Hey babes! I saw you were taking request and I was hoping I could put one in! I was thinking a Billy x slasher!reader x Stu if possible where the reader is a huge horror fan and wouldn’t say it out loud but finds Ghostface cool and inspired them to go a little mad themselves.
Maybe the reader has been friends with the two for a while and is into both of them but has no idea that they’re ghostface and end up at the same house as them or something for a kill? Fluff and some smut if you’re comfortable with that, but if not that’s okay too! Whatever you imagine the scenario to be is fine honestly, and I’m sure it’ll be great! :))
Tripple
warnings: smut ofc!, threesome, facial, cum play, unprotected sex, murder, and cheating.
Criticism is appreciated! I would love to know how I can improve on my writing.
A/N: I'm so sorry for the wait! It took me a while trying to plan out how to write this one but I hope u enjoy :)
Billy Loomis x fem!reader x Stu Macher
Navigation
Request page
Masterlist
Scream Masterlist
Most recent fic
Written: May 24th, 2025- June 22nd, 2025
Published: June 22nd, 2025
Summary: Someone takes over your first kill..which leads to something steamy.
wc: 3,387
“Oh come on! You don’t even think it’s a little cool?” I said to Sid as she shook her head. “There’s nothing cool about killing innocent people, Y/N.” Sid stated as she was throwing her lunch tray away. I rolled my eyes before responding. “Casey Becker wasn’t all that innocent, Sid. She cheated on Stu and he’s our best friend.”
Sid paused for a second before answering. “Well- Yeah, but she didn’t deserved to be gutted and stabbed.” She lowly said. I mean..I guess Sid’s right, but Casey has always been a total bitch to everyone since elementary school, so I’d say it’s deserve. “Enough about Casey, you wanna have a movie night, tonight?! We could have horror movie marathon! Tatum could come too!” I cheerfully asked. I LOVE horror movies, they just speak to me. There’s just something about the gore, the blood, the killing, and the hope the main character has right before they’re about to die.
“Totally! But how about something a bit more tame? We could watch Clueless!” Sid suggested. I groaned in annoyance. “Fine, I guess.” Sid grabbed my arm practically dragging me outside to the front of the school with a smile on her face. “Oh don’t be such a Debbie downer!” She teased. I ignored her and was looking around until I saw Billy, Stu, Tatum, and Randy all sitting down on the water fountain. We walked over to the and sat down with them. Sid sat on the end of Billy, I sat in between Billy and Stu, and Tatum sat on the other side of Stu, and Randy sat next to Tatum.
“So, you guys hear about Casey Becker?” Randy asked me and Sid as we were walking up. “Yeah, she was completely gutted open.” I said as I reached over to take a grape. “How do you..gut someone?” Sidney hesitantly asked as we all looked over at her. “You take a knife..and you slit em from groin to sternum.” Stu started off as Billy questionably stared at him.
I was intrigued on where this conversation was going. Stu doesn’t even know he’s giving me tips on how to murder my next victim. “-Hey! It’s called tact, you fuck rag.” Billy rudely said to Stu as he cut him off. I raised a brow and looked over to Billy as he smirked. “What was that look?” Billy teasingly asked as my body began to run cold. Shit! I looked too interested.
“What do you mean?” I asked as all eyes were on me now. “You seem oddly curious about this subject, your whole face lit up when Stu was explaining on how to gut someone.” Billy said with a smirk as Sidney slapped his arm. “Leave her alone, Billy.” Sid groaned. “Classic horror trope!” Randy butted in as Tatum was still munching on her grapes. “Blame it on another person to draw suspicion from yourself! Stu’s obviously the killer, he just explained how to gut someone!” Randy finished. I mean..Randy’s not wrong. How did Stu know about that? Did he have experience?
Billy threw a rock at Randy and Randy then winced in pain. I was trying my best to contain my laughter, so was Tatum. “Hey, didn’t you used to date Casey Becker?” Sid asked Stu as he looked almost like he was offended she would even say something like that. “Yeah for like two seconds!” He nervously said as Tatum side eyed him. “Before she dumped you for Steve!” Randy added as Tatum’s eyes widened at the statement. “I thought you dumped her for me?” Tatum questioned Stu while he looked over at Randy with a death glare. This got messy fast.
