Harry Powers (born Herman Drenth; 1892- March 18, 1932), also known as Cornelius O. Pierson and A.R. Weaver was born in the Netherlands. He and his family emigrated to the US in 1910. They lived in Cedar Rapids, Iowa but moved to West Virginia in 1926. Harry, however, did not want to be an immigrant farmer like his father. He wanted to live a high standard of living and planned to use the resources and opportunities in America that were unavailable in the Netherlands to gain money.
Harry married Luella Srtother, an owner of a farm and grocery store in 1927 after replying to her lonely hearts ad in Lonely Hearts Magazine. Despite being married, Harry decided to take out his own lonely hearts ads to gain more money and companionship. He posted fake information in his ads in an attempt to get more attention from lonely women; because of this, many women wrote back. Postal records indicated that replied to Harry’s ad poured in at a rate of 10-20 letters per day. He eventually constructed a garage and basement in his home in Quiet Dell; the garage was later determined to be where he committed the murders.
After he was arrested in 1931, police investigation using fingerprints and photographs revealed that he had also been incarcerated for burglary under his birth name in Barron County, Wisconsin in 1921-1922. Though he wasn’t charged,he was suspected of involvement in the 1928 disappearance of Dudley C. Wade, a carpet sweeper salesman who Harry once worked with, and the unsolved murder of a Jane Doe in Morris, Illinois.
The first murder he was eventually convicted of was in 1931. Using the name Cornelius O. Pierson, Harry began writing letters to Asta Eicher, a widowed mother of three in Park Ridge, Illinois. Harry visited Asta and her children – Greta, Harry, and Annabell – on June 23, 1931, and shortly after left with Asta for several days. A woman named Elizabeth Abernathy cared for Asta’s kids while she was gone. Elizabeth got a letter saying that “Cornelius” was going to pick up the children to join him and their mother. When he came, he sent a child to a bank window to withdraw money from their mother’s account. The child came back empty handed because the signature on the check turned out to be forged. Harry took the children and quickly got away. He even told concerned neighbors that they were on a vacation trip to Europe.
Later, Harry attracted Dorothy Pressler Lemke from Northborough, Massachusetts, who was also looking for love through a lonely hearts ad. He brought her to Iowa to marry her, then persuaded her to withdraw $4,000 from her bank account. Dorothy didn’t notice that, instead sending her luggage to Iowa, where Harry claimed to be living, he sent them to the address of Cornelius O. Pierson of Fairmont, West Virginia. Both women and Asta’s children had went missing with no explanation.
The murders came to light on August 26, 1931 when the police started looking into the disappearances of Asta Eicher and her children. Police began searching into Asta’s last known contacts, and they found that Cornelius Pierson was one of them. The police realized that no one named Cornelius Pierson lived in Clarksburgh, West Virginia but the description of Cornelius matched Harry Powers. Police eventually obtained a search warrant for Harry’s home in Quiet Dell.
After searching the home, police found the crime scene in four rooms located under the garage. Bloody clothing, hair, a burned bankbook and a small bloody footprint of a child was found. Police dug up a freshly filled in ditch found on the property; because of this, the bodies of Asta Eicher, her children, and Dorothy Lemke were found. Evidence and autopsy reports showed that the two girls and their mother were strangled to death while the boy’s head was beaten in with a hammer. Dorothy was uncovered with a belt wrapped around her neck, which she was strangled with. Love letters were found in the trunk of Harry’s car; he had written back to many women and had intentions of stealing their money and killing them, similar to his last victims.
On December 12, 1931, Harry was sentenced to death by hanging. Judge John Southern said, “It is the judgement of the court that you will be taken to the state penitentiary at Moundsville, there to be kept and treated in the manner provided by law and then hanged by the neck until dead on March 18, 1932 between the hours of sunrise and sunset.”
On March 18, 1932, Harry was walked to the scaffold at the Moundsville State Penitentiary to be hanged. He declined to make a last statement. The guard put a cap over his head at 9:00 a.m., the button was pushed that dropped Harry through a trap door. He was pronounced dead by the prison doctor and a physician who witnessed the hanging after eleven minutes.