it's bad enough that the writers more often than not have used female love interests (for buck specifically) as nothing more than plot devices and rarely bothered to even give them more than one personality trait (or even last names), but seeing fans put these characters on pedestals and act like they weren't flawed (which is not necessarilly a bad thing) or poorly/under-written and could do no wrong is truly the cherry on top for me.
taylor kelly was easily the most three dimentional fml we ever had for buck. she had a personality. she was smart, witty, had a complex past and was highly ambitious. and most importantly, she had flaws, like every real human being. it's one of the reasons i loved her as a character and would root for her to be back on the show now and then.
ignoring her flaws and mistakes only diminishes her as the multifaceted character that she was/is.
she was wrong to run the story on jonah. there's no dancing around it. not only did she go back on her word to buck; promising him not to run this story, she lost her integrity as a journalist by using information given to her "off the record".
while the latter point isn't really up for debate, with the former, you could argue that it was always in her nature to prioritize her work and career ambitions over love. and i would agree. doesn't make what she did morally right though. And thats OKAY. fictional female characters can be morally grey or "bad" and you're still allowed to love them and root for them.
in my personal opinion, she was in the wrong for doing it because (again) not only did she break her promise to her romantic (relatively long term) partner, she also risked jeopardizing the LAFD's image and the firehouse that she knew were family to her boyfriend.
yes, perhaps someone else would've run it, but someone else would not have all the info she had prior to jonah's arrest, and someone else wasn't close with one of the firefighters close to the situation.
you normally don't step on your boyfriend's family to reach your career goals, and if you do, you can't expect your boyfriend to be okay with it.
Tldr: taylor kelly was flawed, and it's what made her such an interesting and compelling character.













