Spell Caster (M)
★ PAIRING: Etsywitch!Renjun x Reader x Jaemin
☆ WORD COUNT: 12k~
★ GENRE(S): slight E2L, smut, magic!au
☆ SUMMARY: When your best friend hires a witch from Etsy to make her crush fall in love with her, you're skeptical. You’ve never believed in magic and you’re doubtful about whether the witch’s powers are real. Curious to find out the truth, you decide to do some digging of your own
★ ☆ WARNINGS: unprotected sex, mature, 18+ MDNI
☆★ NOTES: Im sorry i missed Halloween I was supposed to get this finished in October but i was lazy TT please enjoy. Im not sure when the next fic will be out, i do have a jeno one i have been sitting on ill probably drop that and then dip for another year. Jk idk when ill be back but dont let this flop PLEASE!
-support me here <3
⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺
Blocked again.
You were sitting outside sprawled out in the middle of the yard, letting the hot sun beat down on you. You’d been told countless times that touching grass and getting enough vitamin D would clear your head, so you thought maybe it was worth a try.
Things were going fine until you checked your phone and noticed that you’d been blocked once again by the same guy who’s been turning your world upside down lately. Guess it’s another reminder that maybe you should have just left your phone inside. You were trying to connect with nature, but now you’re right back where you started.
Not surprised he blocked you, given the last argument you two had, but it still made you roll your eyes. You consider telling your best friend Jiwoo about it, but you could already imagine the lecture she’d give you. “You deserve better” and how “he wasn’t even all that.” Well she didn’t really know him like you did. Plus, her situation wasn’t exactly better.
Jaemin was arguably the total package. Looks, brains, and a heavenly body. To outsiders, he might seem like just a typical fuckboy, but that’s only because no one knew him like you did. He was the kind of guy to help an old lady cross the street, pick you up at 3 a.m. when you got too drunk without a single complaint, and he was great with kids. Was he a fuckboy? Oh, definitely. But you’d probably be one too if you looked like that.
Jaemin lived the fuckboy lifestyle, but he didn’t have the heart of a fuckboy and that’s what mattered. He just needed time and a little bit of work and he would be boyfriend material.
You throw your phone into the grass beside you and groan in frustration.
“This isn’t working,” you mutter, running your fingers through the blades of grass, hoping the cool dirt will calm your racing mind.
You try to will your mind to think about anything else, ANYONE else, but every single thought keeps circling back to Jaemin. The way he whispered sinfully sweet promises into your ear. The way his gentle yet strong hands trailed up the inside of your thighs teasingly.
Your fingers claw at the grass now, digging deep into the soil as you remember the last time you were with Jaemin.
You’d been busy all week. Halloween was coming up, and if you didn’t start on your costume now, you weren’t going to finish in time. Juggling sewing projects with work and school always gave you a headache, but this year, you were determined to start early. It took a week, some pricked fingers, a few shitty stitches, but your costume was finally done.
You got the text notification while hauling your heavy sewing machine back into storage.
“I’ve been thinking about you. I need to feel your legs wrapped around me again.” The text read.
Jaemin was always straight to the point, and you loved that.
Most of your relationships with guys never went beyond friends with benefits. You perfered it that way, not wanting the drama that came with a relationship, but something about jaemin had you wanting more. You were always hungry for his attention.
You feel yourself clench as your eyes linger over the words again and again. After the hell week you’d been through, you deserved a little treat.
“Come over.”
You were always direct, and Jaemin loved that.
Thirty minutes later, he had your knees pinned up against your chest, and your headboard knocking noisily against your bedroom wall.
His plush lips had kissed every inch of your skin, and his fingers gripped your thighs so tightly that you were sure they’d be bruised in the morning.
He always knew the perfect positions to contort your body so he could hit all the right spots, making your eyes flutter to the back of your head. You’d always try to hold back your moans, not because you were afraid of your neighbors hearing, but because Jaemin made the most sinful noises that only a careful ear could catch. He’d try to stifle them, but whenever you heard a moan slip from his lips, it had you clenching down hard around him.
You weren’t sure if the cold shiver running down your spine was from the images flashing across your mind or from the autumn breeze starting to pick up. It was still the beginning of August, so it hadn’t gotten chilly just yet, but you could feel fall breathing down the city’s neck as the hot summer days grew colder and colder.
Suddenly, you remember where you are and cringe, drawing your fingers from the earth and grimacing at the dirt under your nails.
Touching grass didn’t work.
You make your way inside to clean up, taking a cold shower in hopes of calming the heat between your legs. When you step out, you plop down on your couch and scroll through movie options, eventually choosing a movie that fits the Halloween aesthetic of October. You hit play on The Craft and settle in.
Suddenly, your phone rings, and you see it’s Jiwoo trying to FaceTime you. You hesitate for a moment, considering not answering. Right now you aren't in the best state of mind, and you tend to overshare and spill your business to your best friend unprompted. You didn’t want her to know you were still hung up over Jaemin but curiosity gets the best of you, and you end up answering.
“You're interrupting my movie,” you say before you flip your camera to show the TV screen.
“You're having a spooky movie marathon and I can’t even get an invite?! You are so fake! And to think I had great news to share!”
“Oh, yeah?” You raise an eyebrow.
“Yeah! And now you’ll never know.” Jiwoo huffs dramatically.
“What a shame. I guess I’ll just hang up and go back to my movie—”
“Jiwon asked me to be his date to his Halloween party!” Jiwoo spills excitedly.
You sit up straighter at the news. “Jiwon? As in the guy you’ve had a one-sided crush on since middle school?”
“Well, it isn’t one-sided anymore, sister, so take that!”
You’re left in stunned silence. Honestly, you’re confused to say the least about this new development. Just last week, Jiwoo was using your shoulder as a snotrag, crying over Jiwon because he rejected her after she finally mustered the courage to confess.
“I mean, I’m happy for you, but isn’t this a bit odd? Don’t you think it’s weird that he rejected you just last week, and now he’s asking you to be his date to a Halloween party?”
“It’s absolutely not weird, besides I knew this would happen. I made it happen,” Jiwoo says confidently.
You can’t stop yourself from rolling your eyes. “And how exactly did you make this happen?”
“Magic! I paid an Etsy witch to cast a love spell on him, and she told me if I manifested it, it was sure to happen. And now, look!” Your friend sounds so giddy that you don’t have the heart to tell her she’s probably just gotten scammed.
You take a deep breath. “I’m happy for you, Jiwoo. Do you know what you’re going as?” You say trying to change the subject.
“Catwoman! Gonna make it really slutty!” she says excitedly.
You smile and nod. “That’s going to be so hot,” you say, snuggling deeper into your blanket.
“What about you?”
“It’s a secret. You’ll see,” you reply with a mysterious grin.
“Aw, come on!”
“Bye,” you say with a giggle before she can start badgering you and you end the call.
You turn your attention back to your movie. It’s at the part where Sarah puts a love spell on Chris after he spreads nasty rumors about her across the school. It reminds you of your conversation with Jiwoo. You’re not a fool, and you definitely don't believe in magic. Maybe something came over Jiwon, and he finally realized how amazing Jiwoo is. If not, and this was some huge joke to him, you’d be furious.
Before the Halloween party, you’re definitely going to do some detective work to find out the truth.
⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺
It had been a week since Jaemin had blocked you, and it was starting to get to you. Normally, you’d have your fights, but eventually, one of you would get horny enough to break the no-contact rule. But this was the longest you’d gone without touching him. You’d even tried to sleep with another guy. This one talked a big game, and you were more than annoyed that he couldn’t back it up. Most guys like that never delivered what they claimed, but you were desperate and horny, and you were afraid you might just pounce on the next poor guy who looked at you for too long.
