Alr so I js rewatched HTTYD 3 and I have some serioussss beef w it
So this is tweaks I would make to improve it :3 (if I was spontaneously sent back in time and made director with full creative control blah blah blah)
Also this is imooo so feel free to disagree obvi :]
First. I would beg tj miller on my HANDS ON KNEES. CLAWING AT HIS TROUSERS to come back as tuff for hidden world. I like his new va but he’s js not ruff :,) - also how is this guy voicing him for the multiple series but not this movie- 😭
Personally, I feel the hiccup and toothless vibe of this movie was js off- granted they did have their adorable bsf bits but ur telling me when hiccup gave him the tale toothless would have just left him like that??? No ty-
And to add to that- while I do love the concept of the light fury, and their black and white aesthetic, I think her hate comes from the fact she was taking toothless away from hiccup and in doing so, away from the series. I don’t blame her- she’s just following her instincts, and she doesn’t realise that the Viking’s are dragons friends here. Idk how exactly, but I’d definitely change that, so the fans blame the light fury less, maybe if we even get a bonding moment with her and hiccup, so she doesn’t seem less like this new character who took toothless away and had bbys w him
Oh yeah- about toothless- I am again going back to the fact that he LEFT HICCUP. LIKE STRAIGHT AWAY. Like sure he had that moment where he hugged him bc he thought it meant forever, but STILL 😭. We’ve grown attached to this dragon for the last 3 movies, and he just leaves like that??? I’d say ooc tbh, and I’d tweak it to make toothless more obviously torn between the two. This might be my fanself speaking, but instead of him like choosing the light fury, and saving hiccup as an afterthought, he could instead see the two equally, and actually have a dilemma about it. It would add to his character and not the past movies feel worthless
Again adding to that- idk if it was just me but I felt so awkward when hiccstrid made it to the hidden world, and toothless left it to save them. I just feel so bad for hiccup, and the movie isn’t giving him any justice 😭😭. Then to make it worse, the fury’s basically get captured, indirectly because of hiccup, which makes the awkward bad feeling even worse. Just imo, but they could have evoked another tone there
Now, this idea has probably been thought about a lot so srry if I’m being oblivious- but at the end- hiccstrid: has 2 kids. Toothless and Luna: have 3 kids. Sequel potential??? Hello???? Like instead of nine realms this is right here??? Nofink has the mainly white one, zephyr has the mainly black one, and the one left can add a little mystery to it, or they can incorporate another character here. It feels like a great setup that they js completely left in the cold
And finally, I rly don’t ljke how the dragons left- (also I am maddd that they only panned to the other riders for a teensy bit. They are the characters we see the most in series and stuff- ans Erik gets more screen time then? I wanna see their raw intense emotions of having their companion leave them). I feel like it was kinda rushed, and the writers could have kept them if they put the effort in.
Like- for me- I would make it so its like- we’ve had the scene where the dragons leave- and now we get a new scene, it’s a few weeks later, and hiccup is doing some chores of whatever on new berk. Then trees rustle and whatever, climax, the he looks up curiously, and BOOM toothless is there, with the light fury looking inquisitively behind him. Toothless and luna still live in the hidden world, but they visitttt bc that existsssss. It’s not so gut wrenchingly sad, and the dragons still go to the hidden world. I mean realistically, toothless’ tail would need maintenance. Luna can become more comfortable around humans, and heal her trauma. All their kids can grow up together, and it would be rly cute and cool. The other dragon riders see theirs too, but it would be a happy side note as the main focus is toothless and hiccup. Boom- the movie still holds change, but now it’s not so sad.
Js to be clear- I don’t hate this movie 😭😭😭- I js feel it’s a) rly sad and heartwrenching but b) isn’t dealing with the sadness in a great way, and feels a bit rushed and ooc