Pope Heyward x plus-size reader, Rafe Cameron x plus-size reader, JJ Maybank x plus-size reader.
Plus Size! Reader is more confident and didn't realise the boys (JJ, Pope, and Rafe) liked her really because she thought they were all in a relationship, you know (with Kie, Cleo, and Sofia), but they are into her.
Inspired by an idea in the DMs shared with - @chalahyung01
You wake up in your bed to your Staffordshire Bull Terrier, Bella, waking you up, grabbing your slippers, and getting ready to take the dog out while wearing a baggy sweatshirt and short shorts. You walk down stairs in your house when you, Sarah, passed out on your couch, remembering the party you went to the night before.
"Yo, Sarah, wake up," you say, walking past her.
You open the back door, letting Bella out. You stand there as you see JJ passed out in your backyard. "Yo, JJ, what the fuck?" you yell out too as he wakes up walking up the steps. "You got any food?" JJ asks, and you nod. "Bella, get in here!" you shout out to your dog.
As you and Bella walk into the kitchen, "Do you know who all slept here?" you ask JJ as he shakes his head. "I'm gonna go look around and see who I can find." You head into the living room to see John B with Sarah; now you roll your eyes before heading upstairs, where you see Kiara with Cleo in your guest room. Walking past the bathroom, you find Pope asleep next to your radiator. You kick him, attempting to wake him up. "Pope, wake up."
Once everyone was downstairs, you asked the almighty question, "Are we going out tonight?" A chorus of yes erupts as you nod. "I'm going to shower; someone stay and watch Bella, please," you say, noticing how all of their presence at once has excited the dog.
As you head upstairs, you hear Pope and JJ arguing, most likely over who can leave, smiling to yourself, you go in your shower. After an hour you change into a pair of jeans and a black vest top, getting ready to take Bella out for a walk. When you walk downstairs, you see JJ sitting on the couch cuddling with Bella.
"Oh hey, Jay, I didn't think you'd be the one to stay," you say to JJ, grabbing your backpack. "Why wouldn't I? Bella loves me most; I'm basically her dad," JJ says as you look at him confused. "Does that make me her mom?" You ask JJ, "Well, I'm going to take her for a walk if you want to come with?" You ask JJ to smile, grabbing Bella's leash. "Whoa, yeah, finally," you take it from him, putting it on her.
As you and JJ walk Bella, you see Pope talking to Cleo. "Hey, guys," you yell, and as you and JJ walk, Pope turns, glancing at you both, frowning. You keep walking, upset. "I wonder what that was about," you ask, walking away. "Maybe it's trouble in paradise," you continue, JJ looking a bit confused. "What do you mean?" JJ asks, wrapping his arm around your shoulder. "You know how Cleo and Pope are dating? Maybe they are fighting," JJ smirks to himself before speaking up. "Right, Cleo and Pope."
As you both walk past the wreck, "Go see your girl," you say to JJ, hinting about him and Kiara. He stops before you walk away. "Go see Kie," you yell as you walk away.
Hours pass, and you begin getting ready to go out drinking with the pogues. You slip on a white dress with black detailing and black boots with a white purse; you do your makeup in a casual yet still elegant look. Leaving your house, you see the pogues waiting in Twinkie; as you get in, you see a spot open between Pope and JJ. Sliding in, you smile at them both before Cleo smirks at you.
"Marry me?" Cleo asks, and you smile to yourself about how Cleo thought you looked. As you get on the beach.
Walking over to the keg, you pour yourself some beer before approaching Sofia.
"Hey, Sofia, right?" You walk over smiling, "Yeah, (Y/N), right?" She asks in response, unaware she already knew who you were.
"You work at the country club that must be hard" you say as she nods "Yeah it is hard but I get all the tea so" you both share a laugh as you glance at rafe who is rapidly approaching you nudge her arm "Hey how is everything going with you two" you ask sincerely "what do you mean" sofia asks "aren't you and rafe together" you ask confused about it when she shakes her head "I know what people may think but rafe likes someone else" you nod your head as she walks away as rafe arrives "Hey doll, you look nice" you smile at rafe thanking him
After an hour of flirting with rafe, pope and jj approach as they seem tense you wave rafe off walking off with them.
The next morning, as you let Bella out, you hear arguing coming from the front yard. Bringing Bella in, you walk out to see JJ, Pope, and Rafe arguing.
"HEY, IDIOTS, WHAT THE FUCK?" you yell as they all look at you in your pyjamas, which was a pair of shorts and a vest. JJ staring at you as if you could solve all the world's problems without breaking a sweat, Pope looking at you like you were an angel and Rafe seemingly whispering about a wedding when you notice all three are holding different bouquets of flowers.
Jj was holding a handful of wildflowers he seemingly picked himself while Pope was holding a mix of daisies and tulips. Rafe was holding two dozen red roses. You invite the three in, sitting them down. "Bella, be a good girl and sit," you say to Bella, who instinctively ran to JJ before grabbing a vase and putting the flowers in there.
After putting the flowers away, you sit down.
"What the hell was that?" you ask as all three go shy. "Quit looking around like idiots. Okay, JJ, what about Kiara?" you say, frustrated. "What about her?" he responds, "She's your girlfriend," you say, growing angry as JJ speaks up. "Me and Kie aren't dating; she was giving me advice on how to ask you out," he says as Pope speaks up. "That's the same with me and cleo" Rafe smirks before speaking up.
"I never deceived you," you say right before speaking. "I thought you were dating Sofia." Rafe sighs before shaking his head. "Rafe, I don't know if you've changed from your frat boy ways because I know frat boys like to bully girls like me who are bigger," you say angrily as Rafe gets on his knees begging you to believe he means it.
"Whoa, okay, so wait, you all want to date me?" You ask as the three boys nod, "What to do?" you ask yourself when JJ speaks up, "I wouldn't mind sharing." Pope then speaks, "I agree with him." You all look at Rafe, who sighs begrudgingly before nodding, "Me too," he adds on as you smile, feeling arms wrap around you and seeing Rafe hugging your waist and feeling both JJ and Pope kissing your forehead.
"Wait, I'm all of your girlfriends," you ask to make sure.
"Yes," the three boys say in unison as you text the group chat with Sarah, Cleo, and Kiara, telling them about this crazy situation.
