it was Gray or Erza, who blames themselves and both have severe survivor's guilt from mistakes they actually made. So Natsu doesnt feel like the right person to say that line. He does not consider his wanton destruction a crime.
It would be another thing though, if they weren't talking about crime but rather about regret itself, from being helpless and losing loved ones. Kind of an extension of the "everyone in FT has been hurt" message from Mira at the start of Macao arc.













