“You thought, because you were alone,
Your falsehood never could be known,
But liars always are found out,
Whatever ways they wind about;”
Sarah sat on the cold floor of the cellar, quietly listening to the stories that drifted down from the floor above. Her mother sat in the parlor, reading stories to her elder brothers.
Sometimes she closed her eyes and imagined that she was in the parlor with them. She could nearly feel the soft warmth emitting from the kerosene lamps that dotted the tables. Maybe her mother would wrap her up in a blanket and set her by the fire, and maybe her father would pat her on the head as he walked by. Maybe her brothers would be kind to her, then. Maybe her grandmother wouldn’t be so cruel.
Maybe then, she would be loved.
But she wasn’t loved, and she wasn’t in the parlor. She was in the basement, the same damp and dark basement that she had been in for ages.
Sometimes when Sylvie delivered her meals, she would leave the door unlocked “by accident.” Sarah had ventured upstairs a few times, but she rarely went to the parlor. It seemed almost like sacrilege to venture to that part of the house. It was where her family gathered, and she wasn’t welcomed there. But, then again, neither was Sylvie, and they didn’t particularly dislike her. Regardless, Sarah rarely ventured any further than the small hallway that connected the servant’s quarters to the rest of the house.
One time, Sarah had mustered up the courage to slip into the dining room. It was sometime around midday, and the entire family was off on some sort of social call. In the dining room there was a portrait of her grandparents hanging on one wall, along with a more recent family portrait on the other. Her brothers sat proudly on their parent’s laps, but Sarah herself was nowhere to be seen. In fact, Sarah had never really seen her own likeness in a portrait. Of course, she knew what she looked like. There was a mirror in her room, and Sarah often looked at her own reflection while Sylvie styled her hair in the mornings.
Sylvie was a good enough hairdresser, and she was gentle too, but Sarah always wondered what it would be like to have her own mother brush her hair. Sometimes her mother would read a story about a little girl, and in it the mother always brushed her daughter’s hair. Sarah wondered if that story ever made her mother sad, or if it made her angry that her only daughter had been born wrong, and because of that she would never brush her hair like the other mother’s did.
Sarah once told Sylvie about these wonders when she came down to the basement one morning, and Sylvie only told her that those worries were too big for such a little girl to have. But Sylvie frowned as she said it, and Sarah wondered if maybe those worries were bad, or if she was bad for having worried them up. Sarah didn’t ask though, and she only sat still as Sylvie brushed her hair for the day.
Sometimes Sarah wondered if she really did have worries that were too big. She was only 6, but she was clever. Sylvie had told her that once, but Sarah hadn’t known what it meant at the time. She never meant to worry big worries, but there wasn’t much else to do in that basement.
The story was coming to a close now, and Sarah could just barely hear her brothers shuffling. One of them, she thought it was Harold, begged for another story. Another voice, a deeper one, hushed him and said something that Sarah couldn’t make out. There was shuffling and scraping as people and furniture moved about the parlor, and Sarah’s eyes grew heavy. Her brothers would be off to bed soon, which meant that it was time for Sarah to sleep as well. She didn’t need to follow their schedule, because no one would ever come to check on her to see if she was asleep, but she wanted to be a part of the upstairs, even if only in her imagination. If she thought long and hard enough, she could almost see her mother standing in the doorway, coming to tuck her into bed. Sarah had never seen it happen, but Sylvie told her once that all little girls and boys get tucked into bed at night, and Sarah imagined that her brothers were no different. Sarah had no one to tuck her in, so she had to make do herself.
In the morning, Sylvie came in as she always did, with a hairbrush in one hand and a bowl of porridge in the other. Sarah was always awake before Sylvie arrived, and she scrambled out of bed to greet her. She always wanted to laugh and yell “Aunt Sylvie!!”, but she never could. No one but Sarah herself knew that Sylvie brushed her hair, and Sylvie had made her promise that no one ever would know. Sarah thought that it was because her mother might be jealous, but she didn’t know for sure. Her grandmother would be angry if she knew, but Sarah knew that her grandmother was always angry. Everyone knew that.
Sylvie brushed Sarah’s hair as she always did, and Sarah sat still and quiet. When Sylvie was done, Sarah ate her porridge and left the bowl by the door, and then she sat by her bed and waited. Sometimes a little mouse would come under the door to say hello, and other times she could hear a bird from outside. And sometimes the best surprise of all would come, and that was her brother sneaking down to see her.
Ephraim visited her less and less as time had gone on, but Sarah was so young that she barely realized that. All she knew was that someone still loved her, at least a little. Ephraim was mean to her when her parents were near, but sometimes he could be kind too. Sometimes he would even bring her a treat, although that too happened less and less.
Today was one of those rare days in which Ephraim came to visit her, and a treat had come along with him. Another surprise lay beyond the door, but Sarah didn’t realize that at first.
Ephraim slipped into the basement sometime in the late morning. It was a Sunday, and the family had just returned from church. Sarah had listened to the carriage wheels roll away early that morning, and a few hours later she heard them return. Footsteps stormed the house, and a few moments later Ephraim appeared at her door.
He wasn’t sure exactly what to expect when he walked into the basement room. Sometimes Ephraim wondered if he had dreamt it all up, if Sarah was even real at all. But she was real, and she was always sitting there patiently waiting. He was never sure if she was waiting for him or just waiting for anything at all, but she was always waiting.
She looked at him as he walked into the door, and he stared back at her. The basement keys slipped into the pocket of his small waistcoat, and he shuffled from side to side, unsure of what to do. He hadn’t brought any books or toys to the basement this time, and he wasn’t sure what to do about the pale girl staring back at him.
Finally, Sarah spoke. Her voice was small and quiet, but she sounded older than her years.
“Your hair looks nice today.”
Ephraim glanced at the floor. His hair had been the subject of a debate that morning, although he knew that Sarah couldn’t have heard it. His mother was adamant that he needed to look proper for church, and so she had sat him down in front of her vanity and spent nearly an hour primping his hair, combing it and then uncombing it, oiling it and then changing her mind on the style. Finally she had swept it to the side with a bit of pomade, and he had cringed at the smell of it. He smelled like flowers and he hated it, and he knew that Harold would laugh at him for it.
Harold did, and Ephraim had shot him a glare as they headed towards the carriage that morning.
Ephraim looked up at Sarah. “I like your hair too.”
Sarah blushed a bit. She wasn’t expecting a compliment. No one had ever complimented her besides Sylvie, and it embarrassed her even then.
“Thank you. Sylvie did it.”