Welcome to Nightvale - Haven’t gotten caught up, but really enjoyable and absurd.
Kaleidotrope - one season so far *fingers crossed there will be more* adorbale, kinda dorky, sweet fluff bit of a college broadcast show romance, with tropes and a tiny bit of magic. Also Samoas
The Magnus Archives - creepy,eerie, strange stories, underlying plot, The Admiral, it’s all good. (also soul crushing but what else do you expect)
The Bight Sessions - teens with powers plus therapist with ulterior motive.
Limetown - everyone in a research town vanishes, 15 years later, reporter investigates
Archive 81 - haunted creepy thing and tapes
Ars Paradoxica - scientist lady from somewhere in the future 20somethings gets thrown back into 1943...
Remarkable Providences - looking in depth into the Salem witch trials and what actually caused them.
Blackwood Podcast - good but there doesn’t seem to be any sign of a second season, and I felt like there should have been one, so bear that in mind.
Supernatural Sexuality with Dr. Seabrooke - what it says on the tin
Scared to Death - couple relates scary stories sent into them by people. I didn’t mean to get unnerved but they did it without me realizing. Thumbs up!
Tentacles - this seems to be a oneshot done by horror babble from a fictional podcast, but I really loved it so here it is.
A story time, death positive, informative podcast. Quite fun.
The Bridge - a bridge spanning the ocean, mysterious things, a tower, a flower enthusiast...
Full Body Chills - creepy/scary stories (some misses I’ll admit, but others are quite good)
Station Blue - Summer in Antarctica, but scary (not very far in but I’ll admit I’m hooked)
OSP Podcast - first part has them discussing behind the scenes stuff and whatnot on their previous youtube episodes, then they do a q & a (that usually hilariously goes off the rails but is always fun)