I’m not a Vecna apologist and I’m not defending people who are because I understand the sa metaphor but I’m just trying to explain why some people think he could have a redemption arc
I’m assuming the people who want that for him have watched the first shadow. And yeah while show Henry shows no remorse or sympathy, play Henry isn’t actually evil. He starts out being a kid who dreams about killing pets and can’t figure out what’s wrong with him, his mind is corrupted because he’s being possessed by the shadow monster, an evil that exists in dimension x. Which he actually tries to resist until doctor brenner forces him to let it in.
There is a contradiction between the show and the play in that sense. While the play says this evil existed before Henry the show suggests Henry creates the shadow monster in a black widow’s image.
I would say forget the play and focus on the show if the play didn’t play a part in season 5, now I don’t know what to tell you.
They could find a way to explain in season 5 how both of these things make sense at the same time then I’d think a redemption arc might actually be possible.
Not for Vecna, or 001, but for Henry Creel.
The shadow monster would be the show’s villain or even doctor brenner, and those two could never be redeemed. But maybe Henry will free himself from the hold of the evil.
That’s why people want the redemption arc, not because they don’t care about what he did, but because they believe it wasn’t him who did these horrible things.