7 Ways the Assassins are Unsubtle as Fuck
The Assassin Brotherhood’s whole “hide in plain sight” thing seems to be enforced only in the (very) short-term. Here be the receipts:
Distinctive beaked hood that makes it way easier to identify you as an Assassin
Distinctive white robes that make stealth, blending with crowds, preventing civilian casualties, & cleanup post-murder way more difficult than it needs to be. Yes, I know Altaïr used it to blend in with scholars. That’s not applicable in most places anymore. I don’t care if it’s to show off your skill or pay homage to Altaïr, that’s not your fucking job when innocents could get caught in the line of fire if you’re caught.
Putting the Brotherhood’s symbol on everything from secret entrances to hidden blades to giant belt buckles to their skin to a 4-foot giant symbol on the front entrance of Monteriggioni
0 attempts to hide your identity while killing beyond wearing a hood. No mask, no codenames, no nothing. Not even the modern assassins had Desmond wear a mask in public. A medical mask would even blend in if he fakes a cough. Being noticeable in an average way even contributes to covers by distracting from actions according to former CIA Chief of Disguise Jonna Mendez.
Cutting off your ring finger gives you a permanent and hard-to-hide feature identifying you as an Assassin, adds unnecessary difficulty to daily free-running/parkour, may distract you with chronic pain during deadly missions, and fatal infection from the initial injury had a high probability for thousands of years. In addition, should an Assassin wish to retire or leave the Brotherhood, they could still be kidnapped, tortured, enslaved, or murdered upon being identified by their finger amputation; making it that much more difficult to leave this cult. Not to mention that this tradition started because Bayek was a dumbass and put the first Hidden Blade on wrong (and didn’t test it), accidentally amputating his finger on the job. When he started the Hidden Ones, recruits started imitating him to show their commitment despite his protests. It’s implied that he respected their choice once they explained but that doesn’t mean I have to. /hj
I get that this probably wasn’t standard practice and that Hytham (not Haytham Kenway, fuck Ubisoft) was probably just a bout of teenage dumbassery but telling an ally you just met exactly who you are, what you do, your creed, practices, and sacred traditional free fall without her even expressing interest in joining the Brotherhood is really dumb. Basim was just as bad since he gave Eivor a hidden blade and trained her in its use but given he’s not very loyal to the Brotherhood and was trying to manipulate Sigurd, that’s not super surprising. The ally in question is Eivor “Wolf-Kissed” Varinsdottir, for anyone who hasn’t played Valhalla, by the way.
Masyaf Castle & Village gets an honorable mention because, though it is a monument to the Assassins’ stealth abilities (lackthereof), they’re vulnerable whether they’re spread out or concentrated so they might as well pick the devil they know (by knowing/countering their most obvious weakness) and get some socialization, comfort, and money while they’re at it.
I seriously need someone to mention at least one of these unsubtlties in a fic. Personally, I’d nominate Clay Kaczmarek, Shaun Hastings, or a reformed Haytham Kenway as candidates for leading a reform (or just being sassy about this) but if you have a better idea or an addition to the list, please let me know. All my posts double as invitations for discussion.