All Mine. Shoto Todoroki x Reader Smut
Summary: You've been friends with benefits with top hero Shoto Todoroki for quite a while. In the middle of a particularly delicious intimate hookup, Shoto tells you he doesn't want to be friends with benefits any longer because he's catching feelings. Romance (and amazing sex!) ensues.
Important Notes/TW: All characters are A30+, Aged Up Characters, Explicit Sex, Romance, No Protection, Friends with Benefits to Lovers, MDNI, This is an adult only blog posting mature content
"I'm afraid." Shoto says in that short way of his, mumbling into your ear as he slowly makes love to you. You almost miss the words, too distracted by the gentle, wet drag of his cock inside of you.
"Oh!" You can't help but moan as he picks up the pace a bit, the crown of his dick hitting the most delicious spot inside of you. He recognizes that he's found the ideal angle and rhythm, and he concentrates on replicating the motion as many times as he can. You feel like you've died and gone to heaven, dancing on the edge of orgasm as this beautiful man pleasures you in his bed.
But then your brain finally catches up, processing Shoto's mumbled words from minutes before.
"Wait - ah - Sho, stop."
Shoto's body comes to a hault, and he lifts himself up so he can peer down at your face. "Why do you want to stop?" His voice rumbles, low and uncertain as he searches your expression for clues.
"Why are you afraid?" You ask, raising a delicate hand to cup his cheek. Without thinking, he turns his face to press a chaste kiss to your palm.
"Oh. Well." Shoto gulps as he turns back to face you, his delicate hair falling into his lashes. He's so beautiful, sometimes looking at him like this takes your breath away. His sharp, aristocratic cheekbones are etherial. His cupids bow is the perfect curve - just right for kissing. His mismatched eyes are so unique and eye catching, it's hard to look away once you're locked in his sightline.
"You can tell me, Sho." You say softly. "Like...come on. Your bare dick is literally inside of me right now. I think we've lost all traces of decorum."
Shoto nods thoughtfully, doesn't laugh. That's another thing about this man - he's lacking in the social skills department. Sometimes you need to clearly state that you're joking, or else he'll take every word at face value.
"That was supposed to be funny." You add on, making sure he knows you're teasing.
"Oh. Okay." He didn't get it. But that's alright - at the very least he now knows you're trying to be light hearted with him.
"What's bothering you? What are you afraid of?" You smooth his hair back, and he ever so slightly leans into the touch.
"How long have we been having sex like this?" He asks, eyes fixed on your own. You bite your lip and think.
"Maybe...three months now? Ever since we met at that stupid hero gala honoring Mount Lady's charity for women with bad nose jobs." You wrinkle your own nose as you think about your colleague's ridiculous excuse for philanthropy. "Why?"
Shoto's beautiful face contorts into a frown.
"I'm afraid this is getting to be too much for me." He says flatly.
Your heart instantly sinks into your stomach. Ah, of course. Shoto's bored of you. You knew this friends with benefits situation was always too good to be true. It was only a matter of time before Shoto realized that he's too good for a B-grade underground hero. He's so young - at twenty six years old he's already in the Top 10. You're always under cover, working in the shadows. That means you're not even on the board.
And now Shoto's going to drop you - to leave you for some pretty Top 20 hero like Mount Lady.
You can just see the headlines now - Shoto Todoroki seen with beautiful new girlfriend at Hibachi restaurant. Shoto Todoroki proposes to Pro Hero girlfriend in Paris. Shoto Todoroki and Pro Hero wife are pregnant with first child. You know that each of these inevitable news stories will gut you, no matter how much time has past. This is not a wound that will heal easily. Shoto Todoroki is irreplaceable in your heart. You should have never offered to be friends with benefits in the first place - you knew your poor heart wouldn't be able to survive the inevitable sting of Shoto moving on.
Over the past few months of nonstop fucking, you've fallen for Shoto. You've fallen for him hard. How could you not? He's so fucking thoughtful - always ordering in your favorite takeout after a long day on the job, sneaking you into the back booths of his favorite restaurants to avoid the press when the two of you feel like going out. He's so sweet always inviting you to his friend's houses for parties or movie nights, showing you off as if you're something special to him. And the sex. Oh my God the sex! Shoto's an attentive and dedicated lover, always finding new ways to caress and draw pleasure out of you as if it's your first time together. Each moment your bodies intertwine, things are electric between the two of you.
But you knew this would happen - that you wouldn't be able to keep him. He's just so, so good. And you're just an underground hero with a wanting heart.
Shoto has never been one for babbling, but he doesn't wait for you to reply. He keeps talking. Obviously these thoughts have been bothering him. You just wished he would have waited until after sex to dump you.
He looks down at you sadly. "I don't think I can do this 'friends with benefits' any longer."
You sniffle, trying to keep the tears from leaking. "I understand."
His forehead creases in displeasure, his teeth worrying at his lip for a moment. "You do?"
"Of course. You don't want to sleep with me anymore. And I get it - you're busy and have a lot going on and we agreed from the start that this would be casual, didn't we? So it's fine, Shoto. We can stop seeing each other and just be friends." The words flood out of you in a wave. You know you can't 'just be friends' with him after this. Not after you've known how he feels inside of you, how he kisses...but you need to be nice about this. It's your fault for catching feelings, afterall.
