Just putting my own two cents as to whether the Percy/Rachel or Percy/Calypso pairings might be represented on screen the same way they were in the books:
(under a Read More bc this ended up longer than I thought it would be haha)
I personally don't think so. And there are several reasons why, but one important one is that it is established VERY early on that Luke and Annabeth see each other as siblings and not as potential love interests.
I kinda said it in another post, but in my reading of the books (which I last read years ago, so grain of salt), Percy wasn't oblivious to his own feelings for Annabeth. However, he was DEFINITELY oblivious to Annabeth's feelings for him and very insecure and jealous about her possible feelings for Luke.
I remember because this series became one of the main reasons why I can't stand love triangles in Young Adult/fiction novels anymore 😅🤣. Percy seriously thought that every time Annabeth defended Luke she was carrying a torch for him. (Plus the books kept leaning into it, what with Luke asking Annabeth if she ever loved him and Piper at one point seeing how the mention of Luke affected Annabeth and wondering if Annabeth had "another boyfriend before Percy".)
But in the TV show? Annabeth clearly doesn't want Luke dead, but she clearly doesn't have more than brotherly feelings for Luke either. She also actually believes that Luke sided with Kronos this time (I think in the books she had some doubts at first). So Percy doesn't really see Luke as a romantic rival.
Now that wouldn't mean that Percy wouldn't still feel jealous. 🤔 We saw a hint of it when he forced that Iris message between Luke and Annabeth to hang up. 🤣 I think it would be interesting for the show to explore what others on here have already suggested- jealousy between Luke and Percy (and perhaps even Thalia) over Annabeth becoming more vulnerable with Percy and Percy increasingly becoming her most important person.
So if Percy no longer thinks Luke is a "romantic rival" for Annabeth's feelings, is he still going to be oblivious to Annabeth's feelings for him? It's entirely possible.
Will that lead to him still exploring something with someone else? Ummm that devotion Percy is showing to Annabeth right now is top tier. I can't imagine a world in the TV series where that devotion will shift to anyone else in a romantic sense, because that would be him engaging in an emotional affair at this point 😭. (Well unless the TV show wants to show some messy behavior lol)
So bottom line, I don't think things will go the same way in the books. Especially with Calypso. I have a feeling there will be MAJOR changes there because the age implications...hm.
Thanks for letting me ramble, tag. What do you guys think?