All week, you’d been on edge and annoyed. You need to find something to take your mind off of everything.
Jiwoo had invited you over to carve pumpkins. You loved going to Jiwoo’s house; it was so cozy, and she always decorated like crazy for the holidays. Outside were a few Halloween decorations, ghosts and ghouls, dangled from the porch. Inside, it transformed into a total autumn cottage, filled with scents of cinnamon and apple. Blankets and throw pillows in shades of reds and oranges adorned the couch, creating the perfect atmosphere.
You were outside setting up your pumpkin to smash while Jiwoo worked diligently on sculpting hers at the long oak table on her patio, perfecting the wicked smile of her Jack-o'-lantern.
The yard is softly illuminated by strings of orange and purple fairy lights. A scarecrow with a tattered hat and a plaid scarf stands near the garden where you had set up your smashing zone. Scattered cobwebs cling to bushes and the corners of the porch. The air smelled faintly of dried leaves and the sunset was a deep orange.
“Hes taking me out to get coffee tomorrow. I'm so excited!” she giggles.
You finish laying down the tarp and grab a bat that lay next to the shed in her backyard. “Do you already know what you're going to wear?” you ask, trying to stay positive and not let the doubt you had creep into your voice.
“I was thinking of that pretty brown dress I got last month! I haven’t had the chance to wear it yet. I think it will be perfect,” she says, sawing away at her pumpkin to give it sharp teeth. “Will you help me accessorize?”
You grip the bat tighter in your hand and smile. “Of course, I will,” you say, swinging the bat down and cracking open the poor pumpkin.
Jiwoo glances over her shoulder at you and winces at the sight of the pumpkin. “What did that poor guy do to you?” she jokes.
“It’s been a stressful week. I'm unwinding,” you huff, swinging the bat into the pumpkin again with a grin.
“Well, don’t destroy them all. I want to have a go next! And you still need to carve one. I want to put them outside my door. Renjun says they keep away bad spirits.”
You pause your attack on the poor pumpkin and look at Jiwoo. “Renjun? Who is that?”
“That’s the witch I hired off Etsy. He’s really cool and has been giving me spiritual advice.”
You narrow your eyes. “I thought you said it was a woman.”
“I thought so too, but I finally met him the other day, and he did a tarot reading for me. He’s so insightful, I think he’s really legit.” She’s practically bouncing with excitement.
You love your friend, and you hate to rain on her parade but sometimes she can be a bit of an airhead. You take a deep breath, trying to broach the topic without sounding like an asshole.
You always seem to come off that way.
“I think you should stop seeing that guy.”
“What? Why! He’s legit! He proved it to me. He said my grandma’s spirit was still watching over me. He told me her favorite scent was banana. How would he know that if he wasn’t legit?”
“I don’t know but things like this are usually a scam. Plus, I thought he was a witch, not a medium.”
“Maybe he’s both! Can witches talk to spirits?” She tilts her head inquisitively. She shakes herself out of thought. “Regardless, he got Jiwon to finally notice me! What, are you going to tell me that’s fake too?”
You stay quiet, grip tightening on the bat in your hand.
“Well, are you?!” Jiwoo yells in frustration. The hurt in her voice causing your heart to shatter.
“Jiwoo, I’m not saying that. I just think—”
“Why can’t you just be happy for me?” she whispers. “I think you should go.” She stands from the table, her eyes unable to meet yours.
You huff in disbelief and drop the bat. “Fine,” you say coldly, turning to walk past her.
She takes your spot on the tarp as you leave. She picks up the bat and swings down hard. The loud cracking sound of the pumpkin echoes as you slam the gate behind you.
⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺
Two days had passed since your argument with Jiwoo, and you still hadn’t apologized. You knew what you said was harsh, but it was the truth. A man doesn’t just suddenly become obsessed with you after years of ignoring your entire existence. If you turn out to be wrong, you’d apologize. But until then, you were determined to get to the bottom of this.
That’s why you were stalking your best friend. Something about the whole love spell thing still didn’t sit right with you, and you needed to see it in action with your own two eyes.
Well, maybe not your eyes.
“If she catches me spying, I’m snitching, I hope you know that,” a voice grumbles through the phone.
You were lying in bed, half studying for an upcoming test and half listening to the live updates you were getting.
You had your friend yuta follow Jiwoo and Jiwon on their coffee date because no matter how sneaky you tried to be, Jiwoo would notice you snooping from a mile away.
Courtesy of all the times you’d spied on her dates in the past.
Jiwoo was like a little sister to you. She had been your friend since kindergarten, and she had a soft, gentle heart that you couldn’t stand to see get hurt. If any guy was going to have your Jiwoo, it would have to be someone you could approve of without a doubt.
Of course, as you grew older, you became less overbearing and protective. Jiwoo was a grown woman now who could take care of herself, but something about this just didn’t sit right with you. You knew Jiwon, and while he wasn’t outright scum, he definitely hadn’t paid Jiwoo any mind in the past. He knew she had a crush on him since middle school, so why would he suddenly make a move now?
"Just hush and focus the camera,” you say, glancing at your phone.
Jiwon had taken Jiwoo to her favorite coffee shop and looked to be paying for both of their drinks. Okay, that was one green flag, but honestly, it was the bare minimum of what any girl deserved.
“Aw, he pulled her chair out for her,” Yuta says with a smile on the other line.
You make a sound of approval as you read over some of your notes, having been studying intently before Yuta's call
“He seems like a nice guy so far. He's really engaging in conversation, and his body language is open,” Yuta updates again.
Your eyes drift back to your phone, watching the scene unfold with your own eyes.
Jiwoo and Jiwon were sitting by the window of the coffee shop. Jiwon was turned completely towards Jiwoo, smiling softly at her. He offered her a sip of his drink, and she beamed at the taste. She looked genuinely happy, and most of all, he looked really in love.
“I see. Thank you Yuta. Sorry for the trouble, I just had to be sure. That’s enough,” you say.
Yuta flips the camera back to himself and offers you a comforting smile. “Hey, don’t beat yourself up. You’re just trying to be a good friend… maybe a little overbearing, but your heart was in the right place.”
Your heart tightens. Maybe you were wrong, Jiwon seems so genuinely in love that it’s almost scary. You had almost ruined this moment because of your judgment and inadvertently hurt your friend’s feelings in the process. An apology was definitely in order. But before that, you needed to meet this witch called Renjun.
⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺
It took hours to find him on Etsy, but you finally came across the post that might have caught Jiwoo's eye:
NOW $299.99
Avoidant to obsessed
Cold to loving
Make them crave you
Please provide the following details in the personalization:
🌟 Your full name and date of birth
🌟 The same information for the person you're focusing on 💖
🌟 Your email address
🌟 detailed description of what your manifesting
renjunsrituals ★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
Your eyes nearly bulge from your skull. Three hundred American dollars? Was Jiwoo huffing paint when she bought this? There’s no way in hell you’re paying that. You scoff at the post and roll your eyes. Then, you click on the seller's name and send a message.
“Hello, I’m interested in getting a tarot card reading.”
You didn’t see any mention of readings in the listings, so you figure it must be an additional service he offers to clients.
“Must buy something from my shop first,” the reply states bluntly.
“Please, I really only need a reading. I was recommended by a friend who said your readings are accurate. I just want to see for myself.”
A few minutes pass without a response, so you send another message.
“How will I know this isn’t a scam without a tester product? $300 is a lot of money to spend on something I’m not sure will work. Please?”
“Buy and find out. I will provide a 100% refund if the results are unsatisfactory,” came the reply.
You tilt your head, impressed by his confidence in his product, but that wasn’t enough to get $300 out of you.