“Yeah I did, he’s full of shit.” Stu said, referring to Randy. “Are the police aware you dated the victim?” Randy said with a different voice. He was clearly getting under Stu’s skin. “What are you saying? That I killed her?” Stu asked as my eyes widened. I mean that would be a pretty good motive. Stu was known to have a very fragile ego, especially when it came to girls. I couldn’t help but to look over at Billy, he’s been real quiet since the whole exchange..was he hiding something? It was hard to read his face but I could definitely see he wanted Stu to shut the fuck up. “Well it would certainly improve your high school Q.” Randy teasingly smiled as he chomped on a grape.
(it means popularity, I finally looked up what it means lmaoo) “Stu was with me last night, okay?” Tatum said in a tone in which we all know what she meant by that. “Yeah I was.” Stu said with a smirk. My heart tugged a little. I know it’s wrong, Tatum and Sid are my best friends and I like their boyfriends. Well- I’ve always had a crush on Billy, since our elementary days. He asked me to be his girlfriend last year but I told him no. I had a lot going on with my parents divorcing and everything, I wouldn’t have had enough time for him.
And two weeks after that…he asked Sid out. She doesn’t know about it though. Billy and I’ve kissed once but that was before he was with Sid. Stu on the other hand has always been flirtatious with me but toned it down when he got with Tatum. He’s squeezed my ass a couple of times and I always pretended like I didn’t feel it.
“Enough talk about this, it’s grossing me out!” Sid said as she had a disgusting look on her face and was rubbing her arm. Now was my moment to ask Tatum if she wanted to come over tonight. “Tatum, me and Sid are having horror movie marathon, wanna come?” I happily asked as she responded. “Oh my goodness! Yes! I’ll bring the snacks once I’m done with practice.” She agreed. “Since when did you like horror movies?” Billy asked as he nudged my arm. “I’ve always liked horror movies!” I replied. “What’s your favorite scary movie?” Stu asked as he stole some of Randy’s grapes. “Slashers. I don’t care too much for plots. I love blood baths and gore!” I enthusiastically said. “So gross.” Sid said as she shook her head.
“Why don’t we come over and watch too?” Billy suggested as Randy spoke up. “And be in the same room as the killer?! I think not!” I giggled at Randy’s dramatic expression. “No one was inviting you, cum rag.” Billy said as threw another rock at Randy. “Guys chill out. If y’all keep it up then y’all won’t be invited.” I firmly stated. “Fine!” Billy said as he moved his arms into a surrendering position. … School was finally over and I could now go through with my plan. I planned it a couple of weeks ago but I just didn’t have the right moment to strike..but with the recent murder in town, nows my opportunity. I’m gonna kill Principal Himbry. I chose him because he was an easy target, no one in town is gonna care about a dead high school principal. I waited for at least 30 minutes before the building was cleared out. There was only a handful of teachers, a custodian, and Principal Himbry.
I was in the bathroom and changed into my black cloak and ghost mask. I dumped my bag outside the bathroom window so I can hurry out the building and change back. Before walking out the girls bathroom, I looked both ways and didn’t see anyone so I ran for it. I was now in Principal Himbry’s office and there was no one in there, it was very silent. I held my kitchen knife up in one hand while I touched the trinkets on his desk with my other hand. As I was looking at more stuff in his office, I heard footsteps so I hurried and hid behind one of his cabinets.
He walked into the room and grabbed the exact same mask I had on from his closet. What the fuck? I saw him making scary faces in the mirror with it on and just playing around. And then it hit me, this was the mask that one of the boys from earlier had on in the hallway when he was running around screaming at people. As he was still distracted by himself in the mirror, I ran quickly but quietly across the room to the connecting office and ran back outside. As I was now in the hallway, I knocked on his door and hurried and ran to hide behind the coat rack in the hallway. He opened the door trying to see who was there but once he didn’t get a response he went back into his office.