Shoto's frown deepens. "That's not it at all." He says matter of factly. "Of course I want to keep sleeping with you. I'm afraid because I fear I'm developing too many feelings for you and you might not feel the same way. We said we would keep this casual, but I don't think I feel 'casual' about you."
Oh. Oh!
"I don't feel casual about you either." You say in a breathy voice, disbelieving.
Shoto's frown instantly dissolves, his beautiful face smoothing into that gentle smile of his. "Really?"
"Really."
"So...what does that mean?" He asks, cocking his head to the side slightly. He looks like an adorable dog when he does that.
You reach up so you can pull his face to yours in a kiss. He melts against you - lips sliding against yours sweetly. His cock twitches inside of you, instantly rock hard once again and you rock your hips, encouraging him to move. He gets the message and slowly drags his hips back so he can gently move inside of you once more.
You break the kiss and let out a groan of pleasure as he fills you with his cock. He pulls away from you, still smiling.
"I think that means we both want a relationship." You say quietly, smiling back at him. "I think we want to date each other."
"So instead of friends with benefits...I'd be your boyfriend?" He says thoughtfully, a hand moving to smooth over one of your breasts as he shifts inside of you.
"And I'd be your girlfriend." You say, letting out a soft moan as his fingers brush across your pebbled nipple.
"I really like the sound of that." Shoto says, leaning down to press a kiss to your temple as he thrusts deeply inside of you. You're both quiet for a moment, enjoying the sweet sensation of each other's bodies being connected. After a beat, a mischievous smile crosses Shoto's lovely face. "Can your boyfriend make you cum?"
Your heart glows golden inside of your chest, and your pussy flutters around him at the question. "Your girlfriend would like that. Very much."
Shoto's grin makes you giggle as he pulls out of you, placing quick kisses across your chest, your stomach, your thighs, before he tosses your legs over his shoulders and starts eating you out. You let out a string of unladylike expletives as he swirls his tongue through your folds, taking the time to kiss and suck and circle around your clit with gusto.
"Fuck, Sho!" You cry out as you feel yourself getting close. Shoto is the best at oral. You've never had a man eat you out in such an enthusiastic, mind blowing way. "I'm gonna...oh!" Shoto sucks on your clit for a second longer before pulling his face away. You make a disappointed noise as he untangles himself from your legs.
"Don't worry." He chuckles as he rises onto his knees on the bed. "You'll get to cum. I promise."
He grabs you by the hips, flipping you over onto your stomach. He's so strong and built out from his training and hero work, he throws you around like you weigh nothing (which is insane, since you're fairly muscular form your own hero work). You fall easily onto the mattress, crying out in pleasure as Shoto pulls gets you in position so he can take you from behind.
He caresses your pussy with his hardness, swiping his cock through your folds and playing with your clit in a way that has you begging for him to take you. When he finally lines up his cock with your entrance, you hear him let out a soft sigh of satisfaction. He pushes into you slowly, and the sweet stretch of your pussy accommodating him almost makes you cum on the spot. Once he's fully pressed inside, he lets his hands wander to your hips. He starts moving slowly, letting you enjoy every inch of him the way he knows you like.
"Shoto...fuck...Shoto I like you so damn much." You can't help but ramble. At your words, you feel him get impossibly harder. You feel so overstimulated, so good. His hands differ in temperature slightly - the combined warm and cold touch prickling at your senses in the most delicious way. He picks up the pace, groaning as he finds a good rhythm.
"You...are...the best thing that's ever happened to me." Shoto says in a voice that's unusually coated in emotion. His words go straight to your cunt, and you cry out his name over and over as you cum around him, pussy tightening as shocks of pleasure wash over you again and again.
Shoto's not one to curse, but when he feels your pussy flare and pull around him, he can't help himself. "Fuck, Y/N." His orgasm hits him like a wall, and he doesn't remember to pull out. He cums hard, filling you up deliciously with his warm baby batter. It feels so good, so right. You feel tears of pleasure prickle at the corners of your eyes as you come down from your high, body still twitching in ecstasy around a spent Shoto.
You lay together for a few quiet minutes, both of you sweaty and breathing hard as you process what's just happened.
Finally, Shoto speaks.
"I've had feelings for you since the moment our hands touched at that stupid hero gala three months ago. I just didn't get up the courage to say something until today."
You let out a happy laugh. You wonder if he's grinning, too. He slowly pulls out of you, and you feel his thick cum dribbling down your thighs. Fuck, you're going to need to wash the sheets after this. But you don't really care. All you want to do right now is hold Shoto and kiss his sweet, gorgeous face. You turn in the bed so you can face him, body sore from your intense fucking.
Shoto is absolutely beaming, his face radiating joy. He pulls you into his chest, kissing the top of your head as he wraps his strong arms around you in a sweet embrace.
"I've felt exactly the same, Sho." You say, nuzzling into his sweat-slicked chest. "And now we can be together as more than just friends."
Shoto hums happily, holding you to him and placing his chin on top of your head. "I love the sound of that, Y/N." He sighs dreamily, and plants another kiss on the crown of your hair. "I love the idea that you're all mine."




















