I loved your post about love vs lust in ASIB; I do have a question, though. You said, "Irene attempts at the end to take advantage of his feelings for her, pleading with him that it was just a game, that it doesn’t mean she doesn’t actually care for him." I thought it meant the opposite: she did love him, Sherlock knows because of her password, and she's trying to tell him, "this is just part of the game" (i.e. my love for you is not real). Thoughts?
That’s certainly a way to interpret it, but I think by that point, even Irene knew it was too late to convince Sherlock that her attraction to him wasn’t in part real. She seemed to think that the proof Sherlock offered was pretty damning, and even if not, the way she responded to it certainly was. Before, when she was trying to convince Sherlock it wasn’t real, her expressions were light and mocking. When she says “this is just part of the game” however, it is fearful.
No, I think in that moment, Irene, being someone who is skilled at manipulating emotions, would think that her best bet is to use Sherlock’s genuine feelings for her against him, as she has successfully done all along. But Sherlock is not as naive as she, Moriarty, Mycroft, or even John believes, and so she fails.
If you’re still convinced it’s the other way around though, I’d love to hear your explanation. Also, it’s not completely relevant, but this follow-up post I wrote to “Love vs. Lust” might also make my position a bit more clear.
Thank you for the question!