“Tarrot reading please :)”
“Are you having hardships? Want me to cast a spell to find you a job? Either pay or I’ll block you!”
You groan and finally give in. You know you won’t get anywhere if he ends up blocking you. Jiwoo doesn’t realize how lucky she is to have a friend like you.
You return to the love spell post and fill it out. You enter the first name that comes to mind:
Na Jaemin.
After your payment is processed, your phone lights up with a notification:
“Come to this address for your tarot reading.”
⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺
The next day, you head to the address Renjun sent, and honestly, you weren’t quite sure what to expect but it definitely wasn’t this. You had a clear image in your head: following some breadcrumbs through the woods and arriving at a little cottage nestled in the trees, possibly to be eaten by the witch himself. Instead, you’re standing in front of a sleek, modern building in the heart of downtown. It’s the kind of place that screams luxury.
You pause for a moment, caught between disbelief and curiosity. Renjun’s either pulling off the greatest scam of all time or running a wildly successful love spell business. Honestly, you’re not sure which option you’re hoping for more.
Before you can even step inside, a heavy, secure door blocks your way. You press the button on the intercom to Renjun's unit number, and almost immediately, an unfamiliar voice calls out, “Come on up.”
The door clicks and you tug it open, stepping into the building. Inside, a concierge greets you with a professional smile. You check in, feeling a little out of place among the polished decor and sleek furniture, and they direct you to the elevator. They give you clear instructions on how to reach Renjun’s unit.
You stand in front of his door, your hand hesitating for a moment before you gently knock. You can hear faint footsteps approaching inside, and then the door swings open to reveal Renjun.
“Hey,” Renjun says casually. “Come in.”
You weren’t expecting him to be around your age. You had imagined some decrepit old man not the polished young man that stood in front of you now. You step inside, taking in your surroundings. The condo is spacious, with high ceilings, modern art on the walls, and floor-to-ceiling windows offering a stunning city view. It’s far from the rustic cottage you’d imagined. This is pure luxury, the kind you’d expect from a celebrity.
Your feelings of suspicion begin to creep back into the back of your mind as you take in the space. If Renjun were really running a love spell business, there wasn’t anything around that gave off that impression. No jars of frog legs, no big, over-glowing cauldrons like you had imagined. It’s not like he was making love spells with just thyme and parsley so where was he keeping all his supplies?
You’re here for answers, and you were going to get them.
Renjun shows you to his living room and sitting on his glass-top coffee table was a deck of tarot cards and a mat.
“Ill be with you in just a minute” he says gently. His voice was soft like honey, the kind that made you want to believe every word that came out of his mouth.
When he returns, he has a single candlestick in hand and a lighter. He sits right across from you and begins setting up on the coffee table, lighting the candle. You’re afraid it might tip over and fall, but it stands there perfectly still, even the flame does not dance as Renjun picks up the cards from the table and starts shuffling them. You watch him prepare the cards, and you break the silence with a question.
“Can witches talk to spirits?”
Renjun gives you a look. “We prefer the terms sorcerer or mage. But regardless, yes some do while others stray away from that field. Some spirits can be..." he pauses to find the right word. "Tedius to work with. Why? Is there someone you want to reach out to?”
You shiver at his seriousness, and the fire of doubt you initially felt about his work wavers slightly. “No, just curious.”
“Well, then, let’s begin,” he says, leaning forward slightly as he starts to shuffle the cards.
He takes a card from the deck, shuffles, and then lays it face-up on the table. It’s The Magician, a card often associated with skill, resourcefulness, and manifestation.
Renjun looks up at you with a small, knowing smile. “The Magician,” he says softly. “It’s about showing what’s already there. It can also mean taking initiative, not waiting for things to happen but making them happen. Sounds like you’re here for answers, right?”
You nod, feeling a flicker of surprise but you shrug it off. Everyone who goes to a tarot reading is going for answers, you reason. He wasn't that impressive.
He flips another card: The High Priestess.
“This one’s about intuition, secrets, and trusting what you feel,” he continues. “You came with questions, and I think you already know the truth deep down. Sometimes, what we see on the surface isn’t the whole story.”
Renjun picks up the deck again, shuffling smoothly before drawing a card and laying it on the table. It’s the Three of Cups, a card symbolizing friendship, celebration, and community.
He looks up at you, eyes kind and steady. “You came here looking to help a friend. You think this friend is in need of saving when really they need a friend who lifts them up, who believes in them, who stands by them even in times of doubt.”
That last line hits a little too close to home, and you can feel shame bubbling up in your gut. You shove it down, steel your gaze, and try to keep your emotions in check.
“The love spells. If they are legit why isnt mine working?” you say voice trembling in suppressed annoyance
Renjun’s expression remains calm. “You must give these things time. The reviews never lie” he says with a hint of snark.
“Bullshit!” you snap, voice rising. You push yourself to your feet. “You’re nothing but a scam, and I’m going to get proof. When I do, you better hope I don’t find you.”
Without waiting for a response, you turn and storm out of his apartment, your mind racing with a hundred different emotions.
⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺
You didn’t believe in magic, but that might be the only explanation for why Jaemin is standing in front of you with a bouquet of flowers and an apology. “I know we’ve had our fair share of arguments, but that just proves how much we’ve grown. I’m sorry for being distant and for being immature by blocking you instead of working things out,” he says, pushing the gift in your direction.
Jaemin admitting he's immature?
Renjun’s definitely getting a five-star review from you later. You almost feel bad about chewing him out the other day.
“I know this probably isn’t nearly enough to make up for everything, so I got us a dinner reservation at 7. Please say you’ll go?” he asks hesitantly.
So apparently magic is real and it can make world-renowned playboy Na Jaemin take you out on a date.
Your hesitation lingers, but this is what you wanted, so you nod. “Sure, Jaem, I’d love to,” you say with a small smile. He leans forward and kisses you on the cheek.
⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺
After countless calls and texts, your friend Jiwoo finally decided to hear you out, so you took her to her favorite pho place downtown, hoping to smooth things over with good food and enough apologies.
She was already waiting outside when you arrived, and you offered her a small smile and a wave. You walk inside, and a waiter leads you to a cozy booth before taking your order for some drinks.
When the waiter leaves, an almost awkward silence settles between you two as your leg bounces nervously under the table. You had the jitters which wasn’t common for you but you hated when Jiwoo was upset with you.
“Look, Ji, I’m sorry for what I said. I shouldn’t have been so harsh,” you begin.
Jiwoo crosses her arms and looks at you, urging you to continue. “Be more specific.”
“You know…about saying that Renjun was a fake witch and implying that Jiwon’s feelings for you weren’t real,” you admit.
Jiwoo relaxes a little and speaks softly. “I know you’re just trying to look out for me, but I’m really happy right now. I need you to be here for me. Even if it’s fake, can’t I enjoy it just a little while longer?”
You hate that you made your friend feel like shit. She was right. If jiwon made her happy, then that should be enough for you. "No, I was wrong. Jiwon seems like he genuinely likes you. He's actually a gentleman, and anyone who treats you like a princess has my stamp of approval."
Jiwoo raises an eyebrow at that. “I'm glad you've had a change of heart,” she teases, a hint of amusement in her voice.
“Well, I may have stalked you two a little to check him out first,” you admit softly, knowing she’s about to chew you out for invading her privacy.
“You did what—” she starts, but just then, the waitress interrupts.
“Are you guys ready to order?”
⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺
Dinner dates, movie nights, walks in the park, the whole nine yards. That's what Jaemin has been delivering ever since he took you out on that first dinner date. You might have to send Renjun an apology text for ever doubting him.
