Adrian + Ed + Dex is such a psycho combo you’re so incredible at showing it 🥴
I think they’d all crash out if virgin!Reader lets one of them pop her cherry… maybe Adrian’s upset about the bonding!
ANON YOU ARE SOOO SMART FOR THIS!
Adrian is indeed positively fuming. It's not funny to him now. That's his best friend, and by virtue of every law in the universe, your virginity also belongs to him! Think of the bonding experience! He fantasizes about how close it would make the two of you.
If you did decide to tell him, and pick him, he'll light up like a puppy dog. And then immediately drag you to the nearest room. Hey, maybe even the room you're currently in. Who cares if Economos is three feet away and fake gagging? Lead the way, bestie. He's down for wherever and whenever ;)
Que Adrian immeadiatley pressing you up to the wall and groping every part of you he can get his hands on. And licking. He takes that old saying, "I licked it, so it's mine." veryyy literally.
Adrian may be passive aggressive when the other two are brought up. He'd be hurt if you gave your v-card to someone other than him. Very, very hurt. And a hurt Adrian Chase turns into an emotional Adrian Chase. And an emotional Adrian Chase turns into a frustrated Adrian Chase. And a frustrated Adrian Chase tends to turn into a murderous Adrian Chase. He's got a twitchy trigger finger.
On the opposite end of the spectrum, Dex is also quietly fuming, but more so because he views you as something pure. The status of your virginity both stresses him out and makes him all the more obsessive. I firmly headcanon Dex as a virgin too, and you being one as well solidifies this idea in his head that you are meant to be together. That he needs to protect you from everyone who wants to steal this light from you.
Slight NSFW, but Dex daydreams about taking it more obsessively than the other two as well. He likes to think he would make it perfect for you. Go the whole nine yards with candles and flower petals. He'd be gentle. He'd make it the best for you.
Realistically he'd end up fucking you into the mattress like an animal.
So...uh...maybe Dex isnt exactly a good choice for your first time. Unless you're into literally being split open on your first go. Not that he'd ever admit that. The thought of hurting you is equivalent to blasphemy. However the man has little self control where you are concerned. (+Given this being his first experience too, he isn't in control of the situation at all. He doesn't know how it feels, or what to do, besides fuck.)
Dex is the kind of guy to watch porn and analyze it (in a very detached manner) to prepare himself. So is Eddie.
Speaking of Eddie, he isn't much better than Dex, having only two previous bodies on the body count. Kristen and Isabella both were the last time he got some play, and even then it wasn't a terribly good experience.
Finding out your a virgin to Eddie is significantly less stressful than it is to Dex and Adrian. Both Dex and Adrian want this aspect of you specifically, and they want it bad. It's almost a pyschological thing for them. They both mythologize it.
Eddie doesn't. He's a bit too logical for that. He considers the whole idea of virginity to be nothing more then a social construct. And in Eddie's pov, whether or not you're a virgin, you're getting laid down regardless. By him, of course.
That confidence only lasts because he's sure that you'll pick him over these two morons. (His words, not mine.)
Eventually though, he does get in his head about it. Unlike Dex and Adrian who are spiraling from the beginning, it's a slooooow descend for Eddie. It probably starts with a subtle want to share this experience with you, and ends with him having anxiety-induced nightmares over them touching you.
We all saw how he tried to kill Jim Gordon with a giant hydraulic press just for getting back into Lee's life. You might have to listen to all of his crazy torture porn fantasies and ideas on how to kill the other two.
Eddie catches on quickly to the situation at hand. The idea of anyone other than him having their hands on you makes him sick. Makes him want to cut their hands off.
Realistically I think Eddie would be the best choice for your first time. He has the ability to excercise some self control unlike Dex, and might not be talking the whole time like Adrian (Who rushes the main event a tad. He just gets excited okay) Eddie is a good balance in this department. He might be the only one that's actually gentle.
Until the Riddler comes out and starts rearranging your guts in a pussy drunken haze, that is.













