sword0fstorms replied to your post:
It's definitely baffling. Gilbert is also a platonic S support for both m!Byleth and F!Byleth if you did the Blue Lions route.
I knew that Gilbert was the m/m options and tbf I don’t know anything about him either other than he has an... let’s call it ill defined relationship to Anette. I did not know that it was platonic. I knew that this game had some slim pickings for m/m pairings but making half of them platonic is kind of absurd.
kendrixtermina replied to your post:
He mentions the wife & kids in a lot of monastery dialogue; I don't think it's per se bad to have some platonic S supports, it's a good option to have, just like being able to stay single (though it *was* defs a problem when there was only one m/m option; At least they've since remedied this somewhat) - it's not like female Byleth can marry him either.
I don’t think I’ve ever heard him talk about his wife or kids (I am only on chapter 7--it sounds like so little for having played 20+ hours already! I just finished the Fates trilogy where the first 10 chapters would go by in 5 hours or less.)
Fair point on the platonic S supports. I’ve been living in ferdibert world where an A support is the closest you’re going to get to anything romantic, so an S support just sounds like a romantic dream. But you’re right, having some options for platonic life partners isn’t bad at all.
I’ve been mentally putting together my list for what an ideal FE game would look like, and I definitely think that making things like this clearer (S for a romantic happily ever after vs. A+ or even A++ for a platonic bond that cannot be broken for example) is on there. And if you could CHOOSE? Whether the one person you want to be with is your PARTNER IN CRIME or your ROMANTIC LIFE PARTNER? how dope would that be???
Intsys get on our level, geez
sledgehammerbutter replied to your post:
Ok I hate Aloise with a burning passion, but like how do you achieve an S rank platonic bond and barely hear about their family?
first: you have horrible taste in men because you also dislike SETETH how is that pOSSIBLE
second: I guess you do hear about them? a bit?? IDK I just thought I could marry him ;___;