You're currently cuddled up under the covers of your bed with Jaemin and a few snacks, watching The Nightmare Before Christmas. You were debating whether it qualified as a Halloween or Christmas movie, but eventually reached a stalemate and found yourself immersed in the world on the screen.
Laid against his chest, the warmth of his tangled limbs keeping out the autumn chill, it’s perfect. You’ve always wanted to spend October doing cute couple things like going to a pumpkin patch, or having scary movie nights with your partner.
Despite your best efforts, your eyelids start to grow heavy, and you begin to drift into sleep.
Jaemin shifts deliberately, gently prodding you with his shoulder to keep you awake. "You're really falling asleep on me?" he asks softly with a teasing smile.
You giggle and nod, keeping your eyes closed as you snuggle deeper into his chest.
“Princess, you’re missing the best part!” he whines.
You grumble in response but stay put.
“I’m not going to let you use me as a pillow then,” Jaemin threatens, rolling you off of him with a laugh.
Playfully stubborn, you feel around for a pillow but he quickly throws them all off the bed.
“Nuh uh, wake your ass up,” Jaemin teases.
You try to fight down the laughter, pulling the sheets up to your chin to get comfortable once again.
“Oh, you’re tired, huh?” Jaemin says, the devilish smile that plays on his lips is almost audible.
You fake a yawn and snore softly, playing into the game you two have going on.
Jaemin's fingertips dance lightly up your thigh, sending shivers in their wake. "Too bad," he murmurs, his hands reaching your waistband. "I've been wanting to play with you all night." He tugs at your shorts, snapping the fabric against your skin. "And I love how you look in these shorts. Makes me want to do all sorts of things."
You can't help but bite your lip as a soft whimper escapes you. Jaemin's hand slides under your tank top, finding your waist and then moving up to cup your breast. He toys with your nipple, sending a jolt of pleasure through you. "Remember how much fun we had last time? When you let me leave marks all over these sweet curves?" he whispers, his breath tickling your ear.
Your body shudders at the memory, and you can't help but lean into his touch, craving more.
In the dimly lit parking lot, Jaemin slides his seat back and pulls you to straddle his lap. "I just want to look at you, sweetheart," He promised as he cups your face, his thumb brushing your cheekbone. "I just love seeing you on top of me," he murmurs.
His gaze is intense, and you feel your resolve wavering. You had asked to keep things PG-13 for your first official date, but the way he's looking at you makes you question your own rules.
He leans in, capturing your lips in a searing kiss. His tongue explores your mouth, and his hand slides from your cheek to the base of your neck. When he pulls back, he groans softly, licking his lips. He leans back in, this time trailing kisses down your throat, making you shiver.
He slides your dress straps down your shoulders, exposing your breasts to his eager mouth. He explores every inch of your chest with his lips, but doesn’t go further than that, leaving you breathless and craving more.
You remember all too well the mirror reflecting the dark purple bruises left by his lips the next day.
Still you don’t move, wanting to see how much more you could tease Jaemin.
Jaemin playfully sighs, pulling his hand away from your skin and out from under your shirt. You shiver at the loss of his touch, feeling a sudden chill.
"Maybe you really are tired," he teases, leaning back against the headboard. "Guess I'll just have to take care of myself then." He says with a wicked grin.
You hear Jaemin settle onto the bed, his clothes rustling as they hit the floor. Your heart pounds in your chest as you listen to him spit, followed by the wet, rhythmic sound of his hand stroking his cock. His rough moans fill the room, and you can't help but imagine him biting his lip, eyes fluttering closed.
“Ugh fuck, ‘want to be in between your legs pretty girl.”
You can hear the speed at which he strokes himself change from short fast strokes to slow long strokes, the ones you know he loves, the ones that send his eyes rolling to the back of his head. He always looked so pretty like that, It was your favorite sight in the world.
Screw this.
You open your eyes to find him just as you imagined; head thrown back, mouth agape, chest heaving with each breath.
Without hesitation, you crawl between his legs, pushing his hand away and replacing it with your own. You envelop his cock with your lips, moaning at the salty taste of his precum. Jaemin tangles his hand in your hair, guiding you as he moans your name.
"That's my girl, always playing hard to get," Jaemin teases, but you ignore him, focusing on the task at hand. You take him deep into your mouth, coating him in your saliva, and begin to pump his shaft. You lavish attention on the head of his cock, fondling his balls gently. The sound of wet, sucking noises fills the room, and Jaemin's grip tightens in your hair.
"Fuck, you're amazing at that," he gasps, his breath becoming shallower. His hips begin to move subtly, fucking your throat before he lets out a reluctant groan and pulls you off him.
"Come here," he growls, pulling you to sit on top of him. He looks up at you, his eyes heavy with lust, but you can still see the adoration behind them. He grabs the back of your neck and pulls you into a messy, tongue-swallowing kiss, showing you he doesn't care that his cock was just in your mouth.
You grind against him in slow, tantalizing circles, making him thrust up into you impatiently. With a growl, he flips you onto your back and pulls down your underwear and panties in one swift motion. He grips the neckline of your tank top and pulls it down your chest, baring you to him completely.
"Fuck, you look so good," he murmurs, stroking himself as he takes you in. Without hesitation, he grips the base of your neck and holds you still while he lines himself up with your entrance, then thrusts in deeply.
You gasp, your back arching as a long drawn out moan escapes you. He sets a fast, steady pace, driving into you with each thrust. He loves missionary because it gives him a perfect view of your face, to see every expression of pleasure that crosses your features as you throw your head back and lose yourself in the moment.
Jaemin's thrusts become quicker and shallower as he nears his climax. He reaches down between your bodies, rubbing at your clit to bring you along with him.
"I'm so close," you moan, your fingers digging into the sheets beneath you. Your thighs tremble as you reach your peak alongside Jaemin.
After he helps you clean up, you snuggle up to his chest, a content smile playing on your lips.
“What’s so funny?” Jaemin asks, matching your grin.
“Nothing, just thinking about everything that happened over these past few weeks,” you reply.
Jaemin shifts comfortably and looks at you with affection. “Oh, yeah? Tell me about it.”
You laugh and sit up in bed. “Well, for starters, I think I met a real witch.”
Something in Jaemin’s expression shifts slightly, but you ignore it and keep going.
“It’s so embarrassing to admit, but when you had me blocked, it was killing me inside,” you say with a cringe. “And I may have paid an Etsy witch a ridiculous amount of money to cast a love spell on you.”
You turn to look at Jaemin because he’s been uncharacteristically quiet. “It’s stupid, probably a scam, but here you are. So tell me, did it work? Do you feel an undying love for me?” you tease, playfully shoving at his shoulder.
Only your laughter fills the room, but it dies down almost immediately when you notice Jaemin hasn’t smiled once during your story.
Fuck. Did you scare him? Maybe he thinks it’s creepy that you tried to put a love spell on him, fake or not.
“Jaem—” you start, but he quickly cuts you off.
“I have something to tell you, and I have a feeling I know exactly how you’re going to react. But please, just hear me out,” Jaemin finally says, looking at you directly.
If you were nervous before, you’re definitely shitting bricks now. You’ve never seen Jaemin this serious.
“Y/N, these last few days I’ve spent with you were the most fun I’ve had in a long time. Everything I’ve said to you is true, but I have to admit that I knew about the love spell.”
You freeze in confusion. “You knew about the love spell?”
“Renjun isn’t a real witch,” Jaemin says. “He contacted me and told me I had an admirer, and that he would pay me to pretend to be in love with them.”
Before he can finish, you’re out of bed and pacing the room, your mind racing. “Are you fucking serious?! And you just went along with it? So what, were you going to string me along until when? You got bored? Until Renjun paid you?”
