This weekend I read Dead Man’s Hand by James Butcher. I thought it was the start of a new series by award-winning urban fantasy author Jim Butcher; it’s actually the debut urban fantasy novel by his son. Very confusing
Tl;dr: It was fairly enjoyable, and some of the worldbuilding felt new and original. I have no interest in continuing the series
It’s a fairly standard premise: it’s set in a world exactly like ours, except some people can do magic. This isn’t a secret though and is well-integrated, so there’s a government agency that deals with regulating magic use and cleaning up after magical mishaps. Witches (gender neutral) can apply to work for the Department, and the ones who don’t still need to apply for permits to practice magic and develop new spells. There is also some amount of fantasy creatures in this world like vampires, werewolves, and fae that are handled by the Department, but that’s not really explored in the first book
There are a couple of really cool aspects of the worldbuilding. The first is the Elsewhere. The idea of an invisible magical world overlaid on the normal world isn’t new, but I like Butcher’s take on it. Normal people can’t interact with the Elsewhere, but witches can. This is a very bad thing, because it’s a warped hellscape reflection of the real world full off monsters that like to eat witches. All witches wear a magical mask to block out the sight of the Elsewhere. You can also physically enter the Elsewhere via mirrors, at which point you’re playing with full Faewild time-fuckery
Butcher’s version of familiars was also pretty cool. They aren’t regular animals or magical constructs. Instead, you take the parting spirit of an animal and pass it through a biomechanical construct to get an imprint of its soul. You don’t trap the soul, but repeat this process a bunch of develop the platonic ideal outline of what the animal is like. It’s very interesting
The plot was fairly mid. Buddy cop story featuring the snarky new kid and the gruff old retiree, trying to solve a solve a murder and recover the MacGuffin on their own, while the Department is dogging their heels. I could see the structure of a really good story in there, but this is Butcher’s first novel and he doesn’t quite have the skill yet to pull it off. Reminds me of Weir’s Artemis in that way. I can see you enjoying it if you’re really into that kind of thing (or Jim Butcher’s novels), but the ending sets up that the rest of the series is going to be more of the same, and that’s not for me