I bring a "Celegorm and Curufin had several good points" kind of vibe to the tale of Beren and Lúthien that JRRT's ghost really doesn't like
"I see there is more unsaid," Finrod answered wryly, "Tell me, cousin, what think you?"
"I am thinking about my brother's back. It is all scars, you know, and they run all the way down to the bone. I was by his side for months, after Fingon Fingolfin's son bore him back from Thangorodrim on an eagle's wings. I heard him cry out in fever, saw the marks of fire-whips and orc-knives, the bones set broken, the skin branded and flayed back," Curufin set his jaw, "O people of Nargothrond, what eagle will come for each of you, if you follow your king to the Iron Hells?"
"I welcomed you in, cousins, when Aglon was taken by flame," Finrod replied, "Tell you me only now, that you are craven against the Shadow?"
"Happily would I spend my life for victory against the Shadow, but that is not what you seek. You seek not to wound the Enemy, nor to free some measure of Beleriand from his grip, but a pretty jewel to sit in Elu Thingol's vaults. A pretty jewel that will buy a princess three score years with her Man. Is that what a life of torment unceasing, for yourself and all your people, is worth to you, cousin?" Curufin said coldly, "So be it. People of Aglon, we ride for Himring at first light tomorrow, for less cheaply are lives spent amidst the ice of the North than in Nargothrond's jeweled caverns."