Jaemin hops out of bed, reaching out to steady you, but you pull away sharply. “Please, just listen,” he pleads. “It’s not like that. I do like you. I had already agreed before I even knew it was you! I don’t care about the money!”
Your eyes narrow, anger and hurt bubbling up all at once. “Jaemin, why wouldn’t you tell me from the beginning? Even if you’re telling the truth, why hide that you knew? This is so messed up.”
“Almost as messed up as you trying to put a love spell on me?” he counters, voice sharper.
“I didn’t think it would work! And I was right. So what’s your excuse now?” You scoff.
Jaemin sighs and tries to reach out again, but you jerk away. “You need to go. I can’t do this right now.”
Jaemin's eyes flicker with hurt before he turns away, leaving you alone in the room. The door closes softly behind him, and suddenly, you're overwhelmed. Your vision blurs as tears start streaming down your face.
You're unsure how to feel. You want to believe Jaemin is telling the truth, but his sleazy actions in the past make you doubt him. Maybe everyone was right, and you didn’t know him as well as you thought you did. After all, Jaemin was a notorious fuckboy—he didn’t earn that title without telling a few girls sweet lies.
Disgust rises within you, but more than anything, you feel angry. Renjun had played you, and that meant he had played Jiwoo too. Renjun paid Jiwon to take Jiwoo out on a few dates before ultimately breaking her heart. Well you would break him before that happened.
⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺
You greet the receptionist at Renjun’s condo before making your way up to his unit. You had contacted him under the guise of needing a palm reading, but your real plan was to confront him just before you slap that slimy, scheming face of his!
He answers the door with a smile, but before he can greet you, you push past him and storm inside.
“YOU SCAMMING SON OF A BITCH!” you yell.
“Would you keep your voice down? You're going to disturb my neighbors,” he says, raising his hands defensively, trying to calm you.
“Why? Don’t want the neighborhood knowing you’re running a huge scam?” you shout again.
Renjun bristles and quickly moves past you to finally close and lock the front door. When he turns back to face you, you shove him up against it, pinning him with your forearm pressed across his chest.
“If you don’t want to choke on your tarot cards in the next few minutes you’re going to refund me and Jiwoo all our money right now,” you grit out.
“I can’t do that!” Renjun says defensively. “I’ve already used it to pay this month’s rent!”
You feel your anger flare up again. “So the whole ‘100% refund if the results are unsatisfactory’ was bullshit too? Oh, this day just keeps getting better.”
You wind your hand back, prepared to start smacking him around. At the very least it would make you feel better.
“Wait, wait, wait! It’s not too late! I can fix this!” he pleads.
You freeze and glare at him. “Unless you make me a real love potion to give to Jiwoo before this douchebag rips out her heart, I’m going to rip out yours.”
“I can! You have to trust me. I really am a sorcerer. I can make your friend a true love potion,” he insists.
You shove him harder against the wall. “You lying bastard. If you could do that, why didn’t you do it from the start? Sorcerer my ass. I’m gonna—”
Suddenly, your body begins to tingle, and a shiver shoots straight through your bones. You feel something otherworldly engulf you like a mist. The next thing you know, you’re looking up at Renjun’s shoes. You open your mouth to speak, but what comes out horrifies you.
Croak. Croak.
You try to move your hands, to speak or fight, but your new body won’t obey. Instead, you leap several feet into the air. You scream…
Well, you try to but the sound that escapes is just another croak.
Renjun catches you mid-air, holding your cold, slimy form in his hands.
“If you’d just listened,” he sighs, “none of this would’ve happened. Like I said, I’m a real sorcerer—or witch, as you folk like to call it.” Renjun rolls his eyes. He didn’t bother going into the details, non-magic folks always had trouble with the right terms and he wasn’t interested in debating labels.
“Anyway, I want to help your friend, but I need time. Making a proper love potion isn’t easy. The magic is complex and delicate. Without the right calculations and care, it can turn into an obsession spell. Those are dangerous and really hard to undo. True love potions are tricky to get right, and with how much work it takes, I can’t promise every batch will get the attention it needs. That’s part of why I’ve been scamming. But if it’s just one, I can give it a shot. I’ll need your help.”
You sit in his palm, blinking at him with your bulging toad eyes, taking in his words through your new, amphibian ears. He chuckles softly, taking in your toad body before clearing his throat and regaining his serious composure.
“Now I’m going to change you back. If you pick another fight, I might turn you into something worse… like a worm,” he says, amused, with a slight chuckle.
There’s nothing you can do besides wait for him to change you back. You can’t even form the words to promise him you’ll be on your best behavior. You contemplate the risk of being turned into a worm forever just to beat him over the head with his own broomstick, if he had one.
Renjun leans forward and gently places a soft kiss on the top of your toad head.
The same strange sensation from earlier floods your system. When you open your eyes, you’re eye-to-eye with Renjun again, and you let out a sigh of relief. Before you can open your mouth to ask him what his plan is for the love potion, you feel a breeze. Renjun looks at you with beet-red cheeks, frozen in place. His hands rest on your hips from where he held you in your toad form, faces barely an inch apart. You can feel his clammy palms against your bare… skin.
You look down and see your clothes in a pool around you. You scream for real this time.
⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺
You had been going to Renjun’s place every day. He told you he’d need your help if he was going to make the love potion before Halloween. Apparently, that’s when Jiwon was planning to break up with Jiwoo. You found yourself running around town, helping him gather various magical items from hidden shops. He’d dubbed you his apprentice, but honestly, you felt more like his errand boy.
Earlier that day
“On 8th Street, there’s an alleyway next to the coffee shop I had you get me coffee from the other day. If you wander into it at either 3 p.m. or 3 a.m., a shop will appear. Tell Giles I sent you. He knows what you’re there to collect.”
You jot down the instructions in your notebook and nod.
“Oh, and grab me a coffee on your way back,” he adds.
You roll your eyes.
You walk back to Renjun’s condo with a brown paper bag sandwiched between your arm and two coffees in hand. You didn’t have the heart to look inside the rolled-up bag the old man at the magic shop slid to you, too afraid that some three-eyed creature might come jumping out at any moment. You sip on your drink, your mind wandering as nothing eventful happens on the quiet street.
Maybe you could get Renjun to make you a truth potion to give to Jaemin. You needed to find out if he’d been honest all along but that could wait. Your focus was on fixing the Jiwon-Jiwoo mess. Honestly, the thought of giving Jiwon a love potion to make Jiwoo happy didn’t bother you as much as it probably should have. It took you about two seconds to realize that you didn’t care who you had to sacrifice, jiwoo deserved happiness, even if it meant a little manipulation. Plus, if Jiwon agreed to this scam that made him a colossal douchebag, he could probably use a little extra love in his cold heart.
You finally make it back to Renjun’s place, luckily in one piece. The other errands he had sent you on were not nearly as easy as this one. You pass him his drink and glance over his shoulder at the scattering of books sprawled across the floor and the cluttered dinner table, where open pages and notes are strewn about. The scent of incense lingers in the air, mingling with the faint aroma of coffee.
“So, how exactly does the love potion work?” you ask, curiosity piqued as you settle into the worn armchair nearby.
Renjun stretches, taking a break from the table he’s been slaving over. “Despite popular belief, it doesn't turn you into a mindless love slave," he explains. "You still have full control over your thoughts and actions, but it heightens the positive feelings someone has for another. It’s like putting rose-colored glasses on, deluding them into overlooking their partner’s flaws and focusing only on what they love about them.”
“Ah, I see,” you say, nodding slowly. “So, it’s like that saying, love makes you blind and stupid. Like when girls fall for guys who are clearly red flags but they choose to ignore everything bad about them anyway.”
