Ramblings on Trad Craft/"Cochrane's Craft", The Clan of Tubal Cain, and Shani Oates
I am so ready to break out of posting "witchcraft 101" content and moving on to more esoteric/occult-related topics. More specifically, I want to start sharing more about all the deep-dives I find myself in these days. So, here are some ramblings about Robert Cochrane, Shani Oates, and "traditional witchcraft" (Cochrane's Craft).
I've been reading a lot on trad craft (Cochrane's Craft) lately, and digging deep into some academic articles and arguments about what trad craft really is about. Some folks argue that it's Wiccan, or a Wiccan offshoot, but others (namely, Shani Oates) argue that it's a more gnostic, Luciferian practice.
My theory? Cochrane wanted people to *believe* that it was more esoteric/gnostic in nature, when in reality, he and his coven practiced something more akin to Wicca behind closed doors. This would make sense considering he bashed Wicca and Gerald Gardner so hard in the past; he would be embarrassed to admit that 90% of his craft came from Wicca.
It's either that, or, Shani Oates highjacked the whole thing and is trying to spin it into something that it never was. To my knowledge, she's the only one purporting the idea that Cochrane's Craft couldn't be further from Wiccan ideology - which is also a valid theory, considering most of her works and writings are almost incoherent babblings where she tries to sound as sophisticated as possible. I can tell she uses a thesaurus religiously. Not to mention her ideas seem to be very influenced by apocalyptic, almost right-wing conspiracy theories. Trying to read through Tubelo's Green Fire is very difficult - I'm only about 20 pages in, but I have to constantly go back to reference other materials just to figure out what she's talking about. She claims a lot of historical "evidence" that tie into traditional witchcraft's beliefs/practices, but... no sources are cited, and half the time the language she uses makes it literally impossible to Google and figure out what she's referring to.
A few months ago, when I was barely getting into trad craft, I actually communicated with Shani directly - and she really tore into one of the main books that *she* contributed to about the subject (Genuine Witchcraft is Explained). She claimed that the other contributors completely high-jacked her work, took things out of context, etc. And then went on to advertise me her own books that she authored herself. A bit odd in my opinion, but, nonetheless, I am trying to get my hands on a copy of Genuine Witchcraft is Explained, but it runs about $200 on eBay and it's out of print. So we'll see how that goes.
Anyway, if you enjoy reading my occult/esoteric content and would like to see more of it, consider supporting my Patreon. Funds from Patreon help me purchase books and materials, and allow me to spend more time reading and researching.