I then ran back to the connecting office and peaked inside Principal Himbry’s office before going in and saw that he was staring at himself in the mirror again. I hid myself behind his desk waiting for the perfect moment to strike but that’s when I heard a knock on his door. What the fuck? He opened it and that’s when someone came through the door and started stabbing him over and over with a kitchen knife.
I stood up from behind the desk to make my presence known. After the person got done stabbing Principal Himbry, they looked up at me with their head turned. I couldn’t see their face due to the ghost mask covering it…the same mask and cloak I had on right now. “Who are you?” I said with the voice modifier covering my true voice. “Who the hell are you?” The person asked back with the same voice my modifier had.
“I asked first! And you took my kill!” I argued as the mask voice chuckled. “It’s not funny!” I stated before the masked person came face to face with me. Before I knew it, they were gripping my throat as tightly as possible. “You have five seconds to tell me who you are or God so help me I will slit your throat!” The person sternly said. My body trembled with fear, I’m supposed to be putting this fear into others, not the other way around.
I took my mask off my face, revealing who I truly was. The man tilted his head before saying my name. “Y/N?” He said, almost as if it was a question. “You next.” I choked out due to his hand still being wrapped around my throat. He took his mask off revealing to himself and I gasped with wide eyes. “Billy?!” I said with shock. And that’s when it hit me, he’s the one that killed Casey Becker. “You killed Casey Becker?” I questioned. I already knew the answer but I just wanted confirmation.
“I had a little help.” He smirked. “Who are you gonna kill next?” I hesitantly asked. “Ya know..I always thought you were hot but, this whole psycho murder act you got going on makes you even more hotter.” He teased as he moved some of my hair out of my face. “You can’t say that Billy..” I whispered. “Yeah? And why not?” He said as his lips hovered over mines. I wanted to kiss him so bad but he’s dating my best friend. I can’t betray her like that.
“Because you’re dating Sidney.” I lowly said as a tear fell down my cheek. He scoffed before replying to me. “You think I give a fuck about her?” He started off as my eyes grew with confusion. “You’re the one I wanted Y/N! Ever since 8th grade I’ve had a crush on you, I only got with Sid to get closer to you, can’t you see that?” He finished. His eyes were filled with sadness and desperation..I felt bad for him.
And I’d be lying if I said I didn’t have feelings for him, truth is I wanted him too. I told Sid I had a crush on him but she still pursued him anyways, it broke my heart in a way and I tried to move on but it still hurts every time I see Billy and Sidney together. “Look me in my eyes and tell me you don’t want this.” Billy begged as he grabbed my hands. I looked everywhere but his face and didn’t speak.
“We can be together, Y/N. Forget about Sidney. I’ve never liked her anyways.” I sternly said. I sighed to myself before bringing him into a passionate kiss. My hands were tangled in his hair and his hands had a tight grip on my waist. When I moaned into the kiss I felt his tongue slip through my mouth and I was loving every bit of it. Billy then lifted me up as my legs were now wrapped around his waist.
“You don’t how many times I’ve dreamed of this.” He groaned as he took the cloak off of me and same with him. Just before we were about to kiss again we heard someone clearing their throat which immediately made us jump. “So this is why it was taking you so long?” Stu asked as he walked into the room. The fuck? “What is he doing here?” I asked Billy. “Remember when I said I had a little help? It’s him.” He answered.
I would’ve never thought for Stu to be a killer. He’s so sweet and silly, how could he be a murderer? But never mind that thought right now. I’m horny as fuck right now and two dicks are better than one. “What’re you still standing over there for, cmon?” I said to Stu as I waved him over. His eyes lit up like a kid in a candy store. Billy looked confused but a hint of amusement on his face.
Stu closed and locked the door and started taking his shirt off as he walked over to us. I was back on the ground now and walked over to Stu bringing him in a kiss. Due to how tall he is, I had to stand on my toes and he had to lean down a bit just to kiss me. I felt his hands slip in between my legs which made me moan into the kiss. I could feel my panties start to dampen and my whole body feel hot. I broke away from the kiss before motioning for Billy to come here. “One in the front, one in that back.” I said with a smirk on my face. Stu giggled before getting out of his pants as I shook my head at him. Billy came up from behind me and started to take my pants off for me. When he took my jeans off, he started rubbing my pussy through my panties and the pleasure felt so good. I had to stop for a second and grab on to his arm.