Renjun chuckles softly. “Yup. Maybe it’s a ‘delulu’ potion,” he jokes, a playful smirk tugging at his lips. “While it’s less dangerous than an obsession spell, it can still be risky for the person it’s cast on. Let’s say your friend is a huge red-flag manipulator, this potion would make the guy completely blind to that.”
“My Jiwoo is nothing like that, rest assured,” you say, staring at the jumble of books and mystical artifacts around you. Renjun’s explanation makes you feel more confident. At least you wouldn’t be completely stripping Jiwon of who he was or something like that.
Renjun hums a soft melody as he works, his eyes skimming over pages and pages of ancient books
“Where’s the thing I sent you to get?” he asks, taking a slow sip from his coffee, eyes still on the open pages.
You get up from your chair and find the crumpled brown paper bag before handing it over. Renjun sets his drink down carefully, then reaches inside and pulls out an item that instantly makes your stomach churn. You’re glad you didn’t open the bag on the walk back.
“Ogre’s tongue,” Renjun explains, examining the thick, slimy-looking piece with a keen eye. “Fresh one, too. Exactly what I needed. Thanks.”
You pinch your nose and grimace. “You’re welcome,” you mutter, feeling a little queasy.
Renjun turns back to his work, busying himself with the ingredients and the pages in front of him. You find yourself standing awkwardly in his living room. Normally, you’d have made an excuse to leave by now after completing his errands, but over the past few days, you’d grown accustomed to his company. Plus, things seemed to be ramping up in the preparation of the potion. Not every day do you get to witness a witch brewing a potion, especially one as complex as this.
Curiosity gnaws at you. You want to see how much progress Renjun has made since the first day. Quietly, you watch from your spot, trying to peek over his shoulder to see what he’s doing with the ogre’s tongue and the other ingredients you’d gathered.
His hands move with practiced diligence, slicing, mixing, and sorting through the ingredients. You feel yourself rising onto your tiptoes, eager for a better view. Clumsy and distracted, you trip forward over a book lying on the floor.
Renjun sighs, and his hands finally freeze mid-motion. “You want to watch?” his calm voice asks.
You nod, cheeks flushing with embarrassment.
“Then make yourself useful,” he commands, a hint of a smirk curling at his lips. “Be my hands.”
Without a word, you step closer and fall into step beside him, ready to assist in whatever way he needs. You do your best to keep pace, you don’t want to hinder his progress with any clumsy mistakes. Together, you work in perfect harmony for hours.
These days, you’ve grown better at reading Renjun. You notice it, the slight crease in his brow, the way he slams another book shut with more force than necessary. Renjun clicks his tongue in frustration, flipping open another book, pages fluttering wildly.
“What you’re looking for isn’t in any of these books, is it?” you ask softly, trying to piece together the flicker of annoyance behind his furrowed brow.
Renjun bites his fingernail, his expression tightening. “Correct,” he says dryly. His focus is intense, and you can’t help but love the look. It’s like he’s an unstoppable force, relentless in his pursuit of the answer. He’s so absorbed in his work, and you’re captivated watching him. You love the way his mind races, the way his hands move with purpose.
“This is what I’ve managed to create based on what I could infer from my sources,” he says softly, his voice low. “It’s something, but it’s not perfect and that’s what’s been bothering me.”
“Is there anything I can do? A book I could find that might help?” you ask, eager to contribute.
Renjun stretches, glancing around the room for his coffee cup. “No, it’s getting late. It’s probably best if you go home and get some rest.”
You shake your head stubbornly. No way are you leaving after all the progress you’ve made today. You’re in apprentice mode now, and he wants to send you away? Not happening.
“I’m not tired. I want to help,” you insist.
Renjun sighs, but his brows furrow in thought.
“What is it? Did you just think of something?” you press.
Renjun groans softly. “Please. It's nothing,” he mutters, dismissive.
“Tell me what it was!” you whine, stepping closer.
He rakes a hand down his face, clearly torn.
“The potion should be stable enough for a test trial. If I can see how it reacts in a subject, I can tweak it accordingly,” he finally says, voice quieter.
A smile spreads across your face. “Okay, well, obviously I’ll be your guinea pig,” you say excitedly.
“It’s too dangerous,” Renjun replies firmly. “I’d rather spend a few more days searching for the right spell book and making sure it’s right.”
“Jun, we can’t afford to wait,” you argue. “I need this potion now! You’re smart and I trust you. We can do some trial and error.”
Renjun’s expression shifts from curiosity to stern resolve. “No,” he says firmly. “Go home, get some rest. We’ll figure out another way tomorrow.” He begins tidying up the mess.
Frustration bubbles up inside you. “No,” you state, voice steady, and walk over to the countertop where Renjun was mixing the potion earlier. Without hesitation, you snatch up the flask and take a huge swig. Almost immediately, your face contorts as you cough and retch from the bitter taste.
Renjun whips around, eyes wide with alarm. “Are you kidding me?! Have you gone mad?” His gaze sharpens as he notices your eyes suddenly glossing over.
Renjun walks up to you, grabbing your shoulders. “How do you feel?” he asks, his voice steady and attentive.
“I feel fine,” you say, voice slightly hoarse, “aside from my tongue still recovering from that assault.” Then, locking eyes with Renjun, you add playfully, “Maybe a taste of you could wash it down.”
He freezes, caught off guard by your sudden shift in character.
Renjun quickly clears his throat. “Okay, so… it makes you more flirtatious. Noted,” he says, hurriedly grabbing a notebook.
“Describe your feelings for me,” he says like a scholar on the verge of a breakthrough.
The words spill out of you, straight from the depths of your heart without hesitation. “My feelings for you burn hot. It’s almost like it’s not just a feeling but a state of being. Every fiber, every atom tingles at the thought of you. It’s like you’ve become a part of me. Something I can’t live without.”
Renjun’s eyes flicker with a hint of nervousness at your last words, silently praying obsession isn’t taking hold.
“Describe how you’d feel if you had to live without me,” he prompts.
You hesitate, then answer honestly. “It’s hard to imagine, but I think it would feel like an emptiness that could never be filled. If I had to live without you, it would be cold, lonely, and bleak. But… I think the memories we share would keep me going, warming me through the worst times.”
Renjun nods, scribbling furiously in his notebook. Relief washes over his face, and he sighs quietly. Good, obsession avoided.
“Good,” he murmurs. “Now, how does it feel when you look at me.”
“I don’t want to ever take my eyes off you,” you say softly, voice trembling slightly. “When I look at you, I feel alive. Hungry.” Your eyes lock onto his, breath growing ragged.
“Lust,” Renjun notes, his focus returning as he becomes lost in his own world, watching you carefully. Lust wasn’t an abnormal side effect, but since this wasn’t a lust potion, only a measured amount should surface.
You can’t stand the distance anymore. Without thinking, you step closer, craving intimacy.
“What about when you touch me, Renjun? Want to know how I feel when you touch me? Want me to describe it?” you whisper breathlessly.
Renjun’s cheeks flush crimson as he hurriedly scribbles in his notebook. “Loooots of lust,” he mutters under his breath, his voice strained. He clears his throat. “No, no, that’s enough. That concludes the questions. I think I know what I need to tweak in the potion.”
Renjun scurries back to the counter, beginning to work on a new batch.
You watch him from behind, a faint smile tugging at your lips. Stepping closer, you run a hand down his arm, feeling the heat radiating from him.
