TW 5x10: Theo’s incredibly busy timeline - is someone helping?
I felt the need to look closer at the timeline for 5x10 as a result of this conversation. It had already struck me that Theo had a very busy episode with lots of stuff he was doing, both on screen and behind the scenes, and the way the episode was edited Theo is either Barry Allen’s long lost cousin, knows how to disapparte or is surfing the telluric currents like a pro (and according to him he’s a bad skater). I realize the episode took place in the span of a day, but given the editing and sequence of events plus the other characters movement as well, the timeline is questionable at best.
I realize suspenseful editing might be the answer to my confusion. It’s not unheard of to edit scenes together in a way to build the thrill. Or is there a hidden clue here? Did Theo have help? And if so, by whom?
Perhaps some of you can help me out and make sense of it?
The episode starts with Liam, Scott and Theo at Deaton’s where Scott is refusing to give Hayden the bite to try and save her.
Approximately at the same time Stiles’ jeep breaks down, he then throws the wrench.
The sheriff’s station gets the reports about a loping/running creature that they trace to the school.
Meanwhile Melissa has arrived at Deaton’s to help treat Hayden. Liam, Scott and Theo are all there.
We cut to early morning when the sheriff is in his office, pulling open the blinds and then finding the envelop from Melissa with Stiles’ keycard. We can assume he then left to either look for Stiles and/or go back to the crime scene at the school.
We then cut to Scott and Theo talking at Deaton’s. Theo telling Scott he needs his pack and offers to go talk to them. Scott accepts and thanks him.
Theo leaves. This is when he starts all of his manipulative tasks of the day.
Parrish and Lydia is talking in the jail cell.
Scott falls asleep and Liam creeps on him with angry yellow beta eyes.
The jeep is towed, Malia picks up Stiles.
Parrish and Lydia talk some more, Lydia has the epiphany about The Wild Hunt and Lydia leaves for the library.
Back at Deaton’s Hayden is asking for her sister. Scott offers to go find her.
Hayden: My sister... Valerie. She's a deputy.
Scott: I think I might know where she is. Theo just texted me about the high school. He said there's cops everywhere. Might be another Chimera.
Scott leaves for the school since Theo has texted him about cops being there. This would indicate that Theo is or has been at the school - this is possibly where he encountered the sheriff and kidnapped/hurt him.
Stiles and Malia arrive at the sheriff’s station. Malia asks about Donovan. Stiles heads inside the station.
Parrish is having a feverish dream about the nemeton.
A deputy informs Stiles that the sheriff left the scene half an hour ago and was heading back to the station. Stiles waits in his office. Meaning that Theo must have kidnapped the sheriff within the last 30 minutes, or possibly is doing it at this very moment.
Deputy: Sheriff left half an hour ago. He said he was on his way back.
Lydia has arrived at the library and is reading about the hunt. Has a banshee moment and is knocked out by Theo.
So did Theo hurt the sheriff at school, then move him to where Stiles found him and then go back for Lydia only to move her as well? That would take some time. And at the time he knocked out Lydia Scott is already on his way to school. We know there is a 30 minute window before Stiles arrived at the sheriff station that his dad could’ve been taken. And Lydia had already left the station when Stiles arrived. Given that time frame it doesn’t make sense for Theo to leave the school.
So who’s helping him? Or has he just stashed both the sheriff and lydia in his car to drop them off later? Possibly.
But we then cut directly to Malia in the coyote den. Theo tiptoes in and shifts back to human. Offers to teach Malia.
Melissa decides to move Hayden to the hospital.
Theo going to the preserve could of course have have happened hours later. Since Malia had just dropped off Stiles at the sheriff’s station she would need time to get out to the preserve as well.
What is so confusing though is that Scott left Deaton’s office even before Stiles arrived at the station. How long can it possibly take Scott to get from the vet’s to the school?
Scott has now arrived at school and gets a text from Lydia’s phone telling him to go to the library. Lydia is knocked out, she’s not sending any texts. And if we’re to believe that the things we see happens in chronological order then Theo is still in the woods.
It’s implied that Theo sent the text to trap Scott in the library. He’s also had to prep the mountain ash around the entire room. Since Scott will soon find the phone in the library, the logical thing to assume is that Theo is lurking in there already, making sure the ash is in place. But we just saw him in the preserve? what gives?
Next we see Parrish break out of his cell. Stiles follows him.
Then we cut to this. Theo’s still in the woods, tossing a key into the bushes. We cut to a lock on a door in what looks like the hospital.
This will prove to be the tenth chimera, Noah, possibly trapped to occupy Malia later so she can’t help Scott either. Theo has already done this - possibly he found the chimera also at school?
So unless I’ve grossly misinterpreted something Theo has now kidnapped the sheriff, Lydia and captured and locked in a chimera. Lydia and the sheriff can technically still be in his car, but at some point he will need to move them to the DD lab and the other place respectively.
The text from Lydia’s phone could’ve been sent from anywhere. BUT we know that her phone is in the library. If the editing is to be believed Scott got the text while Theo is still in the preserve. And it doesn’t take Scott all that long to get from the hallway and to the library. Theo needs to either travel the currents or disapparate to manage that. Or it’s TV magic.
So, perhaps Theo didn’t send the text. Possibly he knows how to make it look like the text came from Lydia’s phone while actually sending it from his own. Or he has a skilled helper... Or someone else sent it for him..
We then get the scene where Scott finds the phone, and would you look at that. There’s Theo again, making a line of mountain ash.
The rest of the timeline for Theo is less confusing. We next see him tracking down Stiles, making him chose between helping Scott and saving his dad. After that he returns to find that Liam didn’t kill Scott, so he does it himself. And then he makes himself some zombie chimeras.
All in a days work. Very productive guy.
So Is this just confusing editing, or a hint that Theo isn’t operating on his own? I doubt the doctors are helping him. They don’t strike me as the helpful types. Theo did say he was the first success, he didn’t say he was the only one. So is there someone else helping him out?
I’m totally open to me misreading the whole timeline here, and if so please enlighten me. But I find the idea of someone helping him in the shadows oddly appealing.
And am I totally crazy for wanting it to be Danny? Danny who has a medical history, who knows about the supernatural, who I’m sure knew about it from the beginning and seems to have been acting as a sort of watcher from the start, and who was possibly also involved in the deadpool stuff behind the scenes. That operation was just too sophisticated to have been run by a mentally unstable Eichen House patient and a orderly who’s tech skills ended with cassettes/tapes.
Danny who the alpha pack thought was important enough to keep watch on. Who the oni was interested in but left alone, who knows about the telluric currents, and who’s never been confirmed left Beacon Hills or the school.
Or Theo has a twin/clone. Wouldn’t that be a kicker?
Or it’s just another example of anachronism - error in time placement - the show is littered with these little deliberate time conundrums (and the definition was even shown to us in 3x05), so this is hardly the first time.
Let me know what you think :)