I've been thinking about the the whole nobles plotline that went nowhere. Is it maybe the case that the Reiss family lied to the nobility about them being immune from memory manipulation? Given how strict Reiss was with the Ackermans and Asians, why leave such loose ends at all? If the nobility did have memory of the true history of the walls, it seems like at least one would have approached the Survey Corps post-Uprising offering to tell them in exchange for amnesty.
Hello, nonevahed!!!!!
I actually think the nobles plotline regarding Reiss (and those involved) served their purpose well.
The Uprising Arc involved the overthrow of the old government and the unveiling of truth of the problems within the Walls. The fact the nobles couldn't have their memories erased served well to 1. Show how deep it went the Human Corruption; 2. How the power between politics and religion also aligned to work together and put their nation at risk (either with good intentions at their heart or mostly not). It also worked well to show that the Reiss family really persecuted and killed those against them because they couldn't have their memories altered, especially the Ackermans (caps 64, 69).
And while the nobles could really ask for amnesty in exchange for info, I think that - to be fair - the SC and Paradis needed a solid proof to explain what really was happening without bias and most accurately as possible.
The SC had already figured Titans were humans, the Walls were made of them, and an enemy outside the Walls truly wanted them dead; they knew injections and *eating shifters* could turn people into Titans; Erwin, Hanji, Levi and the SC leaders knew their enemies were going to be really extremely difficult, and needed to confirm the extent and the fully true reality - something the nobles couldn't offer properly because they had been isolated with them inside the Walls for 100 years now.
So, imo, the nobles couldn't offer more than scraps of guessing about who was threatening the island, that's it, the whole world hates them. And this has a greater impact with the revelations of the basement and Grisha's journals in a way that is, yes, fantastic and full of despair. Just like we love snk to be 😉 😄
(For those who don't remember, this is the end of the nobles - chapter 70)