"I get so wet when you touch me, Renjun. Remember that time you saw me naked? You had gotten so shy and your hands got all clammy, and they trembled. Did you really think I didn't notice?” You lean in, your chest pressing against his arm, and whisper into his ear, "Your hands were on my hips. It was the first time I felt your touch on my bare skin. Your hands, they're strong and capable. I can't help but imagine them exploring every inch of my body. I want to feel them on me again, Renjun. I want to feel them everywhere."
Renjun freezes, his eyes widening as he glances back at you, clearly caught off guard by your bold admission. His cheeks flush a deeper shade of red, and he swallows hard, trying to regain his composure.
"Uh, I… I'll, uh, keep that in mind while I work on the, uh, next batch," he stammers, turning back to his potion-making, his hands noticeably less steady than before.
You could feel the temperature of your body heat up and the thought of Renjun touching you again had your panties soaked. He was so close, and he smelled incredible. His scent was warm, earthy, with a hint of something citrusy. God, you just wanted him to touch you. His hands kept moving, though, a blur of motion as he worked desperately on a new potion.
“Renjun, please,” you beg softly, voice trembling. “Look at me, just for a second.”
He ignores your plea, his attention still fully absorbed in his work, hands flying to find the right ingredients and notes.
Frustration and longing swell inside you. Without thinking, you reach out and grab his hands, feeling an immediate sense of calm wash over you. He finally stops, eyes meeting yours, and in that moment, you feel complete again. Gently, you guide his hand to cup your cheek, closing your eyes and leaning into his touch, savoring the warmth.
Renjun inhales deeply, and you open your eyes to find him gazing at you with a mixture of affection and restraint. His thumb brushes softly against your cheek, and his voice is soothing, almost like a whisper.
“I’m sorry I haven’t been giving you enough attention,” he murmurs, swallowing hard. “Baby… I need to finish this. Can you sit over there and be a good girl for me? I’m almost done, and I promise I’ll give you whatever you want.”
You consider his words, then smile softly. “Okay,” you reply, leaning in to plant a quick kiss on his cheek. Renjun has to collect himself again before he can continue, steadying his nerves. You turn and make your way to the couch.
After a few more tense minutes, Renjun finally joins you on the couch, a new potion in hand. Beads of sweat glisten on his forehead, proof of his labor.
“It’s done. Open your mouth. Drink,” he commands, his tone firm but tired.
You shake your head stubbornly, crossing your arms.
Renjun sighs in exasperation. “What now? What’s the matter this time?”
“It tastes yucky. That taste is so bad I think I might die if I have to drink it again,” you reply, pouting.
“You’re being dramatic. Stop acting like a child and open your mouth,” he says, growing impatient.
You stand your ground, lips pressed into a tight line.
Renjun clicks his tongue in frustration. “Fine.”
Without further ado, he downs the potion in one swift motion, then leans toward you. Your mouth opens slightly in surprise, but before you can react, Renjun presses his lips to yours. His lips feel electric, a jolt of sensation that makes your entire body tingle. So distracted by the kiss, you don’t notice him slipping the potion into your mouth, transferring it from his tongue to yours.
The raging fire inside you is subdued into something much more manageable. Instead of the sinful desire that had pooled within, you feel butterflies fluttering in your gut.
Renjun had successfully administered the new potion, but neither of you pulled away. Your lips remained pressed together, lingering until you both ran out of breath. You licked into his mouth under the guise of getting every last drop of the potion before pulling away.
Renjun’s lips were swollen and red, a faint pink blush dusting his cheeks. He looked flustered, eyes darting nervously. “Um you should feel fine now. What I gave you was actually an antidote. I don’t think we need to test out the new potion since it only requires a slight change. I can take it to my mentor to have him inspect it before we give it to Jiwon,” he rambled breathlessly, clearly overwhelmed and trying to distract himself from the lingering tension.
The fog in your mind finally lifted, but your heart was still pounding wildly. Your face was probably as hot as Renjun’s, eyes wide and doe-like as you stared back at him, struggling to find your words. Stammering, you managed to say, “Right, uh, I’m kind of tired now. I think it’s time I go home.”
“Do you need me to walk you?”
“I’ll be fine. Good night, Renjun,” you said hurriedly before leaving.
⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺⁺‧₊˚ ཐི⋆♱⋆ཋྀ ˚₊‧⁺
It's been a few weeks since you last saw Renjun. Halloween had already passed, and Jiwon and Jiwoo were still rock solid. Renjun had convinced Jiwoo to bring Jiwon in for a couples tarot card reading. That day, he served them tea and slipped the potion into Jiwon’s drink. He made sure Jiwon drank it and called them in a few more times under the guise of couples palm readings or fortune-telling, just to keep an eye on Jiwon for any negative effects. Renjun had been keeping you updated via text but hadn’t made any effort to see you in person.
It shouldn’t upset you, but it does. These lingering feelings have been driving you crazy. All you wanted was to forget about that stupid Etsy witch, but you couldn’t. It was like he was crawling under your skin, like an itch you couldn’t scratch until you saw him. Yet, you didn’t want to see him, afraid of what you might do. You missed him so badly it hurt, but you convinced yourself it was just the lingering effect of that love spell.
Besides, a wise woman once told you that to get over one guy, you have to get under another.
Come over
You send the text to Jaemin, and within the hour, he’s knocking at your door.
He walks in quickly, and the first thing out of his mouth is an apology. “I'm so sorry. I didn’t mean to hurt you or lead you on. I really do like you a lot, and I’ll do anything to fix this,” he says sincerely.
You hear his words, expecting them to bring relief or hope, but they don't.
You’re confused by the lack of emotion you feel toward Jaemin. Experimentally, you reach out and pull him into a kiss.
But it feels wrong.
When Jaemin’s lips meet yours, a wave of discomfort washes over you. His hands move to touch your waist, but it only makes things worse. The moment felt awkward.
You pull away in frustration. That stupid Etsy witch has been stirring up trouble all month. It had to be his fault. Jaemin is right here, begging you to take him back. You’ve wanted this moment for weeks, the chance to finally have him in your arms again.
Yet… you feel nothing.
This isn’t what you’re supposed to feel. Jaemin was the one you wanted so why does your body crave Renjun’s touch instead? Why does your heart feel like it can only beat for him?
“I'm sorry, Jaemin. I can’t do this,” you whisper, your voice trembling.
He looks at you, a hint of hurt flickering across his face. “Do you really still not believe me?” he asks softly.
You take a deep breath, trying to steady yourself. “I believe you. It’s just… I can’t do this right now. I need some time for myself, okay?”
Jaemin’s shoulders slump, and his expression falls, but he doesn’t argue. He never would fight for you. Instead, he leans in gently, presses a tender kiss to your cheek, and quietly turns to leave.
Renjun
You had to find Renjun. Something wasn't right, and that antidote he made clearly wasn’t working.
You’d grown tired of coming to his condo like this, stomping down the hall in frustration. But this time, you told yourself, would be the last.
You bang on his door for the umpteenth time this month, your patience wearing thin. Almost immediately, he opens it, already expecting you—the only one brave enough to show up late at night and make this much noise.
“Do you know how many noise complaints I’ve gotten this month because of you?” he starts, annoyance evident in his tone.
Without waiting, you push past him into his apartment, matching his fire. “Probably as many problems you’ve caused in my life this month,” you spit back, voice sharp with anger.
Renjun groans and runs a hand down his face, frustration mounting. He then folds his arms across his chest and leans back against the wall, knowing how you get and waiting for you to get whatever it was off your chest.
You take in his appearance. His hair is slightly disheveled, probably from the sleep you likely woke him from. He’s wearing a big white T-shirt and baggy sweats. The tired look in his eyes makes him appear so incredibly attractive, only fueling your frustration and driving you up a wall.
“What issues are you bringing to my doorstep today, sunshine?” he asks, with a sarcastic smile.
