OMG! would you mind doing some headcanons about the creeps doing the pocky challenge w/ the reader? im not sure if you ever heard about the pocky challenge so you might wanna search it up! maybe do from easily flustered to going by the flow (something like that..) pretty pleaseee!!! <3 thank you :3
Omg this sounds so fun absolutely!
Toby-
• He’d be really nervy while asking you to do it
• Plain chocolate kind
• would definitely take huge bites to speed it up
• He would break it a lot due to ticking
• He just wants an excuse to kiss you while also having a sweet treat
• Would let you have the chocolate side.
• Toby would lose a lot.
• He would forget about the game every so often and just end up making out with you before swapping back to the game.
Eyeless Jack-
• He didn’t know what the game was but agreed to play it with you
• Would give you the chocolate side since he wasn’t too big on sweet things anyway.
• Won most of the time
• Took the game a bit too seriously
• Jack would rather just kiss you directly
• A bit awkward at first since he didn’t understand the game but he got the hang of it quickly.
• You used the chocolate kind.
BEN DROWNED-
• He seen it online and knew he wanted to try it with you
• He was really awkward about it but chilled out after you agreed to play
• He lost mostly since he would get a bit flustered and break it.
• you’d have a mix of plain chocolate and strawberry kind
• He would take the chocolate side of the chocolate ones and let you have the strawberry side of the other ones.
• Definitely took a photo of you guys playing
• (if dating) He used this as an excuse for you guys to have your first kiss.
Jeff The killer-
• Would initially refuse to play but eventually agree.
• You’d use the mint chocolate flavour
• Jeff would take the flavoured end
• He lost mostly since he would keep getting annoyed or talking making the treat break off.
• Total grump while playing
Nina the killer-
• She asked you to play
• you guys used a bunch of different flavours
• Nina made sure to take turns on who had the biscuit end and flavoured end.
• Definitely sneaked a few kisses through the game
• She Won most of the games because she’d make you laugh
• Nina would take a few pictures to remember the activity by.
Nina’s comments-
I only ended up doing a few because it was getting a bit repetitive and I’m pretty unfamiliar with the game!
Thank you for the ask it was fun to do! <3
Nina out!












