Summer reading: Feminism and the psychological thriller
This summer, partly because I’ve been reading public library ebooks, I’ve been sticking closer to the bestseller list than usual. And the subgenre I’ve been exploring is that of “psychological thriller featuring women and their complex interior lives.” All of them have been more or less unsettling, because guess what? masculinity is toxic and the patriarchy is coming for us all. And ALL of them contain domestic abuse of some kind. But I’ve enjoyed them, and I’ve found almost nothing for them on Tumblr, so here goes with mini-reviews.
1. The Au Pair, Emma Rous. This strikes me as a more morally ambitious and complex take on the Kate Morton subgenre of “family secrets in picturesque English locations.” Don’t get me wrong, I do love family secrets and/on English estates. And I enjoyed the ways this book explored what has and has not changed in attitudes towards women’s bodies and lives from the late twentieth century to today. Class is handled fairly thoughtfully as well. But I’d have to reread the novel to figure out whether or not it passes the Bechdel test. And I wished that more had been done with the elements of folk beliefs in magic.
2. Her One Mistake/Now You See Her, Heidi Perks. This has a major twist which is surprising and makes sense. Even though the true villain of toxic masculinity is in plain sight all the time, the unfolding of the plot is satisfying. Also, the ways in which the middle-class housewives of the book navigate the expectations of performative 21st-century motherhood are fascinating, as well as not a little unsettling.
3. She Lies in Wait, Gytha Lodge. I was afraid this book was over-hyped. And I wasn’t sure I could take seriously a protagonist named Jonah (Jonah!) But I love the members of the strange little team of detectives, and this iteration of “Mysterious Crime Occurs, Truth Is [Literally] Unearthed Decades Later” was really masterfully done. Due to my detection obsession, I know mystery novel tropes really well, and this still kept me guessing in very satisfying ways.
4. The Widow, Fiona Barton. This is another one that left me wanting more of the main characters (and yes! it is the first in a proposed series.) Middle-aged journalist Kate is allowed to be serious about both her job and her family without being punished for it, and I wish that didn’t feel like a rarity, but it does. And she’s great. It took me a few chapters to settle into the dual-timeline narrative, but it’s a poignant and well-plotted mystery.