“You,” you manage to say, trying to catch your breath. You reach out and grab him by the front of his collar. “Fix,” you breathe heavily. “This.” You gesture between both of you.
He quirks an eyebrow. “And what is ‘this’ that you speak of?”
“Your love potion! The antidote isn’t working or something. I’m still having side effects,” you say, frustration evident in your voice.
“Side effects, like?” he prompts, leaning in slightly to get a closer look at you, and you have to summon all your restraint to resist the urge to close the gap between you.
“I miss you like crazy. I can’t think straight when you’re not around. All I can think about is you,” you blurt out in exasperation.
Renjun lets out a breathless chuckle.
“What’s so funny?” you say, unamused.
“Any side effects from the potion should have worn off weeks ago,” he states calmly, almost clinical.
“Then the antidote didn’t work. Make a new one!” you demand, your voice sharp with impatience.
Renjun steps closer to you and shakes his head. “No,” he says softly.
“No? So you're just going to leave me like this?” you ask in shock.
Renjun smiles and laughs, a sound so pure and genuine that you realize you’ve probably never heard him laugh like this before.
“You're not under any spell, sunshine,” he states smugly. “You just fell in love with me for real.”
Your face heats up, and you shake your head desperately.
“You’re wrong!”
“If I’m wrong, then describe how you feel about me right now,” he challenges, a mischievous glint in his eyes.
“I feel like hitting you because you're not listening,” you snap. “You're impossible and mega annoying.”
Renjun chuckles. “Would someone under a love spell call me mega annoying?”
You groan and pull at your hair in frustration. “You made me fall in love with you. Do something about it,” you plead.
Renjun finally decides to stop teasing you and give in. “I missed you too, and you're right. I am mega annoying, but I’ll make it better.”
He leans in and connects your lips.
This is what you had been needing. You feel all the stress that had been built up inside of you melt away. The feeling of his breath against your skin, the warmth of his arms wrapped around you. You longed to be closer, to be in his skin. You wondered if Renjun had a spell for that.
You settle for pulling his shirt over his head, and he quickly catches on, helping you out of yours.
He pulls you into another kiss and begins walking you back toward the couch. His living room is a mess with books strewn across the coffee table, some even open and sprawled out on the floor. It looks like he’s been deep in a new craft or experiment. The place is dimly lit, with only the moonlight pouring in through the huge floor-to-ceiling window and a single candle flickers nearby, its flame dancing softly on dripping wax, as if it’s been burning for hours
As you blindly shuffle backwards your heel catches on something, probably a stray book or a pile of papers, and you stumble, pulling Renjun down with you. You both land in a tangled heap of limbs, and you can’t help but chuckle as you reach behind you and pull out a book that had been digging into your shoulder.
“Jeez, Jun,” you manage between laughs, “what have you been studying?”
Renjun pushes himself onto his forearms, a proud smile spreading across his face. “I’ve been trying to see if I can tweak that love spell I gave Jiwoo. Maybe dilute the effects just enough to nudge someone in the right direction, letting nature do the rest. Something I can mass-produce for my shop so I don’t have to worry about botched spells. It won’t be a perfect love potion, but if the person they’re using it on already likes them even a little, it’ll boost their chances enough to spark something.”
You blink at him, giving him a soft smile. “That’s actually genius.”
Renjun’s chest puffed up with pride. “See? That way, I can finally stop faking my reviews.”
Your eyes widen. “Wait—your reviews were fake this whole time?”
He tilts his head innocently. “Well, yeah. What do you think happens when the guys I pay break up with the girl?”
You shake your head, smirking. “A real witch running a two-star Etsy shop. Guess even magic can’t fix a bad etsy review.”
Renjun’s eyes twinkle mischievously. “Sorcerer,” he corrects. “And you’re right, magic might not fix everything, but deleting reviews can,” he says proudly.
You smile and pull him back into a kiss. “I want to see some real magic,” you tease with a grin.
He leans back down bringing you into another kiss and adjusting himself so he can lay comfortably between your legs. He pulls away from your lips and kisses down your neck and shoulder as his deft hands work to unclip your bra in one swift movement. He leaves wet kisses across your skin, nipping playfully at your chest before licking at your nipple. Your breath hitches and your arch your back into his touch, urging him to give you more.
Renjun is an attentive lover, lavishing attention on both of your nipples. He sucks and bites one, while his hands massage and tease the other. Even if he says the spell wore off you can't help but doubt him because every caress feels almost otherworldly.
Renjun releases your breast, trailing kisses down your stomach. He scratches lightly at your thighs as he pulls down your panties, then settles between your legs.
Eye contact locked, Renjun doesn't look away for a moment. It's intense, and you feel yourself blushing, but you can't look away either. You watch as he licks his lips and leans forward. He laps at you with broad strokes, then focuses on your clit, sucking it into his mouth. You instinctively try to close your legs, but he forces them open, giving you a stern look.
"Keep them open, don't fight me," Renjun commands, his lower face glistening with your arousal. You blush but nod, trying to relax your legs. Renjun returns to his task with renewed fervor, daring you to move even an inch.
Renjun's tongue works expertly, alternating between slow, sensual licks and messy sucks on your clit. You claw at the carpet, trying to stay still as your thighs tremble. Finally, he takes mercy on you and sits up, wiping his mouth.
"You taste so sweet," he murmurs, his eyes heavy with lust and adoration. He pushes down his sweats and boxers, revealing himself to you. Your breath hitches, and you plead, "Please, Jun, fuck me already."
Renjun's smile is wicked and charming, and you have to fight the urge to push him down and take him yourself.
"Oh, I didn't hear a 'please,'" Renjun teases, gripping the base of his cock and teasing your entrance by pushing just the tip inside before pulling up, making it slip out with a pop, making you shiver.
"Fuck, Renjun, PLEASE!" you cry out.
He doesn't answer, just sinks into you, gripping your thighs and pulling them up to your chest to hit deep. The moan that escapes you is sure to get him another noise complaint.
Renjun's eyes flutter closed as he revels in the feeling of you, but they don't stay shut for long. When he opens them, a dangerous determination burns within them, making you brace yourself. His strokes are deep and calculated, making you inch back slightly, but he pulls you right back down with a chuckle.
You're so wet that the sound of your arousal fills the room, and Renjun loves it. He loves seeing how your body responds to him, loves making you feel good. His fingers find your clit, rubbing circles that bring you closer to the edge. Your body tenses, your breath hitches, and the only sounds in the room at that moment are the wet, squelching noises of your orgasm.
You clamp down around him, your legs shaking, tears collecting in your eyes. Still, Renjun doesn't stop, pushing you through the overstimulation.
"Almost, baby. Just a little more, I'm almost there, please," Renjun groans, desperation clear in his voice. He's so close he doesn't want to stop. After a few more harsh thrusts, Renjun's eyes flutter closed, and a raspy moan rips from his throat as he pulls out and finishes on your stomach.
You both catch your breath, your legs finally still. You lie there, motionless, trying to process what just happened and find your footing in reality.
"Wow," you murmur softly, lost in thought about everything that's transpired over the past month. Renjun leaves and returns with a warm cloth, cleaning you up gently.
“Are you okay?” he asks, kissing your forehead.
“You’re amazing,” you reply, making Renjun laugh.
“That’s not exactly what I asked, but I’ll take it,” he says with a smile. “Here, let’s get you to bed.”
He helps you sit up and guides you to his room.
You settle into his sheets and he cuddles up beside you. You have no idea how you’re going to explain all of this to Jiwoo. You never thought you’d believe in magic, and more surprisingly, you never thought you’d believe in love.
Renjun showed you both.