“I can already feel how wet you are in these panties, pussys soaking for me, ain’t it?” He lowly said in my ear. I moan fell from my mouth as Stu came over to us and spoke up. “Just lookin at her like this is making me hard, fuck!” Stu grunted. Billy’s pace sped up and my knees began to buckle. “You doing so good, baby.” Billy whispered in my ear as I whined in response.
His fingers were moving side to side on clit and just before my orgasm could wash over me, Billy removed his hand from in between my legs. “Why’d you stop?!” I asked. “Cuz I wanna feel you now. Get on your knees.” Billy demanded and I did as so. Billy got behind me and pulled my panties down as Stu stood in front of me and pulled his boxers down.
Billy’s hands were feeling up all over my body as I started to jerk Stu’s dick. His head flew back when I touched his slit and began to spread his precum on the rest of his dick. “Stop teasing would ya?” Stu grunted. I’ve never seen him so desperate before like this. I shoved his cock in my mouth with no warning and he let out a whine. It turned me on even more. There’s just something so sexy about a man whining, especially when you’re the reason.
As I was bobbing my head up and down on his cock, I felt Billy teasing my folds from behind with his cock which made hum on Stu. I could tell the vibrations did something to him because he grabbed the back of my head, shoving his cock deeper in my mouth. I then felt Billy bottom out inside me with a loud groan. “So fucking tight!” He said to himself.
Billy was sliding in and out of me with ease, his dick was hitting all the right spots inside of me. I took Stu out my mouth and started sucking on his balls. “OH FUCK!” he shouted as I giggled. I sucked on them while making eye contact with him. His eyes were dilated and he even shed a few tears. “You suck me so good.” He whined with his eyes closed.
“You should feel her from back here, tightest pussy I’ve ever fucked!” Billy said with a smirk. I squeezed him in response as he sucked in some air. “Shit! Don’t do that!” He before giving a slap to my ass. I moan slipped out my mouth from the slap. I arched my back a bit more and that’s when I felt Billy twitch inside me. “So pretty.” Billy said as he reached down to touch some of the liquids that were falling out of me.
I placed Stu back in my mouth and before I knew he was shouting “I’m cumming! I’m cumming!” He pulled himself out of my mouth and shot his seed all over my face. Leaving it on my cheeks and eyelashes. He whined when he came and it was so hot, I wish I could see him do it one more time for me. He was trying to pump the rest of his seed out on my face and a little more did trickle out of his cock. I then felt Billy cover my mouth with one hand and start to fuck me faster. “You think I’m letting you get away after this? you’re mines now. This pussy is mines.” He sternly said in my ear and that’s when the coil in my stomach snapped.
I came all over but he hurried and pulled out. Billy came on my ass then spreading it around on my lower back and tits. “Who would’ve thought we’d be fucking our friend in a school office?” Stu laughed as I rolled my eyes. My body was so tired that it practically gave out. I was now laying my back on the rug. Stu then came over and started licking his cum off my face with his long tongue. Now I’m wet again. I closed my eyes while he was licking me and he caught me off guard when he brought me into a kiss.
My nails dug in his back while we were kissing and the office was filled with our moans. But then we were rudely interrupted when Billy kicked Stu in his side which made him let out a wince. “Seriously?” Stu said with his hands raised in confusion. “Stop being horny for one second, would ya?” Billy stated as Stu rolled his eyes. I sat up now looking between the both of them.
“We can’t go for round two?” I pouted. “Yeah, cmon on man, I didn’t even get to be inside her yet.” Stu complained as his hand gripped my inner thigh. “You two fuck rags can have your round two but I need to ask her a question.” Billy said, referring to me. I nodded my head for him to go on. “Why’d you try to kill him?” He asked, pointing to the dead body across the room. “Cuz he’s an easy target.” I shrugged.
“You think we should have her on our next kill?” Billy asked Stu. “I think she’d be a great addition.” Stu responded as I smiled. “Who’s are next victim?” I questioned. They both paused and looked at me with a sinister look.
Billy finally spoke up.
“Sidney.”