Review: The Winnowing by Vikki VanSickle
Genres: Science Fiction, Adventure, Mystery
Add it to your TBR on Goodreads here.
My Goodreads Rating: 4/5 Stars
I received a copy via the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
This review may or may not contain spoilers.
This is a long text post.
The Winnowing by Vikki VanSickle is a Young Adult/Middle Grade novel that features a past where something called "The Winnowing" occurs--which is basically a stripping of night terrors and side-effects that affect a young person once they hit puberty. Though it admittedly took me a while to get into it, I enjoyed VanSickle's writing and loved the adventure aspect of the novel.
I met VanSickle at a blogger/bookseller event a couple of years back and had the pleasure of reading If I had A Gryphon, so I jumped at the opportunity to share her newest story with my friends and followers. Her novel is timely with the revival of several beloved Science Fiction series and television shows from the 80s and 90s. One of the shows most prominent in my mind when I think about this book is Stranger Things, which you should watch if you haven't yet.
Though not a perfect read, The Winnowing was a lot of fun. I think a lot of readers will enjoy Marivic's journey as she discovers who she is and what her role is in her society. The cast of characters is diverse and at times frustrating with how relatable they can be. The setting is darkly unsettling with a dash of naive optimism (this mainly coming from me hoping that some jerk characters learn to not do such mean things).
Marivic, the protagonist, is a young girl who lives with her grandfather and has a seemingly normal life until she wakes up from a nightmare with aching legs and feet. The really cool thing about what happens to the children as they change is how original and unique the whole situation is. I loved that VanSickle played with the fear of sleepwalking and added an extra paranormal twist. If anything, learning more about the abilities and the nightmares was my favourite aspect of this novel. I love books that feature kids with superpowers, especially where the kids are rebelling against a common enemy. I'm always up for reading an origin story.
I loved Marivic's character growth. When we first meet her, she seems like the type of teenage girl who has always been dependent on one person or another, but I loved seeing her learn that she can be independent. She learns that she, by herself, has the power to change her situation rather than just waiting for others to change her world for her. One of the things I liked about Marivic was her dedication to her friendship, even if said friendship was flawed. Despite the problematic nature of some of the relationships in her life, Marivic was always true to the people she loved.
What I wasn't a huge fan of is how Marivic herself is treated by those who care for her. I understand that there is complexity in human relationships because nothing is ever black and white, but I felt really uncomfortable with some of the interactions between certain characters, but especially the bullying. While bullying is a big thing in this age group, I guess the optimist in me hoped for a resolution to that particular issue. Sure, there was some admonishment, but for the most part, the bullies got away with the bullying. Again, I may be the victim of optimism on this topic, or just wishful thinking, but I found that that particular thread was left hanging as Marivic continued her journey.
Though not entirely unpredictable, I did enjoy the twist and turns that VanSickle had in her novel. I was always wondering what would happen next, since by the middle of the book, so many things had changed. I've read some reviews where people have said that this book was a bit spooky or creepy, but I honestly didn't think so. I thought this was just a fun and adventurous read with some dangerous moments that made my heart race just a tad.
Despite the entertaining twists and turns, I found the pacing to be a bit frustrating. Near the beginning, it was a little hard getting into The Winnowing, but when I got about four or five chapters in, I was hooked...until I hit the final four or so chapters. That's where I thought the story dragged a bit.
Honestly? I think The Winnowing would benefit from becoming a series. The resolution was a bit too clean and quick for me. There's definitely room for another book or two exploring this same world (or even a companion novel). I feel like there's still a lot more to be said about the situation and a lot more potential for character growth. If VanSickle does decide to write a sequel or a companion novel, I will be all over it.
If you're a fan of The X-Files and Stranger Things then you might enjoy VanSickle's novel! Also, if you enjoyed The Program by Suzanne Young and other books that feature characters surviving a hospital or institution during an epidemic, then you might also want to pick this one up!