Rant time!
Probably huge unpopular opinion but I need to vent and it's what I use tumblr for, so-
I am genuinely sorry, but Detroit Become human did not live anywhere near up to my expectations.
I'll even say I am dissapointed.
If you love the game more than life itself, I urge you to NOT read this, becuase you will only get pissed at me, probably, which is dumb to put yourself through.
I do love a lot about it- but there is too much I don’t like about it, and I need to rant becuase I’m sad about it, AND NO- I have not played it with my own two hands, but I have watched and analyzed it several times and this is a review of the story/script, which is key for me in any game. (and this review explains why I’m starting to wonder if I even want the game.)
Here’s also my favorite youtube reviewer, Angry Joe, makes several great points about both gameplay and story- [x]
×SPOILERS AHOY×
I saw the trailer of Kara being put together when it first came out, years ago, and I just... expected something... mindblowing.
Let me also say- Me, personally- fucking love, I live, I thrive off of robots with personaleties. Ever since being a kid, I have such a humongous amount of weakness and love for tech that can talk and feel, just having a mind of it's own.
Examples of fave little roboes, for good messure;
The cartoon Transformers probably started it off
R2D2, C-3PO, BB8, K-2SO (Star Wars)
Iron giant (1999)
B.E.N (Treasure planet)
Jarvis (Iron man, Marvel)
Sonny (I. Robot)
Baymax (Big Hero 6)
Transendence (2014)
Wall-e, Eve (2008)
Atom (Real Steel, subtle personality)
Literally every little fucker from Tales from the Borderlands (Telltales)
Carl (Meet the Robinson)
Aaaaand those are just from the very top of my head as I'm writing this, there is such a huge amount of robotic and tech-characters and I adore them all.
My point is- put a robot with a mind and personality of its own in anything- and it'll become my favorite character automatically. (huehuehu yes pun)
And so, my expectations for this game might have been unrealisticly sky-high from the get-go, becuase of the pedestals I put robots on, I'm not sure exactly, but In any case-
The dialog is good enough, the graphics are obviously fucking insane- and the characters are a mix of amazing and just... plain confusing- but the story???
Well, I don't know, I was expecting...
Better imagienation, I guess. Not to mention some type of damn red thread?? (-partly a hint to the red ice, wtf was that)
The only thread is Jericho, which, originally starts as a part of Markus story- as some sort of fucking religious awakening for him??
In all honesty, the fastest way to make me lose interest in literally anything- shove some religion into it. And this is even worse becuase they’re suppose to be freaking robots. Being spiritual? Sure! They seem to have souls, so that makes sense! But straight-up full-on religious all of a sudden???
The whole rA9 thing????? What??WhY
The fact that he became a goddamn massia of some kind, is just??? dumb??? He ressurected like some damn Jesus and saved his people like Mose, but the androids basically moved from being slaves of the humans to being slaves of Markus. There was no way for me to actually trust that every individual android just gained free-will becuase Markus layed a hand on them???
And there’s the damn Lucy-bot who’s a damn oracle of some kind????wAT
He could’ve had a similar story without having it being so... religious.
And who the fuck is North and why does she have a romance option??? She’s so fucking violent- she responds so easily to hurt humans instead of being peaceful and why would Markus relate to that and like her?? Sure, you can choose for Markus to be violent as well but that doesn’t make sense becuase Carl taught him to fucking chill and treated him well-WHICH ALSO makes it odd that Markus, of all androids, should be the leader of an android-freedom revolution??
I cannot be the only one confused about it??
Yes sure- He learned about empathy, so even tho he had it good with his owner, he was quickly shoved in the garbage and then he felt that his fellow androids were treated like shit and they all needed to be free. STILL doesn’t explain how he got out of that garbage as if he knew exactly what to do. He should’ve stumbled around like bambi on ice, confused and upset.
SO, The whole revolution thing, It's simply a concept that doesn't hold up, not on this type of platform anyway, not in a three-parted story. The pacing goes to shit becuase of it and if I expected anything- I expected a lot of logic in this game.
I was expecting a lot more human-android interaction, but all I get is android vs humans.
The best part is definitely Connor's story. (I do love me that boidroid, very much) He has character development that makes sense- for the most part- and the whole concept of androids joining the force is logical, not exactly original, to have a type of super-human on the side of the police, but atleast it made sense. And also- in this part I did get consistent human-android interaction.
The only one.
And yet- that’s mostly provided that you don't actually die as Connor, becuase he resets as a new copy, which is cool as a gameplay but it fucks up the realistic pacing if you want a friendship with Hank. (yes I'm bitter)
Connor is also the only one who acts like a robot-that is becoming human. This is still testing the limist, as he has potential to die in every damn sequence.
Markus is starting off pretty good, but it’s like he’s becoming more robotic instead? Is it suppose to be a war-thing? becuase it’s not believeble.
And Kara, to me, just feels like a very awkward jittery human. I can’t really find her droid-yness.
Kara I feel like, she was all over the place, I can't even...
I don't even know where to start, her story had pretty good pacing I guess... kind of... sort of... almost. I don't know, Luther was amazing, but he seemed so random, I don’t know why. BUT GUESS WHAT?? THE ONLY FEMALE LEAD WANT TO BE A MOTHER??? Come the fuck on, are you fucking kidding me- I assume they wanted to appeal “to the most human part of a woman” for a female android, but it’s just bad imagienation for me.
I mean, Alice is adoreble but, why would she not even know she’s an adroid and fucking TELL KARA???
And please, for the love of games- I can’t be the only one who immedietly thought about Madison from Heavy rain in the creepy phsyco’s house when Kara went to Zlatko?
Quantic dream really love to put women in a creepy-fucker situation, don’t they. (even starting too seem unoriginal, innit?)
-
Alright so, if you read this and hate me- well, I warned you. If you read this and see what I mean, thank you! I love not feeling alone!
Thank you for reading!
I hope I didn’t steal too much if your time!
-
There are probably some points that I have missed but these are the most frequantly coming to mind.
DBH, My summery-
Superb desgin
Insane and amazing multi-ending concept
Bad imagienation
I love Chloe, the main menu lady, so much.














