M’kay, so with the fresh excitement in the air from the Direct news, now seems like a good time to tell people about my fun little maybe hot take of a headcanon for the Metroid timeline! So, a while back, I was on the Metroid Database reading all of the mangas and comics it has to offer, y’know, as you do! One of the comics I came across was a comic version of Metroid Prime, and well, let’s just say a couple o’ panels caught my attention…..
This implies that Super Metroid already happened, contradicting the primarily accepted headcanon that all Prime games happened in between Metroids 1 and 2, AND breaking the secondary theory that the 2d games and Prime games are alternate universes without ANY game overlap! I know this comic isn’t canon, but when I think about this with how Prime and Fusion were released on the EXACT SAME DAY, the coincidences are too overwhelming!
So my theory? There are two timelines/universes. In one universe, we have the Samus that went through the Zero Mission and Samus Returns versions of the first two games, as well as Other M, Fusion and Dread. This timeline has the X Parasite, Adam, Raven Beak, etc!
In the other, we have the Samus whose first two games were the original NES and Gameboy versions, as well as the Prime games! The first thing that seems to set this timeline apart is the lack of X Parasite, which means the origins of the Metroids are shrouded in more mystery. Speaking of shrouded in mystery, while we do know Prime!Samus went through relatively similar origins to Fusion!Samus based on this panel-
-much less is explicitly shown or stated. Furthermore, the deviation from Fusion and Prime implies that any lore introduced in Other M, Fusion, Dread, and any other game not tied to the Prime games post-Super straight up doesn’t exist in this timeline! In other words, there is no Adam, no Raven Beak, no Metroid DNA infusion!
Speaking of Super, while this is the game that has the most overlap between the two timelines/universes, there is one altercation between the two universes that is the final proof of their distinction: the Animals! In Fusion, the Etecoons and Dachoras are shown to be alive, while in Prime, they’re nowhere to be seen! Therefore, I theorize that the Fusion vs Prime timeline, in regards to Super, is the classic Save vs “Kill” the Animals!
DISCLAIMER: This is NOT saying that the Animals are X-Parasites, nor that they caused the X-Parasite! While that is a possible interpretation of the events, I personally am listing the X vs No X and Animals vs No Animals as separate points! I’m also not stupid enough to think that the existence of characters like Adam or Raven Beak all comes down to whether or not Samus walks into a specific room and blows up a wall in a single game! What I’m referring to is more of a Butterfly Effect situation than anything else!
Of course, this is just scratching the surface of my headcanons of the Metroid timeline! I haven’t even gotten to all my crack ideas for how other canon-adjacent content might fit into lore (i.e. Samus and Joey, Captain N, etc), but I already feel like a conspiracy nut with a murder board of strings as is! Now, is this really that deep? No. Do I think this is what Nintendo has intended? Absolutely not! So why am I thinking all of this?
I have a few reasons. One, I really love the additional comics and mangas, obviously! Two, as I mentioned before, the “Fusion-Prime release date” is too much of a coincidence to not hyperfixate on! Three, the Prime events have been going on so long that trying to fit them between the first two games would be a tighter fit than Samus in the Morph Ball! Four, throughout the 2D & OM games, Fusion!Samus monologues SO MUCH about her past that it looks awfully suspicious that she NEVER mentions the Prime game events!
But the real reason I’m grasping for this theory, the petty and childish motive that has driven this whole rabbit hole, is that it would NOT be fair if THIS-
-were the SAME timeline! It just would not be fair! I don’t CARE if she loses the abilities by the end of the game, her lesbian energy would shatter the universe if these occurred in the same version of the character! So, for the sake my own sanity, and to appease my indulgent desires, I’m just going to cope by telling myself I have two cakes! Okay? Okay! Good talk!