CeCe Drake Theory/N.A.T. club theory/A Team theory.
I got to thinking, maybe CeCe is related to Wilden, here's why.
-CeCe mentions that her and Ali's families rented summer houses at Cape May. If Wilden is her brother then there's his reason for being in Cape May.
-CeCe and Wilden are both from Rosewood. CeCe's picture was in the Rosewood yearbook. In the first secret we seen Wilden twice, once bringing home a drunk Ashley Marin. And again at the Kahn party talking to Jenna.
-CeCe knew about Hanna's shoplifting. She claimed Ali talked about the girls to her, only Hanna's stealing didn't start until after Alison's death. However, Wilden knew about Hanna's shoplifting.
-Alison referred to Wilden as the beach hottie, so she didn't have to tell CeCe she was sleeping with her brother.
-CeCe said, "I've seen cops do a lot worse."
-In the Kahn Game, Spencer asks Jenna "What else have you lied about?" Jenna looks at CeCe
So here's the theory part. I think there are two groups. The A Team and N.A.T. Club. So who's who?
The A Team, those who have been hurt/tormented by Ali and the liars.
-Jenna (Leader Red Coat) I think Jenna wanted revenge on Alison and the liars for blinding her. Jenna got close to Garett for access to N.A.T. Information and of course to make sure her video wasn't seen. Jenna and Mona met in the first secret. It's safe to say that between what Mona and Toby had probably told her about Alison she had plenty of reason not to like her.
-Mona (Jenna's right hand man) the brains and stealth behind the A teams menacing acts.
-Toby (recruited) I think Jenna gave Toby the option after what Emily put him through. It was his goal to get inside info on the girls but he fell for Spencer.
-New Unknown Member I think is Noel. I think the only reason Mona was with him was to get his help. I think once he was dating Jenna, he got recruited. And has an axe to grind with Aria.
N.A.T. Club, the we see all club famous for video taping people without their knowledge and learning all the secrets of Rosewood.
-Ian we know Ian liked to make Movies, we also know Alison was interested in him. (Dead)
-Garett dated Jenna, pretended to kill Alison, then lied for her by telling Jenna he did it. (Dead)
-Jason Alison's older brother, stoner, drunk.
-Melissa Hastings maybe not an official member but knows too much.
-Jenna, pretty sure she is a double agent. Working both NAT and A team
-Wilden I think Wilden was an NAT member, I assume since it's been mentioned that he enjoyed partying, maybe he was one of "Jasons's Friends" Alison often referred too.
-CeCe I think CeCe was also a member of the NAT club, she went to rosewood.
-Meredith & Ezra are also suspicious of N.A.T to me
So I think there may be one or two more members of each one. But overall with what is happening right now. I think the N.A.T. Club knows who killed Alison. I think it was one of their members, and they are all risking their lives to keep this secret buried. I don't think Wilden killed her but I think he is suspicious because if it got out that Wilden and Ali had a relationship he would be number one suspect. I think everyone on the N.A.T. Club had some sort of spiff with Alison that night. The goal is to keep their secrets not just safe but buried.
Ian's death. He was willing to kill to keep their secrets, when the girls were getting close to answers. (he tried to kill spencer) only A intervened and pushed him. Whether he died instantly or not is unsure. But A team moved his body. Then someone (undetermined A team or N.A.T. Club) shot him and forged the suicide note.
Garett's death. Shot on the Halloween Train. By unknown assailant. My theory. N.A.T. & A team were both on the train. Known members on train - A team- Mona & Toby - NAT members Garett, Jason, Jenna. I think someone on NAT shot him after he confessed some secrets to Spencer and Jason was involved in discarding the body.
Both were accused of killing Alison before their death.
Other times N.A.T. Members have been harmed.
-Melissa's car accident
-Jason's elevator incident
-Jenna almost dying in fire at Jason's house
Jenna/CeCe friendship- at the end of 3x20 CeCe tells Aria she owes her one, at the end when A is playing spin the bottle it lands on aria but it gets moved to spencer, giving aria a free pass. I think CeCe told Jenna that. And Jenna told her minions Aria catches one break.
A put a snake in Spencer's dressing room at CeCe's boutique either A had her do it, or she gave A access to do it.
CeCe gave a rude call to Jenna to keep her away from Nate. Jenna may have set that up for CeCe to do. As Jenna knew what a creep Nate really was.
CeCe and Jenna both mention Cape May, and we seen Jenna talking to Wilden. Assuming I'm right and CeCe and Wikden are siblings maybe Jenna knew them both from there.
CeCe Twin theory
Okay so the twins in Alison's story, and the girl who visited Hanna's mom looked awful a lot like CeCe. So here's my theory on that. CeCe is the one with the twin. She stabbed her twin as a child, out of jealousy. The moved from their old house on mockingbird to a new house. They sent CeCe off to Radley. As we know from Mona Radley can cure someone by summer, so we now have teenage CeCe who meets Alison. They hit it off until Alison starts acting like CeCe. Which makes CeCe inferior. And once again jealous. If CeCe had mental issues it would explain why Widen had "party boy issues" he prob came from a broken home with a dead sister and a crazy one. I think if anything CeCe killed (thinks she killed) Alison and Widen is trying to help keep it a secret. CeCe is prob the one who hit Ali with the shovel.
Ali could have more than one attacker that night. She was hit hard in the back of the head, someone may have just left her for dead, and someone else came along found her still alive and finished the job by burying